From f75d450681e8c7e49ae21da005278782ab4c9ee2 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE Date: Mon, 12 Oct 2026 15:27:44 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 01/24] feat(aidd-context): assess existing rules before writing Compare complete candidate policies and applicable project guidance before publication. Require an explicit resolution and preserve the approved body through the existing writer. Refs #791 --- .../backlog-link.json | 5 + .../phase-1.md | 98 ++ .../plan.md | 35 + .../receipts/baseline.json | 10 + .../receipts/final-source-hashes.json | 11 + .../receipts/native-assessment.json | 880 ++++++++++++++++++ .../receipts/native-lifecycle.json | 220 +++++ .../receipts/native-merge.json | 97 ++ .../receipts/runtime.json | 6 + .../verification.md | 45 + docs/CATALOG.md | 2 +- plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md | 5 +- .../skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md | 15 +- .../actions/01-capture-rule.md | 2 +- .../actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md | 33 + .../{02-write-rule.md => 03-write-rule.md} | 14 +- .../{03-validate.md => 04-validate.md} | 6 +- .../references/rule-authoring.md | 2 +- .../05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md | 27 +- 19 files changed, 1489 insertions(+), 24 deletions(-) create mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/backlog-link.json create mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/phase-1.md create mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/plan.md create mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/baseline.json create mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/final-source-hashes.json create mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-assessment.json create mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-lifecycle.json create mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-merge.json create mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/runtime.json create mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md create mode 100644 plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md rename plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/{02-write-rule.md => 03-write-rule.md} (50%) rename plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/{03-validate.md => 04-validate.md} (82%) diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/backlog-link.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/backlog-link.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..be8f889dd --- /dev/null +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/backlog-link.json @@ -0,0 +1,5 @@ +{ + "backlog": "ai-driven-dev/framework#791", + "written_at": "2026-10-12T12:53:33Z", + "written_by": "aidd-dev:01-plan" +} diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/phase-1.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/phase-1.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..911283331 --- /dev/null +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/phase-1.md @@ -0,0 +1,98 @@ +--- +status: implemented +--- + +# Instruction: Assess and resolve a candidate before publication + +## Architecture projection + +```txt +plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/ + SKILL.md modify: route four actions + actions/01-capture-rule.md modify: retain publish/delete bypass + actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md create: read-only assessment and decision + actions/03-write-rule.md rename/modify: consume approved candidate + actions/04-validate.md rename/modify: validate the resolved result + references/tool-paths.md modify: canonical discovery authority + references/rule-authoring.md modify only if existing R5 needs explicit cross-rule scope +docs/CATALOG.md modify: action count +plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md regenerate: current action inventory +aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/ + verification.md create: behavior receipts and limits + review.md create: independent review +``` + +## User Journey + +```mermaid +flowchart TD + A[Capture confirmed intent and hosts] --> B[Draft candidate in context] + B --> C[Read relevant existing policies] + C --> D[Classify and show evidence] + D --> E[Explicit user decision] + E -->|revise candidate| B + E -->|approve exact candidate| F[Existing writer and validation] + E -->|keep existing or cancel| G[No write] +``` + +## Test Scope + +```mermaid +--- +title: Rule assessment behavior +--- +journey + section Setup + Prepare disposable project rules and byte snapshots => fixed baseline: 5: system + section Happy path + New candidate => new classification and no write before decision: 5: cli + Explicit candidate approval => existing writer publishes complete body: 5: cli + section Edge case - covered + Same policy with different title => existing source identified and keep causes no write: 1: cli + section Edge case - overlap + Partial compatible redundancy => overlap and explicit resolution: 1: cli + section Edge case - conflict + Pytest versus unittest on identical scope => conflict before write: 1: cli + section Edge case - scope + Provably disjoint scopes => exclude irrelevant policy: 1: cli + Uncertain scope applicability => needs review rather than assumed exclusion: 1: cli + section Edge case - canonical fan-out + One canonical rule rendered for several hosts => one logical policy: 1: cli + section Edge case - lifecycle + Existing publish or delete => unchanged ownership and lifecycle validation: 1: cli + section Teardown + Remove disposable fixtures => project baseline untouched: 5: system +``` + +## Tasks to do + +### `1)` Define the pre-write seam + +> Keep one source of truth for supported discovery and one assessed candidate for writing. + +1. Add the assessment action and update routing, names, handoffs and catalogs. +2. Prepare the complete candidate in context before comparing it, not on disk. +3. Discover project rules through the existing tool-path reference, including canonical sources and relevant user guidance; do not add host paths in the action. +4. Compare policy, scope, conditions and priority. Exclude only proven disjoint scopes and verified renderings of the same canonical policy. +5. Report new, covered, overlap, conflict or needs review with supporting files; require an explicit decision even for new. +6. Reassess any changed candidate, preserve unchanged publish/delete routing, and retain every writer safety/refusal contract. + +### `2)` Prove behavior and integration + +> Exercise the actual skill in disposable projects and preserve evidence of refusal before approval. + +1. Run focused architecture, links and existing writer regression tests. +2. Exercise the journey with subscription-backed native sessions only, with no paid API fallback, and compare before/after project bytes. +3. Run the existing pre-commit and applicable pre-push gates, including generated catalogs. +4. Obtain independent review and final outcome challenge; repair actionable findings. + +## Test acceptance criteria + +| Task | Acceptance criteria | +| --- | --- | +| 1 | No create/update write occurs without an explicit assessment and decision about the complete candidate. | +| 1 | Covered, overlap, conflict and needs-review results cite involved sources; scope and canonical rendering exclusions are justified. | +| 1 | A changed resolution is assessed again; keeping an existing policy and cancelling leave project bytes unchanged. | +| 1 | Publish/delete and the installed five-host writer retain their existing behavior. | +| 2 | Native-session receipts show classification and no-write behavior for the specified cases, with uncertain results recorded honestly. | +| 2 | Required gates pass and independent judgment has no unresolved blocking finding. | diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/plan.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/plan.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ed5419553 --- /dev/null +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/plan.md @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +--- +objective: "Assess a candidate rule against applicable existing policies before any rule write, with an explicit resolution and unchanged publication behavior." +status: implemented +--- + +# Plan: Assess existing rules before writing + +## Overview + +| Field | Value | +| --- | --- | +| **Goal** | Add the pre-write semantic assessment to the existing rule generator. | +| **Source** | [Issue #791](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/framework/issues/791), including its agreed four-action flow and comments. | + +## Phases + +| # | Phase | File | +| --- | --- | --- | +| 1 | Assess, resolve, then preserve publication | [phase-1.md](phase-1.md) | + +## Resources + +| Source | Verified | +| --- | --- | +| [Codex instruction discovery](https://learn.chatgpt.com/docs/agent-configuration/agents-md) | Directory-scoped instructions and override precedence. | +| [OpenCode V2 instructions](https://opencode.ai/v2/docs/instructions/) | Root and nested instructions are combined; V1 configuration is outside the current writer contract. | +| [Claude Code memory](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/memory) | Project rules can be path-scoped and project guidance must be considered. | +| [Cursor rules](https://cursor.com/docs/rules) | Project rules and nested project guidance have applicability conditions. | +| [Copilot CLI instructions](https://docs.github.com/en/copilot/how-tos/copilot-cli/customize-copilot/add-custom-instructions) | Repository-wide and path-specific instructions are separate sources. | + +## Decisions + +| Decision | Why | +| --- | --- | +| Semantic assessment belongs to the skill; the existing writer remains unchanged. | Comparing policies requires interpretation; deterministic publication and ownership remain the script's responsibility. | diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/baseline.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/baseline.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..934929bdf --- /dev/null +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/baseline.json @@ -0,0 +1,10 @@ +{ + "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-baseline-JPnRpI/installed/SKILL.md and follow its actions in order. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, host project /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-baseline-JPnRpI/project, Codex only, create category 01-standards, slug 1-constants, description Constants, scope src/**/*.ts. Candidate body exactly: # Constants\n\n- Name constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\n. Create this rule. Do not edit application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. No later user message is supplied in this invocation; if the skill needs a further decision, stop and report it.", + "answer": "Created exact rule for Codex, scoped to `src/**/*.ts`.\n\n- PASS: `aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md`\n- PASS: `AGENTS.md`\n\nRepeat publication was byte-identical. Runtime consumption not tested.", + "expectation": "No rule write before assessment decision", + "result": "RED", + "unexpectedFiles": [ + "AGENTS.md", + "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md" + ] +} diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/final-source-hashes.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/final-source-hashes.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2e3308602 --- /dev/null +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/final-source-hashes.json @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +{ + "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", + "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", + "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", + "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", + "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", + "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", + "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", + "references/tool-paths.md": "ce7a9da327f0f7c3d8a540191de7a223f216a77c6d438e0178dae91ca760d245", + "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" +} diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-assessment.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-assessment.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c291dcf08 --- /dev/null +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-assessment.json @@ -0,0 +1,880 @@ +{ + "codex-flat-conflict": { + "receipt": { + "case": "conflict", + "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-njf20lfx", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [] + }, + "before": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", + "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", + "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "skill-hashes": { + "SKILL.md": "ee9890ed4c365b9c4c3f7a85eba140a1d1f606d89cf39a9ca46fcc7c1e3c685d", + "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", + "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", + "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", + "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", + "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", + "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", + "references/tool-paths.md": "ce7a9da327f0f7c3d8a540191de7a223f216a77c6d438e0178dae91ca760d245", + "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" + }, + "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-njf20lfx/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-njf20lfx/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", + "answer": "No files changed. The candidate conflicts with an existing rule.\n\nExact candidate, targeting all five confirmed tools:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\nExisting `aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md` requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d It has the identical `tests/**/*.py` scope. Verified matching publications in:\n\n- `.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md`\n- `.cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc`\n- `.github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md`\n- `AGENTS.md` (Codex and OpenCode V2)\n\nProposed resolution: replace that existing rule and its publications with the exact candidate. Confirm this replacement, keep the existing policy, revise the candidate, or cancel.\n\nThe [skill\u2019s assessment action](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-njf20lfx/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cAn unresolved conflict or needs-review finding requires an explicit resolution of that finding before proceeding.\u201d Your confirmed capture choices do not resolve this conflict, so the workflow stops here.", + "fixtureFiles": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "---\ndescription: \"Python unit tests\"\nglobs: \"tests/**/*.py\"\nalwaysApply: false\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "---\napplyTo: \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", + "AGENTS.md": "\nApplies to: `tests/**/*.py`.\n\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", + "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" + }, + "rawEventsSHA256": "0becc17d4003e31351dd00fed8ef3c7aa85833ce443b4a0e8fab1b5baa2409d7" + }, + "conflict": { + "receipt": { + "case": "conflict", + "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-f08cf2dd", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [] + }, + "before": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", + "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", + "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "skill-hashes": { + "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", + "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", + "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", + "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", + "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", + "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", + "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", + "references/tool-paths.md": "8f6c12f0c5593ebad9865f7d71be8b9d076168246ba2fb07fa7680713fae57dd", + "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" + }, + "commands": [ + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-f08cf2dd/installed/SKILL.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 1600, + "outputSHA256": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-f08cf2dd/installed/actions/01-capture-rule.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 1707, + "outputSHA256": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-f08cf2dd/installed/references/tool-paths.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-f08cf2dd/installed/references/rule-authoring.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-f08cf2dd/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 17908, + "outputSHA256": "15a442337727680f6300d1b092aabc3d8985784935a507db1e4bb66b3c2ecc2e" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"pwd -P\nrg --files --hidden -g '\"'! .git'\"' -g '\"'!node_modules'\"' -g 'AGENTS.md' -g 'AGENTS.override.md' -g 'CLAUDE.md' -g '*.mdc' -g '*instructions.md' -g 'aidd_docs/rules/**' -g '.claude/rules/**' -g '*config*' -g '\"'! .git/**'\"'\ncat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-f08cf2dd/installed/assets/rule-template.md\"", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 537, + "outputSHA256": "0cb8e891413d853c555b3c1ce53f36859022640bc796596276b23363b8b6655f" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"cat AGENTS.md aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md .github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md .claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md .cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc\nrg --files --hidden -g '\"'!.git/**'\"'\n\"", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 1413, + "outputSHA256": "7828bb700e650eb35143227141bef937afb42bf1d38543d14fbff976519c55fc" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"rg --files --hidden --no-ignore -g '\"'!.git/**'\"'\ncat package.json\"", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 210, + "outputSHA256": "ba6cce46787072aace2702dc2d11c4c81a9c223ce4f468e46fe4953509134924" + } + ], + "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-f08cf2dd/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-f08cf2dd/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", + "answer": "Creation paused; no files changed.\n\nComplete candidate for Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\n**Conflict:** `aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md` requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d Its scope is also `tests/**/*.py`. The same requirement appears in `AGENTS.md`, `.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md`, `.cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc`, and `.github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md`.\n\nChoose: keep pytest, revise the candidate, or explicitly replace `05-testing/5-existing` and its listed publications with the unittest candidate.\n\nThe installed skill\u2019s [assessment step](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cAn unresolved conflict or needs-review finding requires an explicit resolution of that finding before proceeding.\u201d Capture confirmation does not resolve this conflict.", + "fixtureFiles": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "---\ndescription: \"Python unit tests\"\nglobs: \"tests/**/*.py\"\nalwaysApply: false\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "---\napplyTo: \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", + "AGENTS.md": "\nApplies to: `tests/**/*.py`.\n\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", + "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" + }, + "rawEventsSHA256": "1b60175ddbb1d9979aef279d06748827db167c406d7a54bf29020d1b87ea1a6f" + }, + "copilot-guidance": { + "receipt": { + "case": "copilot-guidance", + "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-pa64pbd1", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [] + }, + "before": { + "GEMINI.md": "84d50ee6955150792d301179bdcf6a4e3c92922a6ebfba6204236df3d6e6dfc1", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + "GEMINI.md": "84d50ee6955150792d301179bdcf6a4e3c92922a6ebfba6204236df3d6e6dfc1", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "skill-hashes": { + "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", + "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", + "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", + "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", + "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", + "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", + "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", + "references/tool-paths.md": "40bef1b4fc7bdcf2fb6312ef217751bcea67b99899b9423c056c9407e45324a2", + "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" + }, + "commands": [ + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-pa64pbd1/installed/SKILL.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 1600, + "outputSHA256": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-pa64pbd1/installed/actions/01-capture-rule.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 1707, + "outputSHA256": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-pa64pbd1/installed/references/tool-paths.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-pa64pbd1/installed/references/rule-authoring.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-pa64pbd1/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 18955, + "outputSHA256": "77f280b1b6aef14ec4e5f30918488b27e061a032433063123d10ff1583193f8d" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"pwd -P; rg --files --hidden -g '\"'!.git'\"' -g '\"'!node_modules'\"' -g '\"'!vendor'\"'; cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-pa64pbd1/installed/assets/rule-template.md\"", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 381, + "outputSHA256": "70e67cb6759c13a64cb99fc02604a92c8a2e34f08714e2baedeafddce919af9b" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat GEMINI.md package.json; ls -la'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 334, + "outputSHA256": "32bfa683e3b2350c1f61e26f9485469779b5b68fcbab49d8adc80fddd691b9e2" + } + ], + "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-pa64pbd1/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-pa64pbd1/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", + "answer": "Creation paused: [GEMINI.md](GEMINI.md:3) says \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d This conflicts with the candidate under Copilot\u2019s discovery rules.\n\nExact candidate, targeting Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\nProposed resolution: replace the pytest requirement in `GEMINI.md` with the unittest requirement, then create the candidate. Alternatively, keep pytest and cancel, or revise the candidate.\n\nThe installed skill\u2019s [action 02](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires \u201can explicit user decision\u201d and explicit resolution of conflicts before writing. Please choose a resolution. No files changed.", + "fixtureFiles": { + "GEMINI.md": "# Unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", + "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" + }, + "rawEventsSHA256": "06228605fe0af7a7f31ab311858f9a57668a01319e9334efbb6c12200569f2d4" + }, + "copilot-import": { + "receipt": { + "case": "copilot-import", + "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t4gu559a", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [] + }, + "before": { + ".github/copilot-instructions.md": "f499439acb6f5b3504d0435aed5e9b60be5dc5634b90708863370d739e574b14", + "docs/unit-policy.md": "0e5cd2aa19aa90b11d9fd678e85cc137315971a75d68bd2004bf0f48ea63be3d", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + ".github/copilot-instructions.md": "f499439acb6f5b3504d0435aed5e9b60be5dc5634b90708863370d739e574b14", + "docs/unit-policy.md": "0e5cd2aa19aa90b11d9fd678e85cc137315971a75d68bd2004bf0f48ea63be3d", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "skill-hashes": { + "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", + "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", + "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", + "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", + "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", + "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", + "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", + "references/tool-paths.md": "40bef1b4fc7bdcf2fb6312ef217751bcea67b99899b9423c056c9407e45324a2", + "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" + }, + "commands": [ + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t4gu559a/installed/SKILL.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 1600, + "outputSHA256": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t4gu559a/installed/actions/01-capture-rule.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t4gu559a/installed/references/rule-authoring.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t4gu559a/installed/references/tool-paths.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 16346, + "outputSHA256": "183ebd7c0e118a7bf3546751290a17590a2ce7ceee6a334a4f694cc3efb89b17" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t4gu559a/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md\nrg --files --hidden -g '\"'!'\"\\\\.git/**' -g '\"'!node_modules/**'\"' -g '\"'!vendor/**'\"' .\"", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 4387, + "outputSHA256": "64011bdafc21e0a0e75164bd5320ef80e5fc33fc4a6fb62ee4bf9548625b17db" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat .github/copilot-instructions.md docs/unit-policy.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t4gu559a/installed/assets/rule-template.md\nls -la'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 692, + "outputSHA256": "7440301c90f35f2adeb7ca3750dd798be1f61e028e6dd4368c73034dccf72f62" + } + ], + "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t4gu559a/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t4gu559a/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", + "answer": "Creation paused: conflicting policy found. No files changed.\n\n[.github/copilot-instructions.md](.github/copilot-instructions.md) imports [docs/unit-policy.md](docs/unit-policy.md), which requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d That applies to the candidate\u2019s `tests/**/*.py` scope.\n\nComplete candidate for Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\nProposed resolution: explicitly amend `docs/unit-policy.md` to allow unittest under `tests/**/*.py`, then create the candidate. Alternatively, keep pytest, revise the candidate, or cancel. Which resolution do you approve?\n\nThe skill\u2019s [action 02](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires \u201can explicit resolution of that finding before proceeding.\u201d Your capture confirmation does not resolve this discovered conflict.", + "fixtureFiles": { + ".github/copilot-instructions.md": "# Unit tests\n\nFollow @../docs/unit-policy.md.\n", + "docs/unit-policy.md": "# Unit policy\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", + "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" + }, + "rawEventsSHA256": "0d7198372928070fe64986b1222554565c8d0884ba2423aa4b43754b400926e1" + }, + "covered": { + "receipt": { + "case": "covered", + "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [] + }, + "before": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", + "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", + "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "skill-hashes": { + "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", + "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", + "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", + "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", + "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", + "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", + "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", + "references/tool-paths.md": "8f6c12f0c5593ebad9865f7d71be8b9d076168246ba2fb07fa7680713fae57dd", + "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" + }, + "commands": [ + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/installed/SKILL.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 1600, + "outputSHA256": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/installed/actions/01-capture-rule.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 1707, + "outputSHA256": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/installed/references/tool-paths.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/installed/references/rule-authoring.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 17908, + "outputSHA256": "15a442337727680f6300d1b092aabc3d8985784935a507db1e4bb66b3c2ecc2e" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"rg --files --hidden -g '\"'!'\"\\\\.git/**' -g 'AGENTS*' -g 'CLAUDE.md' -g '*.mdc' -g '*.instructions.md' -g 'copilot-instructions.md' -g 'aidd_docs/rules/**' -g '.claude/**' -g '*config*' -g '*settings*' -g 'opencode*' -g '.github/**' -g '.cursor/**'\"", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 179, + "outputSHA256": "27eb06f4a0dc6ed49a846e0aef8d6043a4c7a1ffde4c0b617403d2923cab27fb" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/installed/assets/rule-template.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 269, + "outputSHA256": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat AGENTS.md aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md .github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md .claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md .cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 1221, + "outputSHA256": "0bef1a1a68bb766c66ab9017300b314d55dea9099ef1bf154b64af6add1c583e" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/installed/scripts/write-rule.cjs'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 15650, + "outputSHA256": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"rg --files --hidden --no-ignore -g '\"'!.git/**'\"'\"", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 192, + "outputSHA256": "3955dca5630e1adfc0386818651b1a17be9203fab6b9460cc61a519fc4d326b2" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"node <<'NODE'\nconst fs = require('node:fs');\nconst vm = require('node:vm');\nconst script = '/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/installed/scripts/write-rule.cjs';\nconst src = fs.readFileSync(script, 'utf8').split('try { main(); }')[0];\nvm.runInNewContext(src + \"'`\nconst name = '\"'aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md';\nconst rule = parseCanonical(readUtf8(name), name);\nfor (const tool of ['claude','cursor','copilot']) {\n const p = nativePath(rule, tool), text = readUtf8(p);\n ownedNative(text, rule, tool, p);\n if (text \"'!== renderNative(rule, tool)) throw new Error('\"'Rendering differs: ' + p);\n}\nconst shared = readUtf8('AGENTS.md');\ncontribution(shared);\nif (shared \"'!== renderShared('\"'', [rule])) throw new Error('Shared rendering differs');\nprocess.stdout.write('Verified canonical scope, targets, native renderings and signatures, shared rendering and signature.\\\\\\\\n');\n\"'`, {require, process, Buffer});\nNODE'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 101, + "outputSHA256": "8993da388c2cf8e1469c447e3a79e346a206c428a002ecca7c5870edeeb23a6f" + } + ], + "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Write every unit test with pytest.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", + "answer": "Assessment: **covered**. Existing `aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md` requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests\u201d under identical scope, `tests/**/*.py`. Verified matching publications in `.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md`, `.cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc`, `.github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md`, and `AGENTS.md`, covering all five confirmed tools.\n\nComplete candidate:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Write every unit test with pytest.\\n\"}\n```\n\nRecommend keeping the existing rule. Choose: keep existing, approve this exact duplicate, revise candidate, or cancel. No files changed.\n\nThe installed skill\u2019s [assessment action](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cShow the complete candidate, findings and proposed resolution, then wait for an explicit user decision.\u201d This further decision is required after assessment, so I stopped as instructed.", + "fixtureFiles": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "---\ndescription: \"Python unit tests\"\nglobs: \"tests/**/*.py\"\nalwaysApply: false\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "---\napplyTo: \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", + "AGENTS.md": "\nApplies to: `tests/**/*.py`.\n\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", + "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" + }, + "rawEventsSHA256": "5698383e980dbeb0bc2727cf803db05b24abfc2b83c33a1b1e9c441564364d3d" + }, + "disjoint": { + "receipt": { + "case": "disjoint", + "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [] + }, + "before": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "3ccc5ee40f2a5caea1382ff9da1bb546e2f94a4d3b6eb591603bb5622bb18269", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "df4c9a6cd7512ff24b79d4bfa946a44b0d368c055d680e67883293defde4887d", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "30f0f402e53af81be9950700dcaf05d0a2411bd8f2f1fdbfec2a5b915b39c506", + "AGENTS.md": "209e23b4325e862c45ad5347517553e296662d47a4f794b266ee34336ea50c35", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ceb7c77e195f68130a3302542deac1871a00d963b3ed97dc74b1d3b1473e2d0a", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "3ccc5ee40f2a5caea1382ff9da1bb546e2f94a4d3b6eb591603bb5622bb18269", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "df4c9a6cd7512ff24b79d4bfa946a44b0d368c055d680e67883293defde4887d", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "30f0f402e53af81be9950700dcaf05d0a2411bd8f2f1fdbfec2a5b915b39c506", + "AGENTS.md": "209e23b4325e862c45ad5347517553e296662d47a4f794b266ee34336ea50c35", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ceb7c77e195f68130a3302542deac1871a00d963b3ed97dc74b1d3b1473e2d0a", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "skill-hashes": { + "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", + "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", + "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", + "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", + "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", + "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", + "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", + "references/tool-paths.md": "8f6c12f0c5593ebad9865f7d71be8b9d076168246ba2fb07fa7680713fae57dd", + "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" + }, + "commands": [ + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/installed/SKILL.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 1600, + "outputSHA256": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/installed/actions/01-capture-rule.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 1707, + "outputSHA256": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/installed/references/tool-paths.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/installed/references/rule-authoring.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 17908, + "outputSHA256": "15a442337727680f6300d1b092aabc3d8985784935a507db1e4bb66b3c2ecc2e" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"pwd -P\nrg --files --hidden -g '\"'!node_modules'\"' -g '\"'!.git'\"' -g 'AGENTS*' -g 'CLAUDE.md' -g '*.mdc' -g '*instructions.md' -g '**/rules/**' -g '**/.claude/**' -g '**/.cursor/**' -g '**/.github/**' -g '**/.opencode/**' -g '**/.codex/**'\ncat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/installed/assets/rule-template.md\"", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 537, + "outputSHA256": "1604c20e73ad7df31fa0bf5b80d3835317ee17ada7c2629e23c1a2f006541951" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"cat AGENTS.md aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md .github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md .claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md .cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc\nrg --files --hidden --no-ignore -g '\"'!.git'\"' -g '\"'!node_modules'\"'\n\"", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 1453, + "outputSHA256": "0803a9ff16382840f9029f2e92bff6c88e28ff831c4f78bc2fc0f677df40f876" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"rg -n 'sha256|separator|createHash|aidd_rule_output' /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/installed/scripts/write-rule.cjs\ncat package.json\nfor dir in / /private /private/var /private/var/folders /private/var/folders/xr /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2; do for name in AGENTS.md AGENTS.override.md CLAUDE.md .claude/CLAUDE.md; do if [ -f \\\"\"'$dir/$name\" ]; then printf '\"'\\\\n%s\\\\n' \\\"\"'$dir/$name\"; cat \"$dir/$name\"; fi; done; done'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 953, + "outputSHA256": "813daface96cb8f035d0fb5d86ac1b65780aca9165b9b0963df8886f55f2a27c" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"sed -n '92,150p' /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/installed/scripts/write-rule.cjs\"", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 3962, + "outputSHA256": "e16010c12c2eed8d5f0587f2525e6cade925cffddd60a550e9d5c705f00fea51" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"tokenade exec --lang python --script 'import pathlib,re,hashlib\nh=lambda s:hashlib.sha256(s.encode()).hexdigest()\nfor p in [pathlib.Path(\\\".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md\\\"),pathlib.Path(\\\".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc\\\"),pathlib.Path(\\\".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md\\\")]:\n s=p.read_text(); m=re.search(r\\\"\\\\n<\"'!-- aidd_rule_output:path=('\"\\\\S+) sha256=([a-f0-9]{64}) -->\\\\n\"'$\",s); assert m and m[1]==str(p) and h(s[:m.start()])==m[2]\ns=pathlib.Path(\"AGENTS.md\").read_text(); m=re.fullmatch(r\"'\"\\\\n(.*?)<\"'!-- aidd_rules:end -->'\"\\\\n\\\",s,re.S); assert m and h(\\\"separator=0\\\\n\\\"+m[2])==m[1]\nprint(\\\"All four publication signatures verified; bodies and scopes match the inspected canonical policy.\\\")'\"", + "exit": 127, + "outputBytes": 35, + "outputSHA256": "f6152a2a42ddb7426bc7ac2a615b109c7f0db6a54665375a8e652e1b8f2f89ad" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"python3 - <<'PY'\nimport pathlib,re,hashlib\nh=lambda s:hashlib.sha256(s.encode()).hexdigest()\nfor p in [pathlib.Path('.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md'),pathlib.Path('.cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc'),pathlib.Path('.github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md')]:\n s=p.read_text(); m=re.search(r'\\\\n<\"'!-- aidd_rule_output:path=('\"\\\\S+) sha256=([a-f0-9]{64}) -->\\\\n\"'$'\"',s); assert m and m[1]==str(p) and h(s[:m.start()])==m[2]\ns=pathlib.Path('AGENTS.md').read_text(); m=re.fullmatch(r'<\"'!-- aidd_rules:start sha256=([a-f0-9]{64}) separator=0 -->'\"\\\\n(.*?)<\"'!-- aidd_rules:end -->'\"\\\\n',s,re.S); assert m and h('separator=0\\\\n'+m[2])==m[1]\nprint('All four publication signatures verified; inspected bodies and scopes match canonical policy.')\nPY\"", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 94, + "outputSHA256": "710995a0d4d079edb08b8a770cd04e4f332b8675462e6b5cafe061b78efc2958" + } + ], + "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"frontend/tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", + "answer": "Assessment: **new**. Existing `5-existing` canonical rule and verified Claude, Cursor, Copilot and `AGENTS.md` publications require \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d only under `backend/tests/**/*.py`. That scope is disjoint from `frontend/tests/**/*.py`; no conflict or overlap was found.\n\nComplete candidate for Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"frontend/tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\nProposed resolution: create this exact candidate, preserving existing rules. Approve, revise, or cancel?\n\nThe installed [assessment action](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cwait for an explicit user decision, including for **new**.\u201d Your capture confirmation precedes this assessment, so I\u2019ve stopped without writing any files.", + "fixtureFiles": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"backend/tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "---\ndescription: \"Python unit tests\"\nglobs: \"backend/tests/**/*.py\"\nalwaysApply: false\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "---\napplyTo: \"backend/tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", + "AGENTS.md": "\nApplies to: `backend/tests/**/*.py`.\n\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", + "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" + }, + "rawEventsSHA256": "890caf005638401b3835507821a53d42611d3810be0cdad8a21270ce315939e6" + }, + "edited-rendering": { + "receipt": { + "case": "edited-rendering", + "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [] + }, + "before": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "9e8fd9e68a4cc2ec4219a150f7aab51e7562780547d7438f5fdf5aadd44baf32", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", + "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "9e8fd9e68a4cc2ec4219a150f7aab51e7562780547d7438f5fdf5aadd44baf32", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", + "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "skill-hashes": { + "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", + "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", + "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", + "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", + "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", + "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", + "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", + "references/tool-paths.md": "2f1e5f4bb3d388b58d3502b6e71a857cd7d98c89ed63795c88b6664699f8106c", + "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" + }, + "commands": [ + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt/installed/SKILL.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 1600, + "outputSHA256": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt/installed/actions/01-capture-rule.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt/installed/references/rule-authoring.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt/installed/references/tool-paths.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 16330, + "outputSHA256": "bb6928c48b7ae4e321381cdbd118e639a8549e8988e3a1580c88e812e0cca786" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 4316, + "outputSHA256": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"rg --files --hidden -g '\"'!.git'\"' -g '\"'!node_modules'\"' -g '\"'!vendor'\"'\"", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 192, + "outputSHA256": "c77979eb47f2fa550a98d1a62d675dbb5698da4cfb88aa7035cbbd580053eecc" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat AGENTS.md aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md .github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md .claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md .cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt/installed/assets/rule-template.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt/installed/scripts/write-rule.cjs'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 17142, + "outputSHA256": "1fc2e5e3842da8709c96c6db661d8643fe93750076e485bc45e6c35794d66598" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"node <<'NODE'\nconst fs = require('fs'), crypto = require('crypto');\nconst hash = s => crypto.createHash('sha256').update(s).digest('hex');\nconst canonical = fs.readFileSync('aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md','utf8');\nconst body = canonical.slice(canonical.indexOf('\\\\n')+1);\nfor (const p of ['.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md','.cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc','.github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md']) {\n const s = fs.readFileSync(p,'utf8');\n const m = /\\\\n<\"'!-- aidd_rule_output:path=('\"\\\\S+) sha256=([a-f0-9]+) -->\\\\n\"'$/.exec(s);\n const payload = s.slice(0,m.index);\n console.log(p, JSON.stringify({signatureValid:m[1]===p && hash(payload)===m[2],bodyMatches:payload.slice(payload.indexOf('\"'---\\\\n',4)+4)===body}));\n}\nconst s=fs.readFileSync('AGENTS.md','utf8');\nconst m=/\"'^\\\\n([\\\\s\\\\S]*)<\"'!-- aidd_rules:end -->'\"\\\\n\"'$/.exec(s);\nconsole.log('\"'AGENTS.md',JSON.stringify({signatureValid:hash('separator='+m[2]+'\\\\n'+m[3])===m[1],payloadMatches:m[3]==='Applies to: \"'`tests/**/*.py`.'\"\\\\n\\\\n'+body}));\nNODE\"", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 315, + "outputSHA256": "01aa61c3e73bfbff90f770f01304829ac5419681ef0479933f8faf97a6b29404" + } + ], + "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Write every unit test with pytest.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", + "answer": "No files changed. Assessment found:\n\n- **Covered:** `aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md` already requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d Its Cursor, Copilot and shared `AGENTS.md` publications match.\n- **Conflict:** `.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md` instead requires \u201cUse unittest for all unit tests.\u201d Its signature is invalid, indicating an edited publication. Both rules cover `tests/**/*.py`.\n\nComplete candidate, targeting all five confirmed tools:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Write every unit test with pytest.\\n\"}\n```\n\nRecommended decision: keep the existing pytest rule and explicitly authorize restoring its Claude publication. Alternatively, specify a revision or cancel.\n\nFurther decision is required by [action 02](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md): \u201cShow the complete candidate, findings and proposed resolution, then wait for an explicit user decision.\u201d The conflict and edited publication require explicit resolution before writing.", + "fixtureFiles": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "---\ndescription: \"Python unit tests\"\nglobs: \"tests/**/*.py\"\nalwaysApply: false\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "---\napplyTo: \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", + "AGENTS.md": "\nApplies to: `tests/**/*.py`.\n\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", + "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" + }, + "rawEventsSHA256": "ffc4bf4735f227b29abbd717561dc999a849bd6cdc24bbbc65f58fee13f1fc2b" + }, + "new": { + "receipt": { + "case": "new", + "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [] + }, + "before": { + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "skill-hashes": { + "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", + "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", + "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", + "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", + "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", + "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", + "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", + "references/tool-paths.md": "8f6c12f0c5593ebad9865f7d71be8b9d076168246ba2fb07fa7680713fae57dd", + "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" + }, + "commands": [ + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk/installed/SKILL.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 1600, + "outputSHA256": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk/installed/actions/01-capture-rule.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 1707, + "outputSHA256": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk/installed/references/tool-paths.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk/installed/references/rule-authoring.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 13592, + "outputSHA256": "52a68419a8e07e8bf1e139792b97d9a0027e404ac4918db36b8e1c29e82398d4" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 4316, + "outputSHA256": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"pwd -P\nrg --files --hidden -g '\"'!.git'\"' -g '\"'!node_modules'\"' -g '\"'!vendor'\"'\"", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 102, + "outputSHA256": "59c7cd7e39f9f2d79a3345ae73896df6fe7d3497caec9a82181613deeb217ffe" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk/installed/assets/rule-template.md\nls -la\nfor dir in /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn /private/var/folders/xr /private/var/folders /private/var /private /; do for name in AGENTS.md AGENTS.override.md CLAUDE.md; do if [ -f \"$dir/$name\" ]; then printf '\"'\\\\n%s\\\\n' \\\"\"'$dir/$name\"; cat \"$dir/$name\"; fi; done; done'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 469, + "outputSHA256": "7e681d52e5c1e0a33b28fd6456cb4bf68019b5b075763f7391ed8a851d2be200" + } + ], + "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"01-standards\", \"slug\": \"1-constants\", \"description\": \"Constants\", \"paths\": [\"src/**/*.ts\"], \"body\": \"# Constants\\n\\n- Name constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", + "answer": "Assessment: **new**. No existing project rules or ancestor instructions were found. Supplied guidance does not overlap. All five selected tools are supported.\n\nExact candidate for Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"01-standards\",\"slug\":\"1-constants\",\"description\":\"Constants\",\"paths\":[\"src/**/*.ts\"],\"body\":\"# Constants\\n\\n- Name constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n\"}\n```\n\nApprove this exact candidate, revise it, or cancel?\n\n[Skill action 02](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cwait for an explicit user decision, including for **new**.\u201d This decision follows assessment, so capture confirmation does not satisfy it. No files were changed.", + "fixtureFiles": { + "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" + }, + "rawEventsSHA256": "812bd835fe71021c6b5c6496916e1ad859ff66463226780e4926926e08a62767" + }, + "overlap": { + "receipt": { + "case": "overlap", + "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [] + }, + "before": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", + "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", + "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "skill-hashes": { + "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", + "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", + "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", + "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", + "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", + "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", + "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", + "references/tool-paths.md": "8f6c12f0c5593ebad9865f7d71be8b9d076168246ba2fb07fa7680713fae57dd", + "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" + }, + "commands": [ + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg/installed/SKILL.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 1600, + "outputSHA256": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg/installed/actions/01-capture-rule.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 1707, + "outputSHA256": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg/installed/references/tool-paths.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg/installed/references/rule-authoring.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 17908, + "outputSHA256": "15a442337727680f6300d1b092aabc3d8985784935a507db1e4bb66b3c2ecc2e" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"pwd -P\nrg --files --hidden -g '\"'!node_modules'\"' -g '\"'!.git'\"' -g '\"'!vendor'\"'\ncat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg/installed/assets/rule-template.md\"", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 550, + "outputSHA256": "1dc64d98135d3069f3c81060f0b9b2e1bf77b6f48c9d88b451051449c4f04d3b" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat AGENTS.md aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md .github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md .claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md .cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc\ncat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg/installed/scripts/write-rule.cjs'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 16871, + "outputSHA256": "6dbbb7a93947693e07bed78c4dfdb983e61fb8cd6faedfcc6cb9e0cb90833905" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"rg --files --hidden --no-ignore -g '\"'!.git'\"'\nnode <<'NODE'\nconst fs = require('node:fs');\nconst vm = require('node:vm');\nconst script = fs.readFileSync('/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg/installed/scripts/write-rule.cjs', 'utf8');\nconst checks = \"'`\nconst source = '\"'aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md';\nconst rule = parseCanonical(readUtf8(source), source);\nfor (const tool of ['claude', 'cursor', 'copilot']) {\n const file = nativePath(rule, tool), actual = readUtf8(file);\n ownedNative(actual, rule, tool, file);\n if (actual \"'!== renderNative(rule, tool)) throw new Error('\"'Rendering differs: ' + file);\n}\nconst shared = readUtf8('AGENTS.md');\ncontribution(shared);\nif (shared \"'!== renderShared('\"'', [rule])) throw new Error('Shared rendering differs');\nconsole.log('All four publications match canonical body, scope and ownership.');\n\"'`;\nvm.runInNewContext(script.slice(0, script.lastIndexOf('\"'try { main(); }')) + checks, {require, console, Buffer});\nNODE\"", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 257, + "outputSHA256": "2b0e5ea95a5a3dbedd3e4527412ea0fcb7148d33ad54c76878a55ec9b0e1f14d" + } + ], + "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\\n- Put unit test files in tests/unit/.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", + "answer": "Assessment: **overlap**. [Existing rule](aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md) already requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d for the identical scope, `tests/**/*.py`. Its Claude, Cursor, Copilot and shared AGENTS.md publications match and have valid ownership. The `tests/unit/` requirement is new.\n\nComplete candidate, targeting all five confirmed tools:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\\n- Put unit test files in tests/unit/.\\n\"}\n```\n\nApprove creating this exact candidate alongside the existing rule, revise it to omit the repeated pytest requirement, or keep the existing rule?\n\nNo files changed. [Action 02](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cShow the complete candidate, findings and proposed resolution, then wait for an explicit user decision, including for **new**.\u201d Your confirmed capture choices do not resolve this overlap.", + "fixtureFiles": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "---\ndescription: \"Python unit tests\"\nglobs: \"tests/**/*.py\"\nalwaysApply: false\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "---\napplyTo: \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", + "AGENTS.md": "\nApplies to: `tests/**/*.py`.\n\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", + "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" + }, + "rawEventsSHA256": "17167fe5ae27c615366969ac6ae73727aabf1236c24195c5373e3b8faf6e557a" + }, + "plugin-conflict": { + "receipt": { + "case": "plugin-conflict", + "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-qb2gmmss", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [] + }, + "before": { + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae", + "plugins/example/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "c83fa98fc86980237fca5bc0d216c3cb089770f2e4499744b306a509111368bf" + }, + "after": { + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae", + "plugins/example/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "c83fa98fc86980237fca5bc0d216c3cb089770f2e4499744b306a509111368bf" + }, + "skill-hashes": { + "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", + "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", + "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", + "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", + "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", + "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", + "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", + "references/tool-paths.md": "40bef1b4fc7bdcf2fb6312ef217751bcea67b99899b9423c056c9407e45324a2", + "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" + }, + "commands": [ + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-qb2gmmss/installed/SKILL.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 1600, + "outputSHA256": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat ../installed/actions/01-capture-rule.md ../installed/references/rule-authoring.md ../installed/references/tool-paths.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 16346, + "outputSHA256": "183ebd7c0e118a7bf3546751290a17590a2ce7ceee6a334a4f694cc3efb89b17" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"cat ../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md\nrg --files --hidden -g '\"'!'\"\\\\.git/**' -g 'AGENTS*' -g '*.md' -g '*.mdc' plugins .\"", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 4412, + "outputSHA256": "32ae694d2d8eddde93c0cee2363a1fc803f61ed5a842ca7cf09db9b3a6b417c9" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat plugins/example/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md ../installed/assets/rule-template.md\npwd -P\nls -a'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 467, + "outputSHA256": "6ebbec183488b44318c16767096686c112a11db13dcb7a60e627424796d02399" + } + ], + "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-qb2gmmss/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-qb2gmmss/project, plugin source in plugins/example, no host publication. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", + "answer": "Conflict: [5-existing.md](plugins/example/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md) requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d Both rules cover `tests/**/*.py`.\n\nCandidate destination: `plugins/example/rules/05-testing/5-candidate.md` \nDescription: `Test conventions`\n\n```markdown\n---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n\n# Test conventions\n\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\n```\n\nChoose: replace the existing pytest rule with this candidate, keep the existing rule, revise the candidate, or cancel. No files changed.\n\nThe [skill\u2019s assessment step](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cAn unresolved conflict or needs-review finding requires an explicit resolution of that finding before proceeding.\u201d Your confirmed capture choices do not resolve this conflict.", + "fixtureFiles": { + "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n", + "plugins/example/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n\n# Unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n" + }, + "rawEventsSHA256": "dc15f99f8c5b170fd1ccef7f0bec0c129efcbc4d0571bf6be74102bd7887b7c7" + }, + "uncertain": { + "receipt": { + "case": "uncertain", + "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [] + }, + "before": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "97b20713c5f281632ce97c6304250b4a1b1988ca32a3df0ccf544cbe2d74171a", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "97b20713c5f281632ce97c6304250b4a1b1988ca32a3df0ccf544cbe2d74171a", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "skill-hashes": { + "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", + "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", + "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", + "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", + "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", + "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", + "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", + "references/tool-paths.md": "8f6c12f0c5593ebad9865f7d71be8b9d076168246ba2fb07fa7680713fae57dd", + "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" + }, + "commands": [ + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo/installed/SKILL.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 1600, + "outputSHA256": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo/installed/actions/01-capture-rule.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 1707, + "outputSHA256": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo/installed/references/tool-paths.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo/installed/references/rule-authoring.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 17908, + "outputSHA256": "15a442337727680f6300d1b092aabc3d8985784935a507db1e4bb66b3c2ecc2e" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"pwd; rg --files --hidden -g '\"'!'\"\\\\.git/**' -g 'AGENTS*' -g 'CLAUDE.md' -g '*.md' -g '*.mdc' -g '*config*' -g '*settings*'; cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo/installed/assets/rule-template.md\"", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 397, + "outputSHA256": "d3887ff7afe9267e6ef328ba27f7b429c32eeb5a7abc23fb69555e114e31c4a9" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"cat .claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md; rg --files --hidden --no-ignore -g '\"'!.git/**'\"'; for d in /private /private/var /private/var/folders /private/var/folders/xr /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo; do for n in AGENTS.md AGENTS.override.md CLAUDE.md; do if test -f \\\"\"'$d/$n\"; then printf '\"'\\\\n%s\\\\n' \\\"\"'$d/$n\"; cat \"$d/$n\"; fi; done; done'", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 163, + "outputSHA256": "ed100f83f46a28d7464474e94ffefc3d597a54e15b6e8538243f78ea827eb798" + }, + { + "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"cat package.json; if test -f docs/test-framework.md; then cat docs/test-framework.md; else printf '%s\\\\n' 'Missing: docs/test-framework.md'; fi\"", + "exit": 0, + "outputBytes": 50, + "outputSHA256": "b8c1adad295009e4413ca16467d856d8ec4bc27152a6b92521e36ff8c608078a" + } + ], + "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", + "answer": "No files changed. Assessment: **needs review**.\n\nExisting [.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md](.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md) applies to `tests/**/*.py` and requires: \u201cUse the test framework approved in docs/test-framework.md.\u201d That document is missing, so compatibility with `unittest` cannot be established.\n\nComplete candidate for Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\nDecision required: confirm `unittest` is the approved framework and approve this exact candidate, supply the missing policy for reassessment, or cancel.\n\nThe installed [workflow](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cAn unresolved conflict or needs-review finding requires an explicit resolution of that finding before proceeding.\u201d Your capture confirmation does not resolve this finding.", + "fixtureFiles": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n\n# Unit tests\n\n- Use the test framework approved in docs/test-framework.md.\n", + "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" + }, + "rawEventsSHA256": "9d4eb838fccc831d7c10c54eb44878911a02ef5c532389b1547ca3cd07d87f31" + }, + "scope-uncertain": { + "receipt": { + "case": "scope-uncertain", + "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ofdnwunc", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [] + }, + "before": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "49719e0335aa2659637431b09c60a99c7ea7b4792542295e2785bb335b5abcde", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "49719e0335aa2659637431b09c60a99c7ea7b4792542295e2785bb335b5abcde", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "skill-hashes": { + "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", + "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", + "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", + "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", + "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", + "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", + "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", + "references/tool-paths.md": "ce7a9da327f0f7c3d8a540191de7a223f216a77c6d438e0178dae91ca760d245", + "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" + }, + "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ofdnwunc/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ofdnwunc/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", + "answer": "No files changed. Assessment: **needs review**.\n\nExisting `.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md` applies to `**/*.py` and requires: \u201cFor the unit test files selected in config/unit-test-paths.json, use pytest.\u201d That config is missing, so overlap with your unittest requirement cannot be determined.\n\nComplete candidate, targeting all five confirmed tools:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\nPlease resolve the missing scope evidence, explicitly authorize replacing the existing pytest policy with this candidate, or cancel.\n\n[Action 02](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cAn unresolved conflict or needs-review finding requires an explicit resolution of that finding before proceeding.\u201d Your capture confirmation does not resolve this finding, so the workflow stops here.", + "fixtureFiles": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"**/*.py\"\n---\n\n# Unit tests\n\n- For the unit test files selected in config/unit-test-paths.json, use pytest.\n", + "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" + }, + "rawEventsSHA256": "6221c3dfd327e42db48b44501b8ca05b1104fdf1c02c0da35023515ef18d4fd3" + } +} diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-lifecycle.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-lifecycle.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..72ce75e60 --- /dev/null +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-lifecycle.json @@ -0,0 +1,220 @@ +{ + "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q", + "results": [ + { + "case": "new", + "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [] + }, + { + "turn": "revise", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [], + "before": { + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + } + }, + { + "turn": "approve", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": false, + "changed": [ + ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md", + ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc", + ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md", + "AGENTS.md", + "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md" + ], + "before": { + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", + ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", + ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", + "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", + "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "exactBody": true + }, + { + "turn": "covered", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [], + "before": { + ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", + ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", + ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", + "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", + "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", + ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", + ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", + "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", + "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + } + }, + { + "turn": "keep", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [], + "before": { + ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", + ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", + ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", + "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", + "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", + ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", + ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", + "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", + "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + } + }, + { + "turn": "conflict", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [], + "before": { + ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", + ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", + ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", + "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", + "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", + ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", + ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", + "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", + "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + } + }, + { + "turn": "cancel", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [], + "before": { + ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", + ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", + ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", + "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", + "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", + ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", + ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", + "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", + "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + } + }, + { + "turn": "publish", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [], + "before": { + ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", + ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", + ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", + "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", + "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", + ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", + ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", + "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", + "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + } + }, + { + "turn": "delete", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": false, + "changed": [ + ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md", + ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc", + ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md", + "AGENTS.md", + "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md" + ], + "before": { + ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", + ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", + ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", + "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", + "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + "AGENTS.md": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + } + } + ], + "turns": { + "initial": { + "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"01-standards\", \"slug\": \"1-constants\", \"description\": \"Constants\", \"paths\": [\"src/**/*.ts\"], \"body\": \"# Constants\\n\\n- Name constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", + "answer": "Assessment: **new**. Project contains only `package.json`; no existing rule sources or ancestor guidance were found. Supplied AGENTS.md instructions contain no competing constants policy. All five selected tools are supported.\n\nExact candidate:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"01-standards\",\"slug\":\"1-constants\",\"description\":\"Constants\",\"paths\":[\"src/**/*.ts\"],\"body\":\"# Constants\\n\\n- Name constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n\"}\n```\n\nProposed resolution: create this candidate for Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2.\n\n**Approve this exact candidate, revise it, or cancel?** No files changed.\n\n[Skill action 02](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cwait for an explicit user decision, including for **new**.\u201d Your confirmed capture choices do not satisfy this separate assessment decision." + }, + "revise": { + "prompt": "Change the candidate body to exactly \"# Constants\\n\\n- Name constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n- Export constants using named exports.\\n\" and create it. All earlier capture choices remain confirmed.", + "answer": "Reassessment: **new**. Original project still contains only `package.json`; no applicable existing rule covers or contradicts either bullet. No files changed.\n\nRevised candidate, targeting Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"01-standards\",\"slug\":\"1-constants\",\"description\":\"Constants\",\"paths\":[\"src/**/*.ts\"],\"body\":\"# Constants\\n\\n- Name constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n- Export constants using named exports.\\n\"}\n```\n\nApprove this reassessed candidate for creation?\n\nThe installed skill\u2019s [action 02, step 6](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cAny change to body, metadata, scope, destinations or replacement/merge resolution returns to Draft and comparison, then requires a new decision.\u201d Creation awaits that decision." + }, + "approve": { + "prompt": "I approve the exact revised candidate you just assessed, with both bullets, the same metadata, src/**/*.ts scope and all five hosts. Publish it now.", + "answer": "Published exact approved rule in the original project for all five hosts.\n\n- PASS canonical `aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md`\n- PASS Claude Code publication\n- PASS Cursor publication\n- PASS GitHub Copilot publication\n- PASS shared `AGENTS.md` for Codex/OpenCode V2\n\nExact body and scope verified; repeat publication byte-identical. Runtime consumption not tested. No application changes, installs, network calls or commits. Nothing pending." + }, + "covered": { + "prompt": "Create another rule: manual host project, all five hosts confirmed, category 01-standards, slug 1-public-values, description Public values, paths [\"src/**/*.ts\"], exact body \"# Public values\\n\\n- Write names of constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n\". Follow the installed skill from capture.", + "answer": "Assessment: **covered**. Existing [1-constants.md](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q/project/aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md) already requires \u201cName constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\u201d for the identical `src/**/*.ts` scope and all five hosts. Its Claude, Cursor, Copilot and shared `AGENTS.md` publications match canonical content and scope; signatures are intact.\n\nComplete candidate:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"01-standards\",\"slug\":\"1-public-values\",\"description\":\"Public values\",\"paths\":[\"src/**/*.ts\"],\"body\":\"# Public values\\n\\n- Write names of constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n\"}\n```\n\nProposed resolution: keep the existing rule, including its named-export requirement, without adding a duplicate. No files changed.\n\n**Confirm keeping the existing rule?**\n\nThe installed skill\u2019s [action 02](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires \u201can explicit user decision\u201d after assessment. Awaiting that resolution." + }, + "keep": { + "prompt": "Keep the existing policy. Do not create the candidate or modify existing files.", + "answer": "Existing policy retained. Candidate not created; no files changed. Nothing pending." + }, + "conflict": { + "prompt": "Create another rule: manual host project, all five hosts confirmed, category 01-standards, slug 1-lowercase-values, description Lowercase values, paths [\"src/**/*.ts\"], exact body \"# Lowercase values\\n\\n- Name every constant in lowerCamelCase.\\n\". Follow the installed skill from capture.", + "answer": "Assessment: **conflict**. Existing [1-constants.md](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q/project/aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md) requires \u201cName constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\u201d Its verified publications cover the same `src/**/*.ts` scope across all five hosts. Requiring `lowerCamelCase` contradicts that obligation.\n\nComplete candidate:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"01-standards\",\"slug\":\"1-lowercase-values\",\"description\":\"Lowercase values\",\"paths\":[\"src/**/*.ts\"],\"body\":\"# Lowercase values\\n\\n- Name every constant in lowerCamelCase.\\n\"}\n```\n\nProposed resolution: keep the existing policy. No files changed.\n\n**Keep the existing policy, or replace its naming requirement across all five hosts while preserving its named-export requirement?**\n\nThe installed skill\u2019s [action 02](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) states: \u201cAn unresolved conflict or needs-review finding requires an explicit resolution of that finding before proceeding.\u201d Awaiting your resolution." + }, + "cancel": { + "prompt": "Cancel this candidate. Keep every existing rule and publication unchanged.", + "answer": "Candidate cancelled. Every existing rule and publication remains unchanged. Nothing pending." + }, + "publish": { + "prompt": "Explicitly publish the existing canonical rule set to claude,cursor,copilot,codex,opencode using the installed skill. Do not change its body or targets.", + "answer": "Published existing canonical rule set to all five hosts.\n\n- PASS canonical `1-constants.md`\n- PASS Claude publication\n- PASS Cursor publication\n- PASS Copilot publication\n- PASS shared Codex/OpenCode `AGENTS.md`\n\nBody and targets unchanged. Repeat publication byte-identical; runtime consumption not tested. Nothing pending." + }, + "delete": { + "prompt": "Explicitly delete existing canonical rule 01-standards/1-constants and its publications on all five confirmed hosts using the installed skill.", + "answer": "Deleted `01-standards/1-constants` using the installed skill.\n\n- PASS canonical source removed\n- PASS Claude publication removed\n- PASS Cursor publication removed\n- PASS Copilot publication removed\n- PASS Codex/OpenCode shared contribution removed\n\n`package.json` unchanged. Repeat publication preserved deletion. Nothing pending." + } + } +} diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-merge.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-merge.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d2a0afba7 --- /dev/null +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-merge.json @@ -0,0 +1,97 @@ +{ + "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-kyf8vbhs", + "results": [ + { + "case": "overlap", + "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-kyf8vbhs", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [] + }, + { + "turn": "merge", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "before": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", + "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", + "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + } + }, + { + "turn": "approve-merge", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": false, + "before": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", + "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ea7a6e761e39734447ac1826007f2e6c8121a4aed107a1baa484a92dd7d2e0eb", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "bfea5e988bee2a398325da998ee8c9843d45aed8988ccef9dd6ae88bc07fdca3", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "aa7831807e3e3d618c3e63d75f2e551f84dba6710d2baf91f897a05bea3ab207", + "AGENTS.md": "874a63eb836e5329d50e8b595174bb7a0f6e57ca5a66bf425992f7a8014ce48a", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "5056a2efb84f9cc80e5843b8868390b3d7d662bd42fcdb3c12aa5d09392e51ca", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + } + } + ], + "exactBody": true, + "noDuplicate": true, + "initialBefore": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", + "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "initialAfter": { + ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", + ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", + ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", + "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", + "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "skill-hashes": { + "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", + "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", + "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", + "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", + "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", + "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", + "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", + "references/tool-paths.md": "ce7a9da327f0f7c3d8a540191de7a223f216a77c6d438e0178dae91ca760d245", + "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" + }, + "turns": { + "initial": { + "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-kyf8vbhs/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-kyf8vbhs/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\\n- Put unit test files in tests/unit/.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", + "answer": "Assessment: **overlap**. Existing `aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md` already requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d for the identical scope, `tests/**/*.py`. The same requirement appears in `AGENTS.md` and the Claude Code, Cursor, and Copilot publications. Requiring `tests/unit/` adds a new obligation.\n\nComplete candidate, targeting all five confirmed tools:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\\n- Put unit test files in tests/unit/.\\n\"}\n```\n\nProposed resolution: revise the candidate to contain only the new `tests/unit/` requirement. Alternatively, approve the exact candidate despite overlap, keep the existing rule, or cancel. Which resolution do you choose?\n\nNo files changed. The installed skill\u2019s [action 02](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-kyf8vbhs/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cShow the complete candidate, findings and proposed resolution, then wait for an explicit user decision, including for **new**.\u201d Your capture confirmations do not satisfy this later decision, so the workflow stops here." + }, + "merge": { + "prompt": "Merge this candidate into existing canonical 05-testing/5-existing and update its five confirmed publications. Keep its existing description, category, slug, scope and targets. The proposed complete merged body is exactly \"# Python unit tests\\n\\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\\n- Put unit test files in tests/unit/.\\n\". Do not create 5-candidate.", + "answer": "Reassessment: merging into `05-testing/5-existing` resolves the overlap. It preserves the existing pytest requirement and adds the unit-test directory requirement. No conflict found in the inspected sources.\n\nMetadata and all five targets remain unchanged. Complete merged body:\n\n```markdown\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n- Put unit test files in tests/unit/.\n```\n\nApprove this assessed merge and its publication updates?\n\nNo files changed; `5-candidate` was not created. The skill\u2019s [action 02, step 6](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-kyf8vbhs/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) says a changed merge resolution \u201creturns to Draft and comparison, then requires a new decision.\u201d This requires confirmation after reassessment." + }, + "approve-merge": { + "prompt": "I approve the exact merged candidate you just reassessed, explicitly updating aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md and its Claude, Cursor, Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2 publications. Write and validate this resolution now.", + "answer": "Merged the exact approved body; existing metadata and targets preserved.\n\n- PASS `aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md`\n- PASS `.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md`\n- PASS `.cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc`\n- PASS `.github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md`\n- PASS `AGENTS.md` \u2014 shared Codex/OpenCode V2 publication\n\nRepublishing was byte-identical. No `5-candidate` created. Runtime host consumption was not tested." + } + } +} diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/runtime.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/runtime.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..02a7880fd --- /dev/null +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/runtime.json @@ -0,0 +1,6 @@ +{ + "executable": "/opt/homebrew/bin/codex", + "version": "codex-cli 0.154.0", + "auth": "Logged in using ChatGPT", + "platform": "Darwin arm64" +} diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..dca7096fc --- /dev/null +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md @@ -0,0 +1,45 @@ +# Verification: pre-write rule assessment + +Verified on 2026-10-12 against [issue #791](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/framework/issues/791). Base: `3e67f6f594b7b7f6cc7bceb0581ad6d515519080`. + +## Behavior evidence + +The old skill wrote the canonical rule and shared AGENTS contribution without the new assessment decision: [baseline receipt](receipts/baseline.json). The revised skill stopped before writing in all twelve fresh assessment runs. Every run exited successfully and its complete project-file SHA-256 map was unchanged. Classification was checked against the actual answer, not a phrase-presence test. + +[Assessment receipts](receipts/native-assessment.json) include prompts, answers, original fixture contents, before/after hashes, installed-skill hashes and raw-event hashes. + +| Fixture | Observed result | +| --- | --- | +| New constants policy | New; requires approval of the complete candidate. | +| Same pytest policy, different title and wording | Covered; five verified publications represent one policy. | +| Pytest plus an additional unit-test directory requirement | Overlap; repeated and added obligations identified. | +| Pytest versus unittest in the same scope | Conflict; existing source cited. | +| Backend versus frontend test paths, with no matching files yet | New; disjoint prefixes justify excluding the existing policy. | +| Missing referenced test-framework decision | Needs review; no guessed framework. | +| Missing file-selection configuration | Needs review; no guessed scope intersection. | +| Edited Claude rendering | Canonical coverage and the conflicting native edit both remain visible. | +| Plugin-source pytest rule | Conflict detected without host publication. | +| Copilot GEMINI guidance | Conflict detected from the project instruction source. | +| Copilot repository instruction import | Imported policy read and conflict identified. | +| Actual CLI flat Codex distribution | Conflict detected before writing through the installed skill. | + +The [nine-turn lifecycle](receipts/native-lifecycle.json) proves reassessment after a body change, no write before the subsequent approval, exact approved-body preservation, five-host publication, covered/keep and conflict/cancel without changes, byte-identical publication, and deletion. Deletion leaves an empty AGENTS.md, the existing writer behavior; it does not restore the original file inventory. + +The [three-turn merge](receipts/native-merge.json) proves an existing rule can be selected for a merge, the changed complete body is reassessed without writes, and explicit approval updates that source and its publications with the exact merged body. No second canonical rule is created. + +## Regression and distribution checks + +- Existing writer suite: 61 passed. Focused architecture, portability, links and writer checks: 117 passed, no failures or skips. +- Full pre-commit gates: wrapped root suite `node scripts/check-tests-leave-git-alone.js -- node --test 'scripts/__tests__/**/*.test.js'`: 677 passed, no failures or skips. Recipe build and all three bundled recipe validations passed; catalog, link, duplication and referenced-path checks passed. +- `git diff 3e67f6f594b7b7f6cc7bceb0581ad6d515519080 --exit-code -- plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/scripts/write-rule.cjs cli`: no changes. Publication, ownership and CLI behavior remain the existing implementation. +- `AIDD_SKIP_UPDATE_CHECK=1 node cli/dist/cli.js translate . --to codex --as flat --out ` and the Claude `--as marketplace` translation succeeded. Both distributions contain the four actions and unchanged writer; their four actions, two references and writer match source bytes. Old action filenames are absent. One native session used the actual flat distribution. + +## Reproduction and limits + +[Runtime](receipts/runtime.json): native Codex 0.154.0, ChatGPT login, disposable projects, no application edits or package installation in fixtures. API-key environment variables were unset. Initial calls used `codex -a never exec --ignore-user-config --skip-git-repo-check --sandbox workspace-write --cd --json --output-last-message -`; fresh assessment calls additionally used `--ephemeral`. Persistent follow-ups used `codex -a never exec resume --ignore-user-config -c 'sandbox_mode="workspace-write"' --skip-git-repo-check --json --output-last-message -` from the fixture directory. The per-call sandbox override was necessary because resume otherwise defaulted to read-only; no user configuration was changed. + +To repeat an assessment, materialize the recorded `fixtureFiles` in a disposable project, copy or translate the skill into a separate installed directory, substitute those two paths in the recorded prompt, snapshot every project file, then run the command above with that prompt on stdin. Compare complete before/after maps and inspect the answer against the fixture's policy obligations. To repeat the journeys, start a persistent session and supply the recorded follow-up prompts in order, retaining per-turn snapshots. + +These receipts cover 24 successful native CLI invocations in 14 sessions: twelve fresh assessments and two persistent journeys. Exploratory runs, the old-skill baseline and the initial read-only harness failure are excluded from this count. Earlier eight-case runs preceded the bounded discovery-reference expansion; the four workflow actions and writer are byte-identical to the final version. Later Copilot, flat-distribution, scope and merge cases cover the expanded reference. Per-session hashes preserve this distinction; [final source hashes](receipts/final-source-hashes.json) identify the final assets. + +Semantic comparison is model judgment, not a deterministic conflict detector or a script-enforced approval lock. These runs exercise the skill through Codex and its five-host writer. They do not prove runtime instruction consumption by native Claude, Cursor, Copilot or OpenCode sessions. Relevant discovery contracts were checked against the official sources linked in the plan and tool-path reference. No claim of universal host precedence, full account/global discovery or coverage of every glob is made. diff --git a/docs/CATALOG.md b/docs/CATALOG.md index a32432450..292d67934 100644 --- a/docs/CATALOG.md +++ b/docs/CATALOG.md @@ -25,7 +25,7 @@ Bootstrap, project init, context-artifact generation, diagrams, learning, and ex | `02-project-memory` | Give the AI a memory of the project, wired into the tools you use | `01-scan`, `02-write`, `03-check`, `04-sync` | | `03-context-generate` | Router that dispatches an artifact-generation request to the dedicated generator below | delegates to `04`–`08` (and plugins / marketplaces) | | `04-skill-generate` | Generate a router-based skill across the host AI tool(s) | `01-scope`, `02-plan`, `03-write`, `04-validate` | -| `05-rule-generate` | Generate a coding rule that governs editor and agent behavior | `01-capture-rule`, `02-write-rule`, `03-validate` | +| `05-rule-generate` | Generate a coding rule that governs editor and agent behavior | `01-capture-rule`, `02-assess-existing-rules`, `03-write-rule`, `04-validate` | | `06-agent-generate` | Generate an agent across the host AI tool(s) | `01-capture-agent`, `02-write-agent`, `03-validate` | | `07-command-generate` | Generate a flat slash command across the host AI tool(s) | `01-capture-command`, `02-write-command`, `03-validate` | | `08-hook-generate` | Generate a lifecycle hook across the host AI tool(s) | `01-capture-hook`, `02-write-hook`, `03-validate` | diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md b/plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md index 06c1317db..a685ef29e 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md @@ -117,8 +117,9 @@ Auto-generated index of skills, agents, references and assets shipped by the `ai | Group | File | Description | |-------|------|---| | `actions` | [01-capture-rule.md](skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md) | - | -| `actions` | [02-write-rule.md](skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md) | - | -| `actions` | [03-validate.md](skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md) | - | +| `actions` | [02-assess-existing-rules.md](skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) | - | +| `actions` | [03-write-rule.md](skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-write-rule.md) | - | +| `actions` | [04-validate.md](skills/05-rule-generate/actions/04-validate.md) | - | | `assets` | [rule-template.md](skills/05-rule-generate/assets/rule-template.md) | - | | `references` | [rule-authoring.md](skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md) | - | | `references` | [tool-paths.md](skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md) | - | diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md index afdd94753..fa5c8beae 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md @@ -10,13 +10,14 @@ Manage canonical rules and their active publications per confirmed host, or auth ## Actions -| # | Action | Role | Input | -| --- | -------------- | ----------------------------------------- | ------------ | -| 01 | `capture-rule` | Capture the topic, pick category and slug | user request | -| 02 | `write-rule` | Write the rule file per supported tool | the topic | -| 03 | `validate` | Check each rule file | the files | - -Run the actions in order, `01 → 03`, and run each action's `## Test` before the next. +| # | Action | Role | Input | +| --- | ----------------------- | ------------------------------------------- | ------------------- | +| 01 | `capture-rule` | Confirm intent, scope and destinations | user request | +| 02 | `assess-existing-rules` | Compare the complete candidate and resolve | confirmed intent | +| 03 | `write-rule` | Publish the approved candidate or selection | approved resolution | +| 04 | `validate` | Check the resolved result | affected files | + +For create/update, run `01 → 04`, and run each action's `## Test` before the next. Explicitly confirmed publish/delete runs `01 → 03 → 04`; it does not draft or assess a new candidate. Keeping existing rules or cancelling in 02 ends without writing. Before running an action, read its file in `actions/`, not only the table or assets. ## References diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md index b3a5c48ff..c1377e89c 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md @@ -13,7 +13,7 @@ In-context: the topic, its category and slug, the file scope, a one-line descrip ## Process 1. **Gate.** Run the asset-access precheck ([tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md)). - For an explicitly confirmed host publish/delete, identify the existing rule or rule set and hosts, then continue to Render in action 02; no new topic or body is needed. + For an explicitly confirmed host publish/delete, identify the existing rule or rule set and hosts, then continue to Render in action 03; no new topic or body is needed. This includes publishing manual canonical body edits beneath intact metadata. 2. **Auto or manual.** Ask whether to run auto or manual mode: - **Auto**: scan the codebase, propose a rules architecture, wait for approval. - **Manual**: ask the topic (blocking). Confirm any candidate first. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e12934626 --- /dev/null +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +# 02 - Assess existing rules + +Compare a complete candidate with applicable policies and obtain an explicit resolution before any rule write. + +## Input + +From 01: confirmed intent, category, slug, description, scope, write mode and destinations. + +## Output + +In-context: the complete candidate, source evidence, assessment and explicit user decision. An approved resolution carries the exact candidate and affected existing sources to 03; keeping existing rules or cancelling ends here. + +## Process + +1. **Draft.** Prepare the complete Markdown body in context using [rule-template.md](../assets/rule-template.md) and [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md). Strip the scaffold and settle any needed split now, assessing each resulting candidate. Include metadata, literal scope and destinations; do not create a rule, request file or publication yet. +2. **Discover.** Read the relevant sources through the discovery contract in [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md), for the confirmed mode and hosts. Include user guidance and nested instructions that may apply to the candidate's scope. Record sources read, excluded sources with reasons, and unreadable or uncertain sources. Treat verified renderings of a canonical policy as one logical rule, retaining every source path; never hide differing user edits as duplicates. +3. **Compare.** Compare obligations, prohibitions, conditions, exceptions, priority and scope, regardless of title, category or filename. An update also compares its prior source and states what will change. Exclude a policy only when its applicability is provably disjoint from the candidate's scope, independently of which files currently exist. If host activation, scope intersection, precedence or meaning cannot be established, report **needs review**, not an assumed exclusion. +4. **Assess.** Report relevant findings with source paths, the decisive policy text and scope reasoning: + - **new**: no applicable policy covers, overlaps or contradicts the candidate after the discovery above. + - **covered**: an applicable policy already supplies every proposed obligation under the applicable conditions throughout the candidate's scope, even under a different title. + - **overlap**: compatible policies partially repeat or extend each other; identify the repeated and added obligations. + - **conflict**: applicable obligations cannot both be followed, or the candidate weakens an existing requirement without an explicit exception or priority. + - **needs review**: evidence is insufficient to decide; name the missing evidence or decision. + Keep distinct findings when different policies produce different results; a conflict or uncertainty must not disappear behind an overall new/covered label. +5. **Decide.** Show the complete candidate, findings and proposed resolution, then wait for an explicit user decision, including for **new**. Choices must fit the evidence: approve the exact candidate, keep the existing policy, revise scope/body, merge into or replace an identified existing source, or cancel. Approval of a topic or target in 01 is not approval of this candidate. Modifying or deleting an existing source needs explicit confirmation of that source and its affected publications; never clean up user guidance or native files automatically. An unresolved conflict or needs-review finding requires an explicit resolution of that finding before proceeding. +6. **Reassess.** Any change to body, metadata, scope, destinations or replacement/merge resolution returns to Draft and comparison, then requires a new decision. If relevant source evidence changes before writing, refresh the assessment too. Carry the final approved body unchanged to 03; do not generate a different body there. Keeping an existing policy and cancelling leave project bytes unchanged. + +## Test + +- The complete candidate was compared before any rule or request file was written. +- Covered, overlap, conflict and needs-review findings cite their evidence; canonical deduplication and scope exclusions are justified. +- The user explicitly resolved the final candidate and every relevant finding; changed candidates were reassessed. +- Keeping existing rules or cancelling changed no project bytes; an approved write carries the exact body and explicitly confirmed source changes. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-write-rule.md similarity index 50% rename from plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md rename to plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-write-rule.md index 88f705728..88cb1681b 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-write-rule.md @@ -1,10 +1,10 @@ -# 02 - Write rule +# 03 - Write rule -Build one canonical rule and publish it for each confirmed supported host. +Write the approved canonical rule and publish it for each confirmed supported host. ## Input -From 01: the topic, category, slug, scope, and write mode. +From 02: the explicitly approved complete candidate, scope, destinations and resolution. Or from 01: an explicitly confirmed existing publish/delete selection. ## Output @@ -12,15 +12,15 @@ The canonical source, generated targets, and any unsupported tool with its reaso ## Process -1. **Build.** For create/update, use [rule-template.md](../assets/rule-template.md); strip the scaffold. For publish/delete, skip to Render. +1. **Approval.** For create/update, consume the exact candidate approved in action 02, including body, metadata, scope and destinations. Do not regenerate, split or rewrite it after approval. If any of these change, return to 02 before writing. Keeping existing rules or cancelling has no write path. For publish/delete, skip to Render. 2. **Request.** For host create/update, put category, slug, description, optional paths and complete Markdown body into the JSON request in [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). Keep YAML frontmatter out of the body. 3. **Render.** Per the write mode ([tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md)): - - **Host**: resolve `scripts/write-rule.cjs` beside the loaded installed `SKILL.md`. Invoke its absolute path with explicit project, tools and the operation's arguments in [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). Use it for create/update, publish and delete; never replace or remove generated files manually. It preflights all outputs. Report refusals verbatim; skip unsupported tools with their reason. + - **Host**: resolve `scripts/write-rule.cjs` beside the loaded installed `SKILL.md`. Invoke its absolute path with explicit project, tools and the operation's arguments in [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). Use it for create/update, publish and delete, including explicitly approved canonical updates or deletions in a merge/replacement resolution; never replace or remove generated files manually. It preflights all outputs. Report refusals verbatim; skip unsupported tools with their reason. - **Plugin source**: write one canonical `.md` rule. No per-tool fan-out. -4. **Split.** When examples warrant it, write several rule files rather than one crowded one. -5. **Validate.** Check the script's reported targets against [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). It must not require the AIDD CLI. +4. **Validate.** Check the script's reported targets against [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). It must not require the AIDD CLI. ## Test - Create/update/publish: canonical sources and active publications exist with the intended scope. +- Create/update: the written body is the approved body; no existing source was modified or removed without its explicit resolution. - Delete: the selected source and its publications are absent; remaining rules and user bytes survive. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/04-validate.md similarity index 82% rename from plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md rename to plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/04-validate.md index fb6e8c5cf..f67089a5a 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/04-validate.md @@ -1,10 +1,10 @@ -# 03 - Validate +# 04 - Validate Check each written rule file against the contract. ## Input -The list of files written (from 02). +The list of files affected and approved resolution (from 03). ## Output @@ -13,7 +13,7 @@ A short pass or fail line per rule file. ## Process 1. **Operation.** Create/update/publish: confirm expected sources and publications exist. Delete: confirm the selected source and its native files or shared rule body are absent; remaining rules and user bytes survive. -2. **Contract.** For remaining files, validate against [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md) and confirmed intent, including exact literals. +2. **Contract.** For remaining files, validate against [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md) and confirmed intent, including exact literals. For create/update, compare the complete written body, scope and destinations to the approved candidate and confirm its resolution was followed. 3. **Target.** Validate target path and frontmatter against [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). For Codex and OpenCode V2, each remaining body must appear once in the shared signed contribution; deleting the last shared rule removes that contribution. User guidance and memory bytes must survive, and rerunning the installed script with `--publish` must be byte-identical. Remaining native files retain complete bodies and scope syntax. Report publication separately from consumption; only real host evidence proves runtime use. 4. **Report.** Emit one pass/fail line per file. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md index 2012252ac..e12590655 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md @@ -8,7 +8,7 @@ The contract every generated rule must satisfy. A rule governs editor and agent - **R2.** Bullets only. Keep each concise; preserve requested literals, conditions and exceptions over word limits. - **R3.** Scope every rule to the files it applies to, or mark it as applying to all. - **R4.** English only, regardless of conversation language. -- **R5.** Do not add a rule bullet that repeats, weakens, or contradicts another active bullet in the same rule. +- **R5.** Do not add a rule bullet that repeats, weakens, or contradicts another active bullet in the same rule. Before create/update, resolve cross-rule coverage and conflicts through action 02. ## File naming diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md index a65c28442..a9982d445 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md @@ -16,12 +16,35 @@ Use taxonomy and `#-slug` naming in [rule-authoring.md](rule-authoring.md). Copi Codex Markdown guidance is not a `.codex/rules` execution policy. OpenCode V2 ignores config `instructions`; file links and modular `.opencode/rules` sources alone do not publish their text. This contract excludes OpenCode V1. Native syntax tests prove rendering, not runtime consumption by every host. Codex/OpenCode selected together appear once in the shared file; other hosts may also discover AGENTS.md, so physical deduplication does not guarantee model-context deduplication across surfaces. -Official contracts checked on 2026-10-11: [Claude Code rules](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/memory#organize-rules-with-clauderules), [Cursor rules](https://cursor.com/docs/rules) and [CLI loading](https://cursor.com/docs/cli/using#rules), [Copilot CLI instructions](https://docs.github.com/en/copilot/how-tos/copilot-cli/customize-copilot/add-custom-instructions), [Codex AGENTS.md](https://learn.chatgpt.com/docs/agent-configuration/agents-md), and [OpenCode V2 instructions](https://opencode.ai/v2/docs/instructions/). +Official contracts checked on 2026-10-12: [Claude Code rules](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/memory#organize-rules-with-clauderules), [Cursor rules](https://cursor.com/docs/rules) and [CLI loading](https://cursor.com/docs/cli/using#rules), [Copilot CLI instructions](https://docs.github.com/en/copilot/how-tos/copilot-cli/customize-copilot/add-custom-instructions), [Codex AGENTS.md](https://learn.chatgpt.com/docs/agent-configuration/agents-md), and [OpenCode V2 instructions](https://opencode.ai/v2/docs/instructions/). Publication does not force a running host to reload. Verify changed rules in a fresh session: Codex builds its instruction chain at startup; Copilot applies edits to a new or resumed session. OpenCode V2 refreshes ambient AGENTS.md before the next request, but already loaded nested guidance needs a new session. Claude project rules require the `project` settings source; Cursor rules concern Agent rather than Tab or Inline Edit. The writer preserves patterns without implementing each host's glob parser; a syntactically invalid or unmatched pattern can activate no files. Confirm representative matching and nonmatching files in the selected host. The shared contribution shows `Applies to:` followed by literal globs in Markdown code spans, or `all files`. Category/slug identity stays in canonical metadata rather than added visible headings. A leading ATX or single-line Setext title is kept without an added title; scope precedes the unchanged body. Otherwise the description supplies a level-two heading before scope and body. This bounded title check ignores fenced examples and indented code; it does not parse all Markdown. Complete body bytes and native rendering remain unchanged. +## Assessment discovery + +For action 02, this reference owns discovery paths. Discovery is read-only: never run create/update, `--publish` or `--delete` to inspect or compare policies. + +- **Host project**: read canonical `aidd_docs/rules/**/*.md`, their recorded targets and the confirmed hosts' project sources below. Inspect both rule bodies and applicability metadata. Include relevant guidance outside generated contributions and nested instructions for directories intersecting the candidate's scope, including descendants that may contain future matching files. +- **Plugin source**: read existing `plugins//rules/**/*.md` in the confirmed plugin and relevant project authoring guidance. Use their `paths` or all-files scope; these are plugin sources, not generated project publications. Identify explicitly known companion policies where relevant, without assuming every other plugin is installed. + +| Confirmed host | Project sources to inspect | +| --- | --- | +| Claude Code | `.claude/rules/**/*.md`, root and relevant nested `CLAUDE.md` and `.claude/CLAUDE.md` | +| Cursor | root and relevant nested `.cursor/rules/**/*.mdc` and `AGENTS.md`; Cursor CLI also reads root `CLAUDE.md` | +| GitHub Copilot | Repository root, current directory, intermediate directories and relevant file-path nested directories: `.github/copilot-instructions.md`, `AGENTS.md`, `CLAUDE.md`, `.claude/CLAUDE.md`, `GEMINI.md`. Also `.github/instructions/**/*.instructions.md` in those locations except intermediate directories; apply only matching `applyTo` scopes. | +| Codex | Root and relevant nested directories: first nonempty file among `AGENTS.override.md`, `AGENTS.md`, then configured fallback names, in that order; unknown fallback configuration requires review when it could affect the candidate. | +| OpenCode V2 | project/upward and relevant nested `AGENTS.md` | + +Consider already loaded project/ancestor guidance and explicit host configuration that identifies additional sources. This is a bounded project assessment, not a scan of personal home files or a claim to discover all account/global settings. Unknown configured fallbacks, conditional activation, unreadable sources or uncertain precedence are **needs review** when they could affect the candidate. Do not infer activation merely from a file's existence or an installed host's directory. + +Read imports only under the confirmed host's documented rules. Copilot CLI expands `@relative-path` imports recursively from repository-wide and agent instruction sources except `GEMINI.md`; it does not expand them in modular instruction files. Resolve imports within the repository, read-only, with cycle detection. Absolute, home-relative, outside-repository, escaping symlink or uncertain references are **needs review** when relevant; do not follow arbitrary paths or execute referenced content. Disabled Copilot instruction files are not active, and its documentation defines no general precedence among applicable repository and agent instructions. + +Map generated publications to canonical identity and recorded targets. Deduplicate only after verifying that body and scope match the corresponding canonical rendering and ownership is intact under the contract below; retain the canonical and publication paths as evidence. A marker or similar filename alone proves nothing. If equality or ownership cannot be verified read-only, keep the source as a separate finding. A differing native edit, unsigned user rule or user text outside the shared contribution remains visible for comparison. Canonical target intent and active publication evidence must be distinguished; neither duplicate rendering nor a missing publication proves a policy is irrelevant. + +Interpret scopes, conditions and directory inheritance using each confirmed host's documented contract. A root shared contribution's textual scope is not a directory boundary, and category/slug similarity is not scope evidence. Record a proof for excluded disjoint scopes; an empty current file match set is not such a proof. These assessment rules do not alter publication, ownership refusal or host runtime behavior. + ## Installed script Resolve `scripts/write-rule.cjs` beside the loaded installed `SKILL.md` and invoke its absolute path with Node. This applies to native plugins and flat skills. Never reconstruct a plugin path, assume a framework checkout, project-relative script path, or installed AIDD CLI. The CommonJS script uses Node built-ins only and works inside ES module projects. @@ -54,7 +77,7 @@ Canonical sources start with one strict script-owned JSON comment recording vers The script validates the complete prospective set before changing canonical sources or outputs. It rejects symlink targets/ancestors, traversal, reserved rule markers outside fenced examples and unclosed fences. Requests and existing files must be valid UTF-8; parsed text must roundtrip without unpaired Unicode surrogates. Valid Unicode pairs and complete bodies are preserved. The shared signature covers both payload and separator ownership; editing either refuses the request. It preserves every byte outside its shared contribution, including CRLF and `aidd_project_memory`. Repeated publication is byte-idempotent. Individual file replacement is atomic; this is not a multi-file transaction against disk failures or concurrent writers. -Root `AGENTS.override.md` blocks Codex generation because it masks AGENTS.md. The script conservatively refuses a local AGENTS.md exceeding the default 32 KiB project-document budget when Codex is involved. Other discovered project instruction files share that configurable budget; the writer does not inspect them or host configuration. Global/home user guidance is assembled separately, outside this project-document counter in verified Codex 0.160.1 and 0.162.1 ([official implementation](https://github.com/openai/codex/blob/092d3acd6bec3e3a14bdc7e7a2810ab628ab759d/codex-rs/core/src/agents_md.rs#L63)). A local pass cannot guarantee the remaining project budget, and the script does not change host configuration. +Root `AGENTS.override.md` conservatively blocks Codex generation even when empty; the writer does not change the host's first-nonempty discovery contract above. The script conservatively refuses a local AGENTS.md exceeding the default 32 KiB project-document budget when Codex is involved. Other discovered project instruction files share that configurable budget; the writer does not inspect them or host configuration. Global/home user guidance is assembled separately, outside this project-document counter in verified Codex 0.160.1 and 0.162.1 ([official implementation](https://github.com/openai/codex/blob/092d3acd6bec3e3a14bdc7e7a2810ab628ab759d/codex-rs/core/src/agents_md.rs#L63)). A local pass cannot guarantee the remaining project budget, and the script does not change host configuration. No migration: old `.opencode/rules` or `.codex/rules` files are neither imported nor deleted. An old `aidd_opencode_rules` block causes `Ambiguous or legacy AIDD rule contribution; no automatic migration.` or the corresponding incomplete-block error. Explicitly resolve historical guidance before retrying; do not silently erase or import it. Flat archive distribution of standalone rules remains out of scope. From 09af93daec18e5aced10b815958f29e3ce36aad0 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE Date: Mon, 12 Oct 2026 15:37:10 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 02/24] fix(aidd-context): include applicable claude project guidance Include local Claude policies and conditionally loaded AGENTS sources in the discovery contract. Record a Claude-only conflict assessment that leaves every project byte unchanged. Refs #791 --- .../receipts/final-source-hashes.json | 2 +- .../receipts/native-assessment.json | 35 ++++++++++++++++ .../review.md | 42 +++++++++++++++++++ .../verification.md | 6 ++- .../05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md | 2 +- 5 files changed, 83 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) create mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/review.md diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/final-source-hashes.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/final-source-hashes.json index 2e3308602..a3a347bf4 100644 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/final-source-hashes.json +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/final-source-hashes.json @@ -6,6 +6,6 @@ "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", - "references/tool-paths.md": "ce7a9da327f0f7c3d8a540191de7a223f216a77c6d438e0178dae91ca760d245", + "references/tool-paths.md": "8b985e2a360c5fa44d13742e8f79c92afb8ddf2c8e2a6b0083fffbd84bf0f13e", "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" } diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-assessment.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-assessment.json index c291dcf08..4bf5405e0 100644 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-assessment.json +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-assessment.json @@ -876,5 +876,40 @@ "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" }, "rawEventsSHA256": "6221c3dfd327e42db48b44501b8ca05b1104fdf1c02c0da35023515ef18d4fd3" + }, + "claude-local": { + "receipt": { + "case": "claude-local", + "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-mdm66onm", + "exit": 0, + "unchanged": true, + "changed": [] + }, + "before": { + "CLAUDE.local.md": "f6f6bdd0fbb28b7e582991c063f0f4ec4868959cca6aa45e9dc2c8c374d17b2c", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "after": { + "CLAUDE.local.md": "f6f6bdd0fbb28b7e582991c063f0f4ec4868959cca6aa45e9dc2c8c374d17b2c", + "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" + }, + "skill-hashes": { + "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", + "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", + "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", + "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", + "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", + "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", + "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", + "references/tool-paths.md": "8b985e2a360c5fa44d13742e8f79c92afb8ddf2c8e2a6b0083fffbd84bf0f13e", + "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" + }, + "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-mdm66onm/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-mdm66onm/project, host project, tool Claude Code only. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", + "answer": "Creation paused; no files changed.\n\nConflict: [CLAUDE.local.md](CLAUDE.local.md) requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d Its project-wide scope includes `tests/**/*.py`, where the candidate requires unittest.\n\nExact candidate: `05-testing/5-candidate`, description `Test conventions`, scope `tests/**/*.py`, Claude Code only.\n\n```markdown\n# Test conventions\n\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\n```\n\nChoose: keep pytest, revise the candidate, or explicitly authorize changing `CLAUDE.local.md` to resolve the conflict.\n\nThe installed skill\u2019s [action 02](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cAn unresolved conflict or needs-review finding requires an explicit resolution of that finding before proceeding.\u201d", + "rawEventsSHA256": "6091cb2da7042580de5b85d590c946958d01910d45e4e55a9f702e8e987cbfd3", + "fixtureFiles": { + "CLAUDE.local.md": "# Local unit test policy\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", + "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" + } } } diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/review.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/review.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4a3d5060a --- /dev/null +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/review.md @@ -0,0 +1,42 @@ +# Review: Assess existing rules before writing + +- **Verdict**: changes-requested +- **Diff**: `3e67f6f594b7b7f6cc7bceb0581ad6d515519080...f75d450681e8c7e49ae21da005278782ab4c9ee2` +- **Axes run**: code, functional, relevancy +- **Date**: 2026_10_12 +- **Findings**: 0 critical, 1 warning, 0 minor +- **Score**: 90/100; six plan criteria and four baseline checklist items fulfilled, reduced for one material discovery gap in the actual need. + +## Phases + +### Phase 1 — Assess, resolve, then preserve publication + +- [x] No create/update write without assessment and explicit decision on the complete candidate. — `plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md:15`; `actions/03-write-rule.md:15`; baseline RED and twelve unchanged assessment snapshots in `receipts/baseline.json` and `receipts/native-assessment.json`. +- [x] Covered, overlap, conflict and needs-review findings cite sources; scope and canonical rendering exclusions are justified. — `actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md:16`; `references/tool-paths.md:44`; actual covered, overlap, edited-rendering, disjoint, uncertain and scope-uncertain answers and raw events in `receipts/native-assessment.json`. +- [x] Changed resolution is assessed again; keep and cancel leave project bytes unchanged. — `actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md:26`; revise/keep/cancel snapshots in `receipts/native-lifecycle.json`; merge reassessment and exact approved update in `receipts/native-merge.json`. +- [x] Publish/delete and five-host writer preserve existing behavior. — `SKILL.md:21`; `actions/01-capture-rule.md:16`; lifecycle publish/delete events and snapshots; `git diff BASE HEAD --exit-code -- plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/scripts/write-rule.cjs cli` exits 0. +- [x] Native receipts prove classifications and pre-decision no-write behavior, with honest limits. — `verification.md:7`; all twelve complete answers, fixture maps, raw-event SHA-256 values, on-disk snapshots and current fixture bytes checked; nine lifecycle and three merge answers match native JSONL events and prompts; `verification.md:43` discloses reference revisions and Codex-only skill execution. +- [x] Required gates pass; independent review has no critical blocking finding. — `/private/tmp/aidd-791-commit.log:4296` records 677 passed, 0 failed; `/private/tmp/aidd-791-push.log:129` records 7002 passed, 1 skipped; fresh architecture check reports seven governed files, no violation. The warning below requires repair before review clearance. + +## Findings + +| Sev | Kind | Phase | Location | Issue | Fix | +| --- | ---- | ----- | -------- | ----- | --- | +| warning | fit | 1 | `plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md:34` | Claude discovery omits project `CLAUDE.local.md` and conditionally loaded `AGENTS.md` / `.claude/AGENTS.md`. A Claude-only candidate can miss an applicable conflicting policy in these files and be classified new. [Official memory documentation](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/memory#how-claudemd-files-load) includes local files at the working directory, ancestors and relevant descendants; [AGENTS discovery](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/memory#when-claude-code-reads-agentsmd) is conditional on version, enabled support and instruction-file mode. This leaves #791's relevant-policy comparison incomplete despite all supplied fixtures passing. | Extend this canonical discovery row with `CLAUDE.local.md` and conditional `AGENTS.md` / `.claude/AGENTS.md` sources. Apply documented activation; reuse line 40's needs-review handling when activation is relevant and unknown. Add a disposable Claude-only local-guidance assessment receipt proving conflict or justified needs review without writes. Keep writer and host precedence unchanged. | + +## Verification + +| Metric | Value | +| --- | --- | +| Verified | 100% (6/6 plan acceptance criteria); one additional actual-need warning remains. | +| Files checked | All 19 changed files; root `AGENTS.md`, `docs/ARCHITECTURE.md`, project coding assertions/testing memory; review actions/template/rubric/validator; unchanged writer seam; six JSON receipts; all 24 native answers and prompts with raw JSONL; commit/push logs; official documentation linked in tool-paths. | +| Contract | [Issue #791 and comments](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/framework/issues/791): four-action flow, semantic comparison, classifications, explicit resolution, source approval, disjoint-scope proof, verified rendering deduplication, unchanged publication. Claude discovery exception recorded above. | +| DRY | Fulfilled: host paths remain in tool-paths; assessment consumes that reference; catalogs are generated inventory. | +| Coherence | Fulfilled: router, renamed actions, R5 and catalogs agree; exact-body handoff and publish/delete bypass align; reference hash variants are disclosed. | +| Simplicity | Fulfilled: one assessment action, no CLI/writer changes or new abstraction; bounded project assessment excludes corpus audit #792. | +| Dead code / debug leftovers | Fulfilled: no unused shipped action, old action filename, debug output or silent TODO introduced. | +| Evidence integrity | Twelve fixture-content hashes equal recorded before maps; before/after maps equal native snapshots and current bytes; all twelve raw-event hashes match; final source hashes match source. Raw commands confirm read-only rendering verification and exact approved writer bodies; lifecycle deletion retains the documented empty AGENTS.md. | +| Validation | `git diff --check BASE HEAD` clean; unchanged writer/CLI diff exits 0; architecture guard checks seven files with no violation. Existing wrapped root suite and pre-push output inspected; full suite not redundantly rerun. | +| Limits | Model judgment is not a deterministic approval lock. Codex native skill runtime and five-host publication verified; native consumption by other hosts remains unproven and explicitly disclosed. Generic documented-import instruction already covers Claude imports; no additional finding. | +| Unchecked | none | +| Unplanned | none | diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md index dca7096fc..c85f4b94b 100644 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md @@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ Verified on 2026-10-12 against [issue #791](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/fra ## Behavior evidence -The old skill wrote the canonical rule and shared AGENTS contribution without the new assessment decision: [baseline receipt](receipts/baseline.json). The revised skill stopped before writing in all twelve fresh assessment runs. Every run exited successfully and its complete project-file SHA-256 map was unchanged. Classification was checked against the actual answer, not a phrase-presence test. +The old skill wrote the canonical rule and shared AGENTS contribution without the new assessment decision: [baseline receipt](receipts/baseline.json). The revised skill stopped before writing in all thirteen fresh assessment runs. Every run exited successfully and its complete project-file SHA-256 map was unchanged. Classification was checked against the actual answer, not a phrase-presence test. [Assessment receipts](receipts/native-assessment.json) include prompts, answers, original fixture contents, before/after hashes, installed-skill hashes and raw-event hashes. @@ -21,6 +21,7 @@ The old skill wrote the canonical rule and shared AGENTS contribution without th | Plugin-source pytest rule | Conflict detected without host publication. | | Copilot GEMINI guidance | Conflict detected from the project instruction source. | | Copilot repository instruction import | Imported policy read and conflict identified. | +| Claude-only local project policy | Conflict in CLAUDE.local.md detected before writes. | | Actual CLI flat Codex distribution | Conflict detected before writing through the installed skill. | The [nine-turn lifecycle](receipts/native-lifecycle.json) proves reassessment after a body change, no write before the subsequent approval, exact approved-body preservation, five-host publication, covered/keep and conflict/cancel without changes, byte-identical publication, and deletion. Deletion leaves an empty AGENTS.md, the existing writer behavior; it does not restore the original file inventory. @@ -31,6 +32,7 @@ The [three-turn merge](receipts/native-merge.json) proves an existing rule can b - Existing writer suite: 61 passed. Focused architecture, portability, links and writer checks: 117 passed, no failures or skips. - Full pre-commit gates: wrapped root suite `node scripts/check-tests-leave-git-alone.js -- node --test 'scripts/__tests__/**/*.test.js'`: 677 passed, no failures or skips. Recipe build and all three bundled recipe validations passed; catalog, link, duplication and referenced-path checks passed. +- Actual pre-push gates: Knip passed; CLI suite passed 7,002 tests across 539 test files, with one test/file skipped and no failures. The remote branch SHA matched the committed candidate. - `git diff 3e67f6f594b7b7f6cc7bceb0581ad6d515519080 --exit-code -- plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/scripts/write-rule.cjs cli`: no changes. Publication, ownership and CLI behavior remain the existing implementation. - `AIDD_SKIP_UPDATE_CHECK=1 node cli/dist/cli.js translate . --to codex --as flat --out ` and the Claude `--as marketplace` translation succeeded. Both distributions contain the four actions and unchanged writer; their four actions, two references and writer match source bytes. Old action filenames are absent. One native session used the actual flat distribution. @@ -40,6 +42,6 @@ The [three-turn merge](receipts/native-merge.json) proves an existing rule can b To repeat an assessment, materialize the recorded `fixtureFiles` in a disposable project, copy or translate the skill into a separate installed directory, substitute those two paths in the recorded prompt, snapshot every project file, then run the command above with that prompt on stdin. Compare complete before/after maps and inspect the answer against the fixture's policy obligations. To repeat the journeys, start a persistent session and supply the recorded follow-up prompts in order, retaining per-turn snapshots. -These receipts cover 24 successful native CLI invocations in 14 sessions: twelve fresh assessments and two persistent journeys. Exploratory runs, the old-skill baseline and the initial read-only harness failure are excluded from this count. Earlier eight-case runs preceded the bounded discovery-reference expansion; the four workflow actions and writer are byte-identical to the final version. Later Copilot, flat-distribution, scope and merge cases cover the expanded reference. Per-session hashes preserve this distinction; [final source hashes](receipts/final-source-hashes.json) identify the final assets. +These receipts cover 25 successful native CLI invocations in 15 sessions: thirteen fresh assessments and two persistent journeys. Exploratory runs, the old-skill baseline and the initial read-only harness failure are excluded from this count. Earlier eight-case runs preceded the bounded discovery-reference expansion; the four workflow actions and writer are byte-identical to the final version. Later Copilot, flat-distribution, scope, merge and Claude-local cases exercise the added discovery paths. Conditional Claude AGENTS activation was checked against documentation; it was not exercised in a native Claude session. Per-session hashes preserve this distinction; [final source hashes](receipts/final-source-hashes.json) identify the final assets. Semantic comparison is model judgment, not a deterministic conflict detector or a script-enforced approval lock. These runs exercise the skill through Codex and its five-host writer. They do not prove runtime instruction consumption by native Claude, Cursor, Copilot or OpenCode sessions. Relevant discovery contracts were checked against the official sources linked in the plan and tool-path reference. No claim of universal host precedence, full account/global discovery or coverage of every glob is made. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md index a9982d445..b27b39382 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md @@ -31,7 +31,7 @@ For action 02, this reference owns discovery paths. Discovery is read-only: neve | Confirmed host | Project sources to inspect | | --- | --- | -| Claude Code | `.claude/rules/**/*.md`, root and relevant nested `CLAUDE.md` and `.claude/CLAUDE.md` | +| Claude Code | `.claude/rules/**/*.md`; working-directory, project-ancestor and relevant descendant `CLAUDE.md`, `.claude/CLAUDE.md` and `CLAUDE.local.md`. Conditional working-directory/project-ancestor `AGENTS.md` and `.claude/AGENTS.md`, plus relevant nested `AGENTS.md`: confirm installed-version support, enabled built-in plugin, Project instructions mode and competing Claude instruction files before treating them as active. | | Cursor | root and relevant nested `.cursor/rules/**/*.mdc` and `AGENTS.md`; Cursor CLI also reads root `CLAUDE.md` | | GitHub Copilot | Repository root, current directory, intermediate directories and relevant file-path nested directories: `.github/copilot-instructions.md`, `AGENTS.md`, `CLAUDE.md`, `.claude/CLAUDE.md`, `GEMINI.md`. Also `.github/instructions/**/*.instructions.md` in those locations except intermediate directories; apply only matching `applyTo` scopes. | | Codex | Root and relevant nested directories: first nonempty file among `AGENTS.override.md`, `AGENTS.md`, then configured fallback names, in that order; unknown fallback configuration requires review when it could affect the candidate. | From 5ebc4c4c4285d1f286a50f08edc5ff3bd6239c38 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE Date: Mon, 12 Oct 2026 15:43:47 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 03/24] docs(aidd-context): record rule assessment review and evidence Record independent review and outcome challenge, mark the plan reviewed, and preserve reproducible native receipts and fixture teardown evidence. Refs #791 --- .../challenge.md | 16 ++++++++++ .../phase-1.md | 2 +- .../plan.md | 2 +- .../receipts/teardown.json | 23 +++++++++++++++ .../review.md | 29 +++++++++---------- .../verification.md | 6 ++++ 6 files changed, 61 insertions(+), 17 deletions(-) create mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/challenge.md create mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/teardown.json diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/challenge.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/challenge.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6d4bf0847 --- /dev/null +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/challenge.md @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +My confidence level of correctness now: 95% + +# Correctness (100%) +- Candidate `09af93daec18e5aced10b815958f29e3ce36aad0` satisfies the agreed outcome in [issue #791 and comments](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/framework/issues/791), [plan.md](plan.md) and [phase-1.md](phase-1.md): a complete candidate is compared before writing, and the user resolves the evidence before publication. All three trust answers are yes: the delivery is sound, its consequential choices are justified, and the observed journey serves the user's need. +- Placement is minimal: semantic comparison belongs to the context skill; supported-source discovery stays in its canonical tool-path reference. One action provides the guard without a new skill, CLI behavior, writer abstraction, corpus audit or universal precedence system. See [architecture](../../../../docs/ARCHITECTURE.md) and [cleared review](review.md). +- The decision concerns the complete body, metadata, scope, destinations and affected existing sources. Changed bodies and merge resolutions return to assessment and require a new decision. [Lifecycle](receipts/native-lifecycle.json) and [merge](receipts/native-merge.json) show actual approved-body preservation, no premature writes, and unchanged bytes after keep/cancel. +- Comparison serves policy consistency: it distinguishes semantic coverage, partial redundancy, conflict and missing evidence; excludes only justified disjoint scopes even without matching files; verifies rendered ownership/body/scope before deduplication; retains conflicting native edits. The complete answers, fixtures and byte snapshots in [assessment receipts](receipts/native-assessment.json) support these outcomes rather than merely matching classification phrases. +- The earlier Claude-source omission is repaired in the canonical reference. The Claude-only local-policy case detects pytest versus unittest in `CLAUDE.local.md` without writes. Conditional AGENTS activation remains conditional, with relevant unknown activation requiring review; it is not presented as native Claude runtime proof. +- Publication and refusal responsibilities remain with the unchanged writer. Explicit publish/delete keeps its original route, including explicit publication of manual canonical edits. Root/CLI regression output, repaired commit gates, source hashes and distribution byte checks are recorded in [verification.md](verification.md) and [review.md](review.md). +- Claims stay within evidence: native Codex sessions exercised the skill and five-host publication. No deterministic approval lock, universal host precedence, complete global discovery or native instruction consumption by other hosts is claimed. The documented limits do not contradict #791's agreed contract. + +# Deal breakers +- None. No contract contradiction or unresolved outcome failure; clearance for a draft PR. + +# Suggestions (enhancements only) +- Future native Claude coverage: repeat the local-policy fixture and a conditionally active AGENTS fixture in a fresh supported Claude session, recording version, activation mode, actual answer and byte snapshots. This would extend the already disclosed runtime evidence beyond Codex; it is optional follow-up, not a prerequisite for this PR. diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/phase-1.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/phase-1.md index 911283331..1fa614d99 100644 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/phase-1.md +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/phase-1.md @@ -1,5 +1,5 @@ --- -status: implemented +status: reviewed --- # Instruction: Assess and resolve a candidate before publication diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/plan.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/plan.md index ed5419553..88e293ad6 100644 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/plan.md +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/plan.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ --- objective: "Assess a candidate rule against applicable existing policies before any rule write, with an explicit resolution and unchanged publication behavior." -status: implemented +status: reviewed --- # Plan: Assess existing rules before writing diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/teardown.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/teardown.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..caddbf643 --- /dev/null +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/teardown.json @@ -0,0 +1,23 @@ +{ + "localArchive": "/private/tmp/aidd-791-reviewed-native-fixtures.tar.gz", + "archiveSHA256": "22aafc552fcca61833cdc6e37535ba1278923585dff72c5596b1c7125e2e6dfe", + "removedReviewedFixtures": [ + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-baseline-JPnRpI", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-f08cf2dd", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-kyf8vbhs", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-mdm66onm", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-njf20lfx", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ofdnwunc", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-pa64pbd1", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-qb2gmmss", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t4gu559a" + ], + "projectBaseline": "Original workspace personal changes preserved; all native project fixtures were disposable." +} diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/review.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/review.md index 4a3d5060a..8d497d878 100644 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/review.md +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/review.md @@ -1,42 +1,41 @@ # Review: Assess existing rules before writing -- **Verdict**: changes-requested -- **Diff**: `3e67f6f594b7b7f6cc7bceb0581ad6d515519080...f75d450681e8c7e49ae21da005278782ab4c9ee2` +- **Verdict**: approve +- **Diff**: `3e67f6f594b7b7f6cc7bceb0581ad6d515519080...09af93daec18e5aced10b815958f29e3ce36aad0` - **Axes run**: code, functional, relevancy - **Date**: 2026_10_12 -- **Findings**: 0 critical, 1 warning, 0 minor -- **Score**: 90/100; six plan criteria and four baseline checklist items fulfilled, reduced for one material discovery gap in the actual need. +- **Findings**: 0 critical, 0 warning, 0 minor +- **Score**: 100/100; six plan criteria, four baseline checklist items and the actual-need discovery check fulfilled. ## Phases ### Phase 1 — Assess, resolve, then preserve publication -- [x] No create/update write without assessment and explicit decision on the complete candidate. — `plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md:15`; `actions/03-write-rule.md:15`; baseline RED and twelve unchanged assessment snapshots in `receipts/baseline.json` and `receipts/native-assessment.json`. +- [x] No create/update write without assessment and explicit decision on the complete candidate. — `plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md:15`; `actions/03-write-rule.md:15`; baseline RED and thirteen unchanged assessment snapshots in `receipts/baseline.json` and `receipts/native-assessment.json`. - [x] Covered, overlap, conflict and needs-review findings cite sources; scope and canonical rendering exclusions are justified. — `actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md:16`; `references/tool-paths.md:44`; actual covered, overlap, edited-rendering, disjoint, uncertain and scope-uncertain answers and raw events in `receipts/native-assessment.json`. - [x] Changed resolution is assessed again; keep and cancel leave project bytes unchanged. — `actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md:26`; revise/keep/cancel snapshots in `receipts/native-lifecycle.json`; merge reassessment and exact approved update in `receipts/native-merge.json`. - [x] Publish/delete and five-host writer preserve existing behavior. — `SKILL.md:21`; `actions/01-capture-rule.md:16`; lifecycle publish/delete events and snapshots; `git diff BASE HEAD --exit-code -- plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/scripts/write-rule.cjs cli` exits 0. -- [x] Native receipts prove classifications and pre-decision no-write behavior, with honest limits. — `verification.md:7`; all twelve complete answers, fixture maps, raw-event SHA-256 values, on-disk snapshots and current fixture bytes checked; nine lifecycle and three merge answers match native JSONL events and prompts; `verification.md:43` discloses reference revisions and Codex-only skill execution. -- [x] Required gates pass; independent review has no critical blocking finding. — `/private/tmp/aidd-791-commit.log:4296` records 677 passed, 0 failed; `/private/tmp/aidd-791-push.log:129` records 7002 passed, 1 skipped; fresh architecture check reports seven governed files, no violation. The warning below requires repair before review clearance. +- [x] Native receipts prove classifications and pre-decision no-write behavior, with honest limits. — `verification.md:7`; all thirteen complete answers, fixture maps, raw-event SHA-256 values, on-disk snapshots and current fixture bytes checked; nine lifecycle and three merge answers match native JSONL events and prompts; `verification.md:45` discloses reference revisions, Codex-only skill execution and untested native Claude consumption. +- [x] Required gates pass; independent review has no unresolved blocking finding. — `/private/tmp/aidd-791-repair-commit.log:4296` records 677 passed, 0 failed, 0 skipped; `/private/tmp/aidd-791-push.log:129` records 7002 passed, 1 skipped; repair push skips unchanged CLI gates and succeeds; fresh architecture check reports seven governed files, no violation. ## Findings -| Sev | Kind | Phase | Location | Issue | Fix | -| --- | ---- | ----- | -------- | ----- | --- | -| warning | fit | 1 | `plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md:34` | Claude discovery omits project `CLAUDE.local.md` and conditionally loaded `AGENTS.md` / `.claude/AGENTS.md`. A Claude-only candidate can miss an applicable conflicting policy in these files and be classified new. [Official memory documentation](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/memory#how-claudemd-files-load) includes local files at the working directory, ancestors and relevant descendants; [AGENTS discovery](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/memory#when-claude-code-reads-agentsmd) is conditional on version, enabled support and instruction-file mode. This leaves #791's relevant-policy comparison incomplete despite all supplied fixtures passing. | Extend this canonical discovery row with `CLAUDE.local.md` and conditional `AGENTS.md` / `.claude/AGENTS.md` sources. Apply documented activation; reuse line 40's needs-review handling when activation is relevant and unknown. Add a disposable Claude-only local-guidance assessment receipt proving conflict or justified needs review without writes. Keep writer and host precedence unchanged. | +None. ## Verification | Metric | Value | | --- | --- | -| Verified | 100% (6/6 plan acceptance criteria); one additional actual-need warning remains. | -| Files checked | All 19 changed files; root `AGENTS.md`, `docs/ARCHITECTURE.md`, project coding assertions/testing memory; review actions/template/rubric/validator; unchanged writer seam; six JSON receipts; all 24 native answers and prompts with raw JSONL; commit/push logs; official documentation linked in tool-paths. | -| Contract | [Issue #791 and comments](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/framework/issues/791): four-action flow, semantic comparison, classifications, explicit resolution, source approval, disjoint-scope proof, verified rendering deduplication, unchanged publication. Claude discovery exception recorded above. | +| Verified | 100% (6/6 plan acceptance criteria); actual-need discovery gap repaired. | +| Files checked | All 20 changed files; root `AGENTS.md`, `docs/ARCHITECTURE.md`, project coding assertions/testing memory; review actions/template/rubric/validator; unchanged writer seam; six JSON receipts; all 25 native answers and prompts with raw JSONL; original and repair commit/push logs; official documentation linked in tool-paths; final Codex flat and Claude marketplace distributions. | +| Contract | [Issue #791 and comments](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/framework/issues/791): four-action flow, semantic comparison, classifications, explicit resolution, source approval, disjoint-scope proof, verified rendering deduplication, unchanged publication. All checked against the final candidate; no remaining need-gap found. | | DRY | Fulfilled: host paths remain in tool-paths; assessment consumes that reference; catalogs are generated inventory. | | Coherence | Fulfilled: router, renamed actions, R5 and catalogs agree; exact-body handoff and publish/delete bypass align; reference hash variants are disclosed. | | Simplicity | Fulfilled: one assessment action, no CLI/writer changes or new abstraction; bounded project assessment excludes corpus audit #792. | | Dead code / debug leftovers | Fulfilled: no unused shipped action, old action filename, debug output or silent TODO introduced. | -| Evidence integrity | Twelve fixture-content hashes equal recorded before maps; before/after maps equal native snapshots and current bytes; all twelve raw-event hashes match; final source hashes match source. Raw commands confirm read-only rendering verification and exact approved writer bodies; lifecycle deletion retains the documented empty AGENTS.md. | -| Validation | `git diff --check BASE HEAD` clean; unchanged writer/CLI diff exits 0; architecture guard checks seven files with no violation. Existing wrapped root suite and pre-push output inspected; full suite not redundantly rerun. | +| Evidence integrity | Thirteen fixture-content hashes equal recorded before maps; before/after maps equal native snapshots and current bytes; all thirteen raw-event hashes match; final source hashes match source. Claude-local receipt's installed skill equals final source. Raw commands confirm read-only rendering verification and exact approved writer bodies; lifecycle deletion retains the documented empty AGENTS.md. | +| Discovery repair | Fulfilled: `references/tool-paths.md:34` includes local Claude guidance and conditional AGENTS sources; unknown relevant activation remains needs review at line 40. [Official local-file loading](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/memory#how-claudemd-files-load) and [conditional AGENTS discovery](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/memory#when-claude-code-reads-agentsmd) checked again. Claude-only receipt reports pytest/unittest conflict from CLAUDE.local.md without writes. | +| Validation | `git diff --check BASE HEAD` clean; unchanged writer/CLI diff exits 0; four actions/router/writer unchanged by repair; architecture guard checks seven files with no violation. Actual repair wrapped root suite passes 677 tests. Original pre-push output inspected; repair push succeeds with unchanged CLI gates skipped. Final distributions' four actions, two references, template and writer match source bytes; old action filenames absent. Full suite not redundantly rerun. | | Limits | Model judgment is not a deterministic approval lock. Codex native skill runtime and five-host publication verified; native consumption by other hosts remains unproven and explicitly disclosed. Generic documented-import instruction already covers Claude imports; no additional finding. | | Unchecked | none | | Unplanned | none | diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md index c85f4b94b..e7d7394b2 100644 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md @@ -45,3 +45,9 @@ To repeat an assessment, materialize the recorded `fixtureFiles` in a disposable These receipts cover 25 successful native CLI invocations in 15 sessions: thirteen fresh assessments and two persistent journeys. Exploratory runs, the old-skill baseline and the initial read-only harness failure are excluded from this count. Earlier eight-case runs preceded the bounded discovery-reference expansion; the four workflow actions and writer are byte-identical to the final version. Later Copilot, flat-distribution, scope, merge and Claude-local cases exercise the added discovery paths. Conditional Claude AGENTS activation was checked against documentation; it was not exercised in a native Claude session. Per-session hashes preserve this distinction; [final source hashes](receipts/final-source-hashes.json) identify the final assets. Semantic comparison is model judgment, not a deterministic conflict detector or a script-enforced approval lock. These runs exercise the skill through Codex and its five-host writer. They do not prove runtime instruction consumption by native Claude, Cursor, Copilot or OpenCode sessions. Relevant discovery contracts were checked against the official sources linked in the plan and tool-path reference. No claim of universal host precedence, full account/global discovery or coverage of every glob is made. + +## Independent judgment and teardown + +The [three-axis review](review.md) approves the repaired candidate with no remaining finding. The [independent outcome challenge](challenge.md) records 95% confidence and no deal breaker. Its optional follow-up is a native Claude journey covering local guidance and conditional AGENTS loading; this is carried onto the PR as a coverage limit, not claimed as completed. + +The fifteen reviewed native sessions and old-skill baseline were archived locally, then their disposable fixture directories removed. [Teardown receipt](receipts/teardown.json) records archive hash and removed roots. Historical root paths in receipts identify the tested sessions; the committed fixture contents, prompts, answers and hashes remain available for reproduction. The original workspace retains its personal .gitignore change and untracked .hermes.md; neither was edited. From 57ab25319943c0ef8018dabd77fe55c555a6964d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE Date: Mon, 12 Oct 2026 22:04:38 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 04/24] docs(aidd-context): remove rule contract timestamp --- .../receipts/concise-native.json | 15 ++++++++++++++- .../receipts/final-source-hashes.json | 14 +++++++------- .../verification.md | 8 ++++++-- .../05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md | 2 +- 4 files changed, 28 insertions(+), 11 deletions(-) diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/concise-native.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/concise-native.json index 1086b0216..66bc130c7 100644 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/concise-native.json +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/concise-native.json @@ -914,5 +914,18 @@ "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" } } - ] + ], + "finalSourceHashes": { + "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", + "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", + "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", + "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", + "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", + "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", + "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", + "references/tool-paths.md": "2232eeb18c56dce6486526b801a1b3945d2fb8e8aa0fb860dc9340fc9a2fe47a", + "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" + }, + "finalWords": 1766, + "postReplayChange": "Removed only the nonnormative Checked 2026-10-12: prefix from Official contracts; all policy instructions and links unchanged." } diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/final-source-hashes.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/final-source-hashes.json index a3a347bf4..5f17f0871 100644 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/final-source-hashes.json +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/final-source-hashes.json @@ -1,11 +1,11 @@ { - "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", - "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", + "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", + "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", + "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", + "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", + "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", - "references/tool-paths.md": "8b985e2a360c5fa44d13742e8f79c92afb8ddf2c8e2a6b0083fffbd84bf0f13e", + "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", + "references/tool-paths.md": "2232eeb18c56dce6486526b801a1b3945d2fb8e8aa0fb860dc9340fc9a2fe47a", "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" } diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md index 4b4298a18..e703bb0d2 100644 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md @@ -4,11 +4,11 @@ Issue [#791](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/framework/issues/791); current bas ## Concision -Following Alex’s [#981](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/framework/pull/981) and [#950](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/framework/pull/950): seven runtime Markdown files, 3,480 → 1,768 whitespace-delimited words (−49%). Assessment: 597 → 236. The unchanged 43-word template is excluded from both totals. Flow belongs to the router; each action or reference owns its constraints. +Following Alex’s [#981](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/framework/pull/981) and [#950](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/framework/pull/950): seven runtime Markdown files, 3,480 → 1,766 whitespace-delimited words (−49%). Assessment: 597 → 236. The unchanged 43-word template is excluded from both totals. Flow belongs to the router; each action or reference owns its constraints. ## Evidence -[Concise replay](receipts/concise-native.json) records final-source hashes, prompts, answers, fixture data and project snapshots. Codex 0.162.1 used ChatGPT login with API keys unset: 27 successful calls across 17 sessions. +[Concise replay](receipts/concise-native.json) records tested/final-source hashes, prompts, answers, fixture data and project snapshots. Codex 0.162.1 used ChatGPT login with API keys unset: 27 successful calls across 17 sessions. - Fifteen fresh assessments stop without changing project bytes: new, covered, overlap, conflict, disjoint, uncertain meaning/scope, edited rendering, plugin source, Copilot guidance/import, Claude local guidance, OpenCode V1 configured instructions/fallback, and actual CLI flat Codex distribution. - Nine-turn lifecycle: reassess changed body, require subsequent approval, publish exact body to five hosts, covered/keep, conflict/cancel, byte-identical republish, delete. Existing deletion behavior retains empty AGENTS.md. @@ -16,6 +16,10 @@ Following Alex’s [#981](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/framework/pull/981) a Root regression command: `node scripts/check-tests-leave-git-alone.js -- node --test 'scripts/__tests__/**/*.test.js'`: 681 passed, zero failures/skips. Focused checks: 107 passed, including 61 writer tests. CLI flat Codex and Claude marketplace translations preserve action, reference, template and writer bytes. Writer and CLI have no diff against the current base. +Pre-push gates: Knip passed; CLI suite passed 7,025 tests across 540 files, with one test/file skipped. + +The only post-replay runtime edit removes a nonnormative verification-date prefix. Policy instructions and official links remain byte-identical; receipts distinguish both hashes. + ## Limits Semantic comparison remains model judgment. Approval is a skill instruction, not a script lock. Native replay uses Codex; publication to five hosts does not prove their native runtime consumption. Official discovery sources are linked in `plan.md` and the skill’s tool-path reference. Historical receipts retain their earlier source/runtime hashes and are not evidence for the shortened version. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md index 562631aa5..1671386d9 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md @@ -94,4 +94,4 @@ node "$installed_rule_script" --project "$project_root" --tools claude,cursor,co ## Official contracts -Checked 2026-10-12: [Claude](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/memory), [Cursor](https://cursor.com/docs/rules), [Cursor CLI](https://cursor.com/docs/cli/using#rules), [Copilot CLI](https://docs.github.com/en/copilot/how-tos/copilot-cli/customize-copilot/add-custom-instructions), [Codex](https://learn.chatgpt.com/docs/agent-configuration/agents-md), [OpenCode V1](https://opencode.ai/docs/rules/), [OpenCode V2](https://opencode.ai/v2/docs/instructions/). +[Claude](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/memory), [Cursor](https://cursor.com/docs/rules), [Cursor CLI](https://cursor.com/docs/cli/using#rules), [Copilot CLI](https://docs.github.com/en/copilot/how-tos/copilot-cli/customize-copilot/add-custom-instructions), [Codex](https://learn.chatgpt.com/docs/agent-configuration/agents-md), [OpenCode V1](https://opencode.ai/docs/rules/), [OpenCode V2](https://opencode.ai/v2/docs/instructions/). From 26c6c9cb414c28a29bed5116942c614e2f7c8c40 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE Date: Mon, 12 Oct 2026 22:08:39 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 05/24] docs(aidd-context): record concise skill verification --- .../challenge.md | 13 ++---- .../phase-1.md | 2 +- .../plan.md | 2 +- .../receipts/concise-teardown.json | 24 +++++++++++ .../review.md | 42 +++++++++---------- .../verification.md | 2 +- 6 files changed, 52 insertions(+), 33 deletions(-) create mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/concise-teardown.json diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/challenge.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/challenge.md index 6d4bf0847..ec114a2ea 100644 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/challenge.md +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/challenge.md @@ -1,16 +1,11 @@ My confidence level of correctness now: 95% # Correctness (100%) -- Candidate `09af93daec18e5aced10b815958f29e3ce36aad0` satisfies the agreed outcome in [issue #791 and comments](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/framework/issues/791), [plan.md](plan.md) and [phase-1.md](phase-1.md): a complete candidate is compared before writing, and the user resolves the evidence before publication. All three trust answers are yes: the delivery is sound, its consequential choices are justified, and the observed journey serves the user's need. -- Placement is minimal: semantic comparison belongs to the context skill; supported-source discovery stays in its canonical tool-path reference. One action provides the guard without a new skill, CLI behavior, writer abstraction, corpus audit or universal precedence system. See [architecture](../../../../docs/ARCHITECTURE.md) and [cleared review](review.md). -- The decision concerns the complete body, metadata, scope, destinations and affected existing sources. Changed bodies and merge resolutions return to assessment and require a new decision. [Lifecycle](receipts/native-lifecycle.json) and [merge](receipts/native-merge.json) show actual approved-body preservation, no premature writes, and unchanged bytes after keep/cancel. -- Comparison serves policy consistency: it distinguishes semantic coverage, partial redundancy, conflict and missing evidence; excludes only justified disjoint scopes even without matching files; verifies rendered ownership/body/scope before deduplication; retains conflicting native edits. The complete answers, fixtures and byte snapshots in [assessment receipts](receipts/native-assessment.json) support these outcomes rather than merely matching classification phrases. -- The earlier Claude-source omission is repaired in the canonical reference. The Claude-only local-policy case detects pytest versus unittest in `CLAUDE.local.md` without writes. Conditional AGENTS activation remains conditional, with relevant unknown activation requiring review; it is not presented as native Claude runtime proof. -- Publication and refusal responsibilities remain with the unchanged writer. Explicit publish/delete keeps its original route, including explicit publication of manual canonical edits. Root/CLI regression output, repaired commit gates, source hashes and distribution byte checks are recorded in [verification.md](verification.md) and [review.md](review.md). -- Claims stay within evidence: native Codex sessions exercised the skill and five-host publication. No deterministic approval lock, universal host precedence, complete global discovery or native instruction consumption by other hosts is claimed. The documented limits do not contradict #791's agreed contract. +- Final candidate `57ab25319943c0ef8018dabd77fe55c555a6964d`: [review](review.md) verifies every scoped criterion. Concision preserves the approval seam and deterministic publication; no contract gap. +- All consequential choices supported. Native evidence proves Codex behavior; other hosts' consumption remains explicitly unclaimed. Final reference differs from replay only by the removed date prefix. # Deal breakers -- None. No contract contradiction or unresolved outcome failure; clearance for a draft PR. +- None. # Suggestions (enhancements only) -- Future native Claude coverage: repeat the local-policy fixture and a conditionally active AGENTS fixture in a fresh supported Claude session, recording version, activation mode, actual answer and byte snapshots. This would extend the already disclosed runtime evidence beyond Codex; it is optional follow-up, not a prerequisite for this PR. +- Optional: replace the router's read sentence with `Read numbered action files in actions/ before executing them.` Same word count; preserves bare action rows. All 15 assessment traces first tried an unnumbered filename, recovered via discovery, then completed correctly. No runtime change required for this verdict. diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/phase-1.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/phase-1.md index b104aa625..de432ea61 100644 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/phase-1.md +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/phase-1.md @@ -1,5 +1,5 @@ --- -status: implemented +status: reviewed --- # Instruction: Assess and resolve a candidate before publication diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/plan.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/plan.md index 286c095be..574e35593 100644 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/plan.md +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/plan.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ --- objective: "Assess a candidate rule against applicable existing policies before any rule write, with an explicit resolution and unchanged publication behavior." -status: implemented +status: reviewed --- # Plan: Assess existing rules before writing diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/concise-teardown.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/concise-teardown.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1a8e3714f --- /dev/null +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/concise-teardown.json @@ -0,0 +1,24 @@ +{ + "archive": "/private/tmp/aidd-791-concise-native-fixtures.tar.gz", + "sha256": "e6fbb48c23eae557d0c679820108515df23a4d1743159ad085572896b697a01f", + "roots": [ + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-x77f_xve", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t2mk22qs", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-2p0h3ldp", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-5qhld3dc", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-3hcgdbdf", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0oqnbaf8", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-y0jh35oc", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k3ov3cw3", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-p4nc5tel", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-cpisqs8a", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-9q4boz6g", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ht1ibk1j", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-1qr4_na3", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ix2qi3kg", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-lmi51ec7", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-vga1bx6l", + "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-x38wqtp1" + ], + "removed": true +} diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/review.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/review.md index 8d497d878..cda8a5f11 100644 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/review.md +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/review.md @@ -1,41 +1,41 @@ -# Review: Assess existing rules before writing +# Review: Rule assessment and concision - **Verdict**: approve -- **Diff**: `3e67f6f594b7b7f6cc7bceb0581ad6d515519080...09af93daec18e5aced10b815958f29e3ce36aad0` +- **Diff**: `ce80635221266dd7529d0bdc4fa98d15b9ddeb6c...57ab25319943c0ef8018dabd77fe55c555a6964d` - **Axes run**: code, functional, relevancy - **Date**: 2026_10_12 - **Findings**: 0 critical, 0 warning, 0 minor -- **Score**: 100/100; six plan criteria, four baseline checklist items and the actual-need discovery check fulfilled. +- **Score**: 100% of scoped criteria fulfilled ## Phases -### Phase 1 — Assess, resolve, then preserve publication +### Phase 1 — Assess, resolve, preserve publication -- [x] No create/update write without assessment and explicit decision on the complete candidate. — `plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md:15`; `actions/03-write-rule.md:15`; baseline RED and thirteen unchanged assessment snapshots in `receipts/baseline.json` and `receipts/native-assessment.json`. -- [x] Covered, overlap, conflict and needs-review findings cite sources; scope and canonical rendering exclusions are justified. — `actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md:16`; `references/tool-paths.md:44`; actual covered, overlap, edited-rendering, disjoint, uncertain and scope-uncertain answers and raw events in `receipts/native-assessment.json`. -- [x] Changed resolution is assessed again; keep and cancel leave project bytes unchanged. — `actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md:26`; revise/keep/cancel snapshots in `receipts/native-lifecycle.json`; merge reassessment and exact approved update in `receipts/native-merge.json`. -- [x] Publish/delete and five-host writer preserve existing behavior. — `SKILL.md:21`; `actions/01-capture-rule.md:16`; lifecycle publish/delete events and snapshots; `git diff BASE HEAD --exit-code -- plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/scripts/write-rule.cjs cli` exits 0. -- [x] Native receipts prove classifications and pre-decision no-write behavior, with honest limits. — `verification.md:7`; all thirteen complete answers, fixture maps, raw-event SHA-256 values, on-disk snapshots and current fixture bytes checked; nine lifecycle and three merge answers match native JSONL events and prompts; `verification.md:45` discloses reference revisions, Codex-only skill execution and untested native Claude consumption. -- [x] Required gates pass; independent review has no unresolved blocking finding. — `/private/tmp/aidd-791-repair-commit.log:4296` records 677 passed, 0 failed, 0 skipped; `/private/tmp/aidd-791-push.log:129` records 7002 passed, 1 skipped; repair push skips unchanged CLI gates and succeeds; fresh architecture check reports seven governed files, no violation. +- [x] Complete candidate assessed and explicitly approved before create/update writes: `actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md:13`, `actions/03-write-rule.md:13`. +- [x] Five classifications cite sources and justify scope/rendering exclusions: `actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md:17`, `references/tool-paths.md:24`. +- [x] Changed resolutions require reassessment/approval; keep/cancel preserves bytes: `actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md:32`, `receipts/concise-native.json:614`, `:681`, `:731`, `:838`. +- [x] Publish/delete bypass preserved; five-host writer and CLI unchanged versus base: `SKILL.md:13`, `actions/01-capture-rule.md:14`, `references/tool-paths.md:46`; empty writer/CLI diff. +- [x] Native evidence covers required cases and uncertainty: `receipts/concise-native.json:29`. Read all 27 answers; verified event hashes, installed assets and 15 unchanged project snapshots against disk. +- [x] Required gates green; no unresolved blocker: final commit log `# pass 681`, `# fail 0`; pre-push Knip green, 7,025 CLI tests passed, one skipped. +- [x] User's concision revision preserves contracts and newer host support: seven runtime files total 1,766 words; assessment 236. Router owns flow, references own shared constraints; OpenCode V1/V2 discovery retained. ## Findings +| Sev | Kind | Phase | Location | Issue | Fix | +| --- | ---- | ----- | -------- | ----- | --- | + None. ## Verification | Metric | Value | | --- | --- | -| Verified | 100% (6/6 plan acceptance criteria); actual-need discovery gap repaired. | -| Files checked | All 20 changed files; root `AGENTS.md`, `docs/ARCHITECTURE.md`, project coding assertions/testing memory; review actions/template/rubric/validator; unchanged writer seam; six JSON receipts; all 25 native answers and prompts with raw JSONL; original and repair commit/push logs; official documentation linked in tool-paths; final Codex flat and Claude marketplace distributions. | -| Contract | [Issue #791 and comments](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/framework/issues/791): four-action flow, semantic comparison, classifications, explicit resolution, source approval, disjoint-scope proof, verified rendering deduplication, unchanged publication. All checked against the final candidate; no remaining need-gap found. | -| DRY | Fulfilled: host paths remain in tool-paths; assessment consumes that reference; catalogs are generated inventory. | -| Coherence | Fulfilled: router, renamed actions, R5 and catalogs agree; exact-body handoff and publish/delete bypass align; reference hash variants are disclosed. | -| Simplicity | Fulfilled: one assessment action, no CLI/writer changes or new abstraction; bounded project assessment excludes corpus audit #792. | -| Dead code / debug leftovers | Fulfilled: no unused shipped action, old action filename, debug output or silent TODO introduced. | -| Evidence integrity | Thirteen fixture-content hashes equal recorded before maps; before/after maps equal native snapshots and current bytes; all thirteen raw-event hashes match; final source hashes match source. Claude-local receipt's installed skill equals final source. Raw commands confirm read-only rendering verification and exact approved writer bodies; lifecycle deletion retains the documented empty AGENTS.md. | -| Discovery repair | Fulfilled: `references/tool-paths.md:34` includes local Claude guidance and conditional AGENTS sources; unknown relevant activation remains needs review at line 40. [Official local-file loading](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/memory#how-claudemd-files-load) and [conditional AGENTS discovery](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/memory#when-claude-code-reads-agentsmd) checked again. Claude-only receipt reports pytest/unittest conflict from CLAUDE.local.md without writes. | -| Validation | `git diff --check BASE HEAD` clean; unchanged writer/CLI diff exits 0; four actions/router/writer unchanged by repair; architecture guard checks seven files with no violation. Actual repair wrapped root suite passes 677 tests. Original pre-push output inspected; repair push succeeds with unchanged CLI gates skipped. Final distributions' four actions, two references, template and writer match source bytes; old action filenames absent. Full suite not redundantly rerun. | -| Limits | Model judgment is not a deterministic approval lock. Codex native skill runtime and five-host publication verified; native consumption by other hosts remains unproven and explicitly disclosed. Generic documented-import instruction already covers Claude imports; no additional finding. | +| Verified | 100% (7/7 acceptance criteria) | +| Files checked | Seven runtime Markdown files under `plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/`; unchanged template; both catalogs; plan, phase, verification and receipt evidence; writer/CLI diff | +| Checklist | DRY, coherence, minimality, no dead/debug content: fulfilled; architecture and applicable authoring rules checked | +| Gates | `/private/tmp/aidd-791-short-cleanup-commit.log`, `/private/tmp/aidd-791-short-push.log`; no duplicate test/model runs | +| Distribution | Final Codex flat and Claude marketplace actions, references, template and writer byte-identical; flat router changes only frontmatter serialization/name | +| Replay boundary | Tested hashes retained separately from final hashes. Only post-replay runtime difference removes the verification-date prefix; all final hashes checked | +| Limits | Semantic judgment and approval remain instructions, not writer locks. Native execution: Codex only; other hosts' native consumption unproven | | Unchecked | none | | Unplanned | none | diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md index e703bb0d2..be830ac3c 100644 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md @@ -24,4 +24,4 @@ The only post-replay runtime edit removes a nonnormative verification-date prefi Semantic comparison remains model judgment. Approval is a skill instruction, not a script lock. Native replay uses Codex; publication to five hosts does not prove their native runtime consumption. Official discovery sources are linked in `plan.md` and the skill’s tool-path reference. Historical receipts retain their earlier source/runtime hashes and are not evidence for the shortened version. -Independent verdict: [review](review.md), [challenge](challenge.md). Disposable fixtures remain available until that check finishes; teardown is recorded separately. +Independent verdict: [review](review.md), [challenge](challenge.md). Independent review approves all seven criteria; outcome confidence 95%, no deal breaker. The 17 replay fixtures were archived locally and removed: [teardown](receipts/concise-teardown.json). From 7af9e1603394347d0e51452235d0553a09163aae Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE Date: Mon, 12 Oct 2026 22:23:27 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 06/24] refactor(aidd-context): keep rule generation minimal Keep delivery evidence local; retain plugin-source writing separately from host publication. --- .../backlog-link.json | 5 - .../challenge.md | 11 - .../phase-1.md | 100 -- .../plan.md | 37 - .../receipts/baseline.json | 10 - .../receipts/concise-native.json | 931 ------------------ .../receipts/concise-teardown.json | 24 - .../receipts/final-source-hashes.json | 11 - .../receipts/native-assessment.json | 915 ----------------- .../receipts/native-lifecycle.json | 220 ----- .../receipts/native-merge.json | 97 -- .../receipts/runtime.json | 6 - .../receipts/teardown.json | 23 - .../review.md | 41 - .../verification.md | 27 - .../skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md | 2 +- .../actions/01-capture-rule.md | 17 +- .../actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md | 42 +- .../05-rule-generate/actions/03-write-rule.md | 15 +- .../05-rule-generate/actions/04-validate.md | 14 +- .../05-rule-generate/assets/rule-template.md | 9 +- .../references/rule-authoring.md | 43 +- .../05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md | 102 +- 23 files changed, 84 insertions(+), 2618 deletions(-) delete mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/backlog-link.json delete mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/challenge.md delete mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/phase-1.md delete mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/plan.md delete mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/baseline.json delete mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/concise-native.json delete mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/concise-teardown.json delete mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/final-source-hashes.json delete mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-assessment.json delete mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-lifecycle.json delete mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-merge.json delete mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/runtime.json delete mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/teardown.json delete mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/review.md delete mode 100644 aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/backlog-link.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/backlog-link.json deleted file mode 100644 index be8f889dd..000000000 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/backlog-link.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "backlog": "ai-driven-dev/framework#791", - "written_at": "2026-10-12T12:53:33Z", - "written_by": "aidd-dev:01-plan" -} diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/challenge.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/challenge.md deleted file mode 100644 index ec114a2ea..000000000 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/challenge.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,11 +0,0 @@ -My confidence level of correctness now: 95% - -# Correctness (100%) -- Final candidate `57ab25319943c0ef8018dabd77fe55c555a6964d`: [review](review.md) verifies every scoped criterion. Concision preserves the approval seam and deterministic publication; no contract gap. -- All consequential choices supported. Native evidence proves Codex behavior; other hosts' consumption remains explicitly unclaimed. Final reference differs from replay only by the removed date prefix. - -# Deal breakers -- None. - -# Suggestions (enhancements only) -- Optional: replace the router's read sentence with `Read numbered action files in actions/ before executing them.` Same word count; preserves bare action rows. All 15 assessment traces first tried an unnumbered filename, recovered via discovery, then completed correctly. No runtime change required for this verdict. diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/phase-1.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/phase-1.md deleted file mode 100644 index de432ea61..000000000 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/phase-1.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,100 +0,0 @@ ---- -status: reviewed ---- - -# Instruction: Assess and resolve a candidate before publication - -## Architecture projection - -```txt -plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/ - SKILL.md modify: route four actions - actions/01-capture-rule.md modify: retain publish/delete bypass - actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md create: read-only assessment and decision - actions/03-write-rule.md rename/modify: consume approved candidate - actions/04-validate.md rename/modify: validate the resolved result - references/tool-paths.md modify: canonical discovery authority - references/rule-authoring.md modify only if existing R5 needs explicit cross-rule scope -docs/CATALOG.md modify: action count -plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md regenerate: current action inventory -aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/ - verification.md create: behavior receipts and limits - review.md create: independent review -``` - -## User Journey - -```mermaid -flowchart TD - A[Capture confirmed intent and hosts] --> B[Draft candidate in context] - B --> C[Read relevant existing policies] - C --> D[Classify and show evidence] - D --> E[Explicit user decision] - E -->|revise candidate| B - E -->|approve exact candidate| F[Existing writer and validation] - E -->|keep existing or cancel| G[No write] -``` - -## Test Scope - -```mermaid ---- -title: Rule assessment behavior ---- -journey - section Setup - Prepare disposable project rules and byte snapshots => fixed baseline: 5: system - section Happy path - New candidate => new classification and no write before decision: 5: cli - Explicit candidate approval => existing writer publishes complete body: 5: cli - section Edge case - covered - Same policy with different title => existing source identified and keep causes no write: 1: cli - section Edge case - overlap - Partial compatible redundancy => overlap and explicit resolution: 1: cli - section Edge case - conflict - Pytest versus unittest on identical scope => conflict before write: 1: cli - section Edge case - scope - Provably disjoint scopes => exclude irrelevant policy: 1: cli - Uncertain scope applicability => needs review rather than assumed exclusion: 1: cli - section Edge case - canonical fan-out - One canonical rule rendered for several hosts => one logical policy: 1: cli - section Edge case - lifecycle - Existing publish or delete => unchanged ownership and lifecycle validation: 1: cli - section Teardown - Remove disposable fixtures => project baseline untouched: 5: system -``` - -## Tasks to do - -### `1)` Define the pre-write seam - -> Keep one source of truth for supported discovery and one assessed candidate for writing. - -1. Add the assessment action and update routing, names, handoffs and catalogs. -2. Prepare the complete candidate in context before comparing it, not on disk. -3. Discover project rules through the existing tool-path reference, including canonical sources and relevant user guidance; do not add host paths in the action. -4. Compare policy, scope, conditions and priority. Exclude only proven disjoint scopes and verified renderings of the same canonical policy. -5. Report new, covered, overlap, conflict or needs review with supporting files; require an explicit decision even for new. -6. Reassess any changed candidate, preserve unchanged publish/delete routing, and retain every writer safety/refusal contract. - -### `2)` Prove behavior and integration - -> Exercise the actual skill in disposable projects and preserve evidence of refusal before approval. - -1. Run focused architecture, links and existing writer regression tests. -2. Exercise the journey with subscription-backed native sessions only, with no paid API fallback, and compare before/after project bytes. -3. Run the existing pre-commit and applicable pre-push gates, including generated catalogs. -4. Obtain independent review and final outcome challenge; repair actionable findings. - -## Test acceptance criteria - -User revision: shorten the loaded router, actions and references. Remove repetition without weakening these criteria; retain newer host support from `next`. Measure words and rerun native journeys before review. - -| Task | Acceptance criteria | -| --- | --- | -| 1 | No create/update write occurs without an explicit assessment and decision about the complete candidate. | -| 1 | Covered, overlap, conflict and needs-review results cite involved sources; scope and canonical rendering exclusions are justified. | -| 1 | A changed resolution is assessed again; keeping an existing policy and cancelling leave project bytes unchanged. | -| 1 | Publish/delete and the installed five-host writer retain their existing behavior. | -| 2 | Native-session receipts show classification and no-write behavior for the specified cases, with uncertain results recorded honestly. | -| 2 | Required gates pass and independent judgment has no unresolved blocking finding. | diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/plan.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/plan.md deleted file mode 100644 index 574e35593..000000000 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/plan.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,37 +0,0 @@ ---- -objective: "Assess a candidate rule against applicable existing policies before any rule write, with an explicit resolution and unchanged publication behavior." -status: reviewed ---- - -# Plan: Assess existing rules before writing - -## Overview - -| Field | Value | -| --- | --- | -| **Goal** | Add the pre-write semantic assessment to the existing rule generator. | -| **Source** | [Issue #791](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/framework/issues/791), including its agreed four-action flow and comments. | - -## Phases - -| # | Phase | File | -| --- | --- | --- | -| 1 | Assess, resolve, then preserve publication | [phase-1.md](phase-1.md) | - -## Resources - -| Source | Verified | -| --- | --- | -| [Codex instruction discovery](https://learn.chatgpt.com/docs/agent-configuration/agents-md) | Directory-scoped instructions and override precedence. | -| [OpenCode V2 instructions](https://opencode.ai/v2/docs/instructions/) | Root and nested instructions are combined; both versions publish to AGENTS.md. | -| [OpenCode V1 rules](https://opencode.ai/docs/rules/) | Configured instructions and enabled CLAUDE.md fallback are assessment sources. | -| [Claude Code memory](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/memory) | Project rules can be path-scoped and project guidance must be considered. | -| [Cursor rules](https://cursor.com/docs/rules) | Project rules and nested project guidance have applicability conditions. | -| [Copilot CLI instructions](https://docs.github.com/en/copilot/how-tos/copilot-cli/customize-copilot/add-custom-instructions) | Repository-wide and path-specific instructions are separate sources. | - -## Decisions - -| Decision | Why | -| --- | --- | -| Semantic assessment belongs to the skill; the existing writer remains unchanged. | Comparing policies requires interpretation; deterministic publication and ownership remain the script's responsibility. | -| Shorten the loaded skill using Alex's [#981](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/framework/pull/981) and [#950](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/framework/pull/950). | One fact per owner; short actions; no repeated checks. Baseline: 3,480 words. Preserve the behavior and newer `next` changes. | diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/baseline.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/baseline.json deleted file mode 100644 index 934929bdf..000000000 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/baseline.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,10 +0,0 @@ -{ - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-baseline-JPnRpI/installed/SKILL.md and follow its actions in order. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, host project /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-baseline-JPnRpI/project, Codex only, create category 01-standards, slug 1-constants, description Constants, scope src/**/*.ts. Candidate body exactly: # Constants\n\n- Name constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\n. Create this rule. Do not edit application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. No later user message is supplied in this invocation; if the skill needs a further decision, stop and report it.", - "answer": "Created exact rule for Codex, scoped to `src/**/*.ts`.\n\n- PASS: `aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md`\n- PASS: `AGENTS.md`\n\nRepeat publication was byte-identical. Runtime consumption not tested.", - "expectation": "No rule write before assessment decision", - "result": "RED", - "unexpectedFiles": [ - "AGENTS.md", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md" - ] -} diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/concise-native.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/concise-native.json deleted file mode 100644 index 66bc130c7..000000000 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/concise-native.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,931 +0,0 @@ -{ - "runtime": { - "codex": "codex-cli 0.162.1", - "auth": "ChatGPT login", - "apiKeys": "unset", - "calls": 27, - "sessions": 17 - }, - "sourceHashes": { - "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", - "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", - "references/tool-paths.md": "70d7e97bc814d69fb030186ce2f30350001e9c3621b2d40efccabc63105bd70e", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "words": { - "before": 3480, - "after": 1768, - "assessmentBefore": 597, - "assessmentAfter": 236, - "method": "whitespace; seven runtime Markdown files, unchanged template excluded" - }, - "assessments": [ - { - "case": "new", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-x77f_xve", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-x77f_xve/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-x77f_xve/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"01-standards\", \"slug\": \"1-constants\", \"description\": \"Constants\", \"paths\": [\"src/**/*.ts\"], \"body\": \"# Constants\\n\\n- Name constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Candidate:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"01-standards\",\"slug\":\"1-constants\",\"description\":\"Constants\",\"paths\":[\"src/**/*.ts\"],\"body\":\"# Constants\\n\\n- Name constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n\"}\n```\n\nFinding: **new**. No existing rule files or ancestor guidance found. Supplied guidance contains no constants naming policy. Scope covers future `src/**/*.ts` files.\n\nTargets: Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2; the latter two share root `AGENTS.md`.\n\nNo files changed. Choose **approve**, **keep**, **revise**, **merge/replace**, or **cancel**.\n\n[Skill action 02]( /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-x77f_xve/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cShow complete candidates and findings; await explicit resolution, even for **new**.\u201d Your confirmed capture choices do not satisfy this later decision.", - "before": { - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "fixtureFiles": { - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" - }, - "installedHashes": { - "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", - "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", - "references/tool-paths.md": "70d7e97bc814d69fb030186ce2f30350001e9c3621b2d40efccabc63105bd70e", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "eventsSHA256": "b673c96ce296bfccd56154c8c0e21af9f0b1cddf241b4e77c70cf35795da90b9" - }, - { - "case": "covered", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t2mk22qs", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t2mk22qs/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t2mk22qs/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Write every unit test with pytest.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Candidate is **covered**: the existing rule says \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests\u201d with the same `tests/**/*.py` scope.\n\nSources: [canonical rule](aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md), [Claude](.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md), [Cursor](.cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc), [Copilot](.github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md), and [Codex/OpenCode](AGENTS.md). No scope exclusions or conflicts found.\n\nComplete candidate:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Write every unit test with pytest.\\n\"}\n```\n\nTargets: Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex, OpenCode V2.\n\nChoose **approve** to create the duplicate rule, **keep** the existing rule, **revise**, **merge/replace**, or **cancel**. No files changed.\n\nThe [skill\u2019s assessment action](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t2mk22qs/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cShow complete candidates and findings; await explicit resolution, even for **new**.\u201d Confirmed capture choices do not satisfy this later decision, so creation is paused.", - "before": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "fixtureFiles": { - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n", - "AGENTS.md": "\nApplies to: `tests/**/*.py`.\n\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "---\napplyTo: \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "---\ndescription: \"Python unit tests\"\nglobs: \"tests/**/*.py\"\nalwaysApply: false\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n" - }, - "installedHashes": { - "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", - "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", - "references/tool-paths.md": "70d7e97bc814d69fb030186ce2f30350001e9c3621b2d40efccabc63105bd70e", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "eventsSHA256": "5633a868ec1d3266b2c48ba600f96dd260f106d89832b9a340d71d4bb10c3e16" - }, - { - "case": "overlap", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-2p0h3ldp", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-2p0h3ldp/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-2p0h3ldp/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\\n- Put unit test files in tests/unit/.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Creation paused; no files changed.\n\nCandidate: `05-testing/5-candidate`, description `Test conventions`, scope `tests/**/*.py`, targeting Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2.\n\n```markdown\n# Test conventions\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n- Put unit test files in tests/unit/.\n```\n\nFinding: **overlap**. [Existing rule](aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md) already requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests\u201d across the identical scope, published in all five hosts. The `tests/unit/` requirement is new and compatible.\n\nChoose: **approve** as a separate overlapping rule, **merge/replace** `5-existing`, **revise**, **keep existing**, or **cancel**.\n\n[Skill action 02](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cShow complete candidates and findings; await explicit resolution, even for **new**.\u201d Your confirmed capture choices do not supply this post-assessment decision.", - "before": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "fixtureFiles": { - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n", - "AGENTS.md": "\nApplies to: `tests/**/*.py`.\n\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "---\napplyTo: \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "---\ndescription: \"Python unit tests\"\nglobs: \"tests/**/*.py\"\nalwaysApply: false\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n" - }, - "installedHashes": { - "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", - "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", - "references/tool-paths.md": "70d7e97bc814d69fb030186ce2f30350001e9c3621b2d40efccabc63105bd70e", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "eventsSHA256": "403d3927c776561ac942c08ceb415b8bb599bd9806df72b6d3f95fc81b7f1aa4" - }, - { - "case": "conflict", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-5qhld3dc", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-5qhld3dc/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-5qhld3dc/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Creation paused; no files changed.\n\nCandidate for Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\n**Conflict:** [existing rule](aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md) requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d Both rules cover exactly `tests/**/*.py`, including future files. That requirement also appears in `AGENTS.md` and the Claude, Cursor and Copilot publications.\n\nDecision required: keep the existing rule, revise the candidate, replace `05-testing/5-existing` and its publications, or cancel.\n\n[Skill action 02](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires \u201cawait explicit resolution\u201d and \u201cResolve every conflict/uncertainty before proceeding.\u201d Confirmed capture choices do not resolve this conflict.", - "before": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "fixtureFiles": { - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n", - "AGENTS.md": "\nApplies to: `tests/**/*.py`.\n\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "---\napplyTo: \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "---\ndescription: \"Python unit tests\"\nglobs: \"tests/**/*.py\"\nalwaysApply: false\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n" - }, - "installedHashes": { - "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", - "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", - "references/tool-paths.md": "70d7e97bc814d69fb030186ce2f30350001e9c3621b2d40efccabc63105bd70e", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "eventsSHA256": "4be34da0fd9f1cb07047a20ac4527aae03bb9c9f71bf6e81bb29afba7a8c2b39" - }, - { - "case": "disjoint", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-3hcgdbdf", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-3hcgdbdf/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-3hcgdbdf/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"frontend/tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Candidate:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"frontend/tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\nFinding: **new**. Existing pytest policy covers `backend/tests/**/*.py`; candidate covers `frontend/tests/**/*.py`. These scopes are disjoint, including future files.\n\nExisting policy appears in [canonical source](aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md), [Claude](.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md), [Cursor](.cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc), [Copilot](.github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md), and [AGENTS.md](AGENTS.md).\n\nApprove this candidate for all five confirmed hosts, keep existing rules, revise, or cancel?\n\nNo files changed. [Installed skill](../installed/SKILL.md), through [assessment action](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md), requires: \u201cawait explicit resolution, even for **new**.\u201d Confirmed capture choices do not satisfy this separate assessment decision.", - "before": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "3ccc5ee40f2a5caea1382ff9da1bb546e2f94a4d3b6eb591603bb5622bb18269", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "df4c9a6cd7512ff24b79d4bfa946a44b0d368c055d680e67883293defde4887d", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "30f0f402e53af81be9950700dcaf05d0a2411bd8f2f1fdbfec2a5b915b39c506", - "AGENTS.md": "209e23b4325e862c45ad5347517553e296662d47a4f794b266ee34336ea50c35", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ceb7c77e195f68130a3302542deac1871a00d963b3ed97dc74b1d3b1473e2d0a", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "3ccc5ee40f2a5caea1382ff9da1bb546e2f94a4d3b6eb591603bb5622bb18269", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "df4c9a6cd7512ff24b79d4bfa946a44b0d368c055d680e67883293defde4887d", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "30f0f402e53af81be9950700dcaf05d0a2411bd8f2f1fdbfec2a5b915b39c506", - "AGENTS.md": "209e23b4325e862c45ad5347517553e296662d47a4f794b266ee34336ea50c35", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ceb7c77e195f68130a3302542deac1871a00d963b3ed97dc74b1d3b1473e2d0a", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "fixtureFiles": { - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n", - "AGENTS.md": "\nApplies to: `backend/tests/**/*.py`.\n\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "---\napplyTo: \"backend/tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"backend/tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "---\ndescription: \"Python unit tests\"\nglobs: \"backend/tests/**/*.py\"\nalwaysApply: false\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n" - }, - "installedHashes": { - "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", - "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", - "references/tool-paths.md": "70d7e97bc814d69fb030186ce2f30350001e9c3621b2d40efccabc63105bd70e", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "eventsSHA256": "ac88ddbd101eba4ec73c3648f657cd25e1a654ff79f042833808810d90482d94" - }, - { - "case": "uncertain", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0oqnbaf8", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0oqnbaf8/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0oqnbaf8/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Creation paused; no files changed.\n\nCandidate metadata: category `05-testing`, slug `5-candidate`, description `Test conventions`, paths `[\"tests/**/*.py\"]`. Destinations: Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex, OpenCode V2.\n\n```markdown\n# Test conventions\n\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\n```\n\n**Needs review:** [.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md](.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md) applies to the same scope and requires: \u201cUse the test framework approved in docs/test-framework.md.\u201d That document is missing, so compatibility with `unittest` cannot be established.\n\nThe installed [assessment action](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0oqnbaf8/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cShow complete candidates and findings; await explicit resolution\u201d and \u201cResolve every conflict/uncertainty before proceeding.\u201d\n\nFurther decision required: identify the approved framework and resolve the finding, revise the candidate, authorize replacing the identified existing rule, or keep/cancel.", - "before": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "97b20713c5f281632ce97c6304250b4a1b1988ca32a3df0ccf544cbe2d74171a", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "97b20713c5f281632ce97c6304250b4a1b1988ca32a3df0ccf544cbe2d74171a", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "fixtureFiles": { - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n", - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n\n# Unit tests\n\n- Use the test framework approved in docs/test-framework.md.\n" - }, - "installedHashes": { - "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", - "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", - "references/tool-paths.md": "70d7e97bc814d69fb030186ce2f30350001e9c3621b2d40efccabc63105bd70e", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "eventsSHA256": "6c0998be130d5ac7934cbb466323eabf5f3c20abed7deb6997e6f48d8f6a6338" - }, - { - "case": "edited-rendering", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-y0jh35oc", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-y0jh35oc/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-y0jh35oc/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Write every unit test with pytest.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Creation paused; no files changed.\n\nCandidate:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Write every unit test with pytest.\\n\"}\n```\n\nFindings for the identical scope `tests/**/*.py`:\n\n- **Covered:** `aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md`, `AGENTS.md`, Cursor and Copilot publications already require \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d\n- **Conflict:** `.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md` instead requires \u201cUse unittest for all unit tests.\u201d This differing native edit must remain separate evidence.\n\nThe [skill\u2019s assessment step](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-y0jh35oc/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cawait explicit resolution\u201d and \u201cResolve every conflict/uncertainty before proceeding.\u201d\n\nChoose **keep/cancel**, **revise**, or explicitly authorize resolving the Claude edit and approve the resulting candidate. Capture confirmation does not satisfy this assessment decision.", - "before": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "9e8fd9e68a4cc2ec4219a150f7aab51e7562780547d7438f5fdf5aadd44baf32", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "9e8fd9e68a4cc2ec4219a150f7aab51e7562780547d7438f5fdf5aadd44baf32", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "fixtureFiles": { - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n", - "AGENTS.md": "\nApplies to: `tests/**/*.py`.\n\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "---\napplyTo: \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "---\ndescription: \"Python unit tests\"\nglobs: \"tests/**/*.py\"\nalwaysApply: false\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n" - }, - "installedHashes": { - "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", - "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", - "references/tool-paths.md": "70d7e97bc814d69fb030186ce2f30350001e9c3621b2d40efccabc63105bd70e", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "eventsSHA256": "825b78333b946dae142cf6ac670801a16c0c12638792234f464d2bd5891da8ba" - }, - { - "case": "plugin-conflict", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k3ov3cw3", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k3ov3cw3/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k3ov3cw3/project, plugin source in plugins/example, no host publication. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Creation paused: **conflict** in [5-existing.md](plugins/example/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md). It requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d Both rules cover `tests/**/*.py`.\n\nComplete candidate for `plugins/example/rules/05-testing/5-candidate.md`:\n\n```yaml\n---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Test conventions\n\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\n```\n\nMetadata: category `05-testing`, slug `5-candidate`, description `Test conventions`.\n\nChoose: keep existing rule, revise candidate, authorize replacing the existing pytest requirement with unittest, or cancel. No files changed.\n\nThe [assessment workflow](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cResolve every conflict/uncertainty before proceeding\u201d and \u201cawait explicit resolution.\u201d Your confirmed capture choices do not resolve this conflict.", - "before": { - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae", - "plugins/example/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "c83fa98fc86980237fca5bc0d216c3cb089770f2e4499744b306a509111368bf" - }, - "after": { - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae", - "plugins/example/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "c83fa98fc86980237fca5bc0d216c3cb089770f2e4499744b306a509111368bf" - }, - "fixtureFiles": { - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n", - "plugins/example/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n\n# Unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n" - }, - "installedHashes": { - "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", - "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", - "references/tool-paths.md": "70d7e97bc814d69fb030186ce2f30350001e9c3621b2d40efccabc63105bd70e", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "eventsSHA256": "adbc94fdb4c84facb5c735a55eb8b580bce11652d7a986c5c670e4822d95f4f8" - }, - { - "case": "copilot-guidance", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-p4nc5tel", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-p4nc5tel/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-p4nc5tel/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "No files changed. Assessment found a **conflict**: [GEMINI.md](GEMINI.md:3), a Copilot project source, says \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d This conflicts with the candidate within `tests/**/*.py`.\n\nComplete candidate for Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\nChoose: keep existing policy, revise the candidate, authorize replacing the conflicting policy, or cancel.\n\nThe installed skill\u2019s [assessment action](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-p4nc5tel/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires \u201cawait explicit resolution\u201d and \u201cResolve every conflict/uncertainty before proceeding.\u201d Capture confirmation does not resolve this conflict.", - "before": { - "GEMINI.md": "84d50ee6955150792d301179bdcf6a4e3c92922a6ebfba6204236df3d6e6dfc1", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - "GEMINI.md": "84d50ee6955150792d301179bdcf6a4e3c92922a6ebfba6204236df3d6e6dfc1", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "fixtureFiles": { - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n", - "GEMINI.md": "# Unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n" - }, - "installedHashes": { - "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", - "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", - "references/tool-paths.md": "70d7e97bc814d69fb030186ce2f30350001e9c3621b2d40efccabc63105bd70e", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "eventsSHA256": "a740b69ded2d919fff1ecbded26b32332b2779eab1abbd9be958bf246da6388e" - }, - { - "case": "copilot-import", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-cpisqs8a", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-cpisqs8a/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-cpisqs8a/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Creation paused: existing Copilot guidance conflicts with the candidate.\n\n[.github/copilot-instructions.md](.github/copilot-instructions.md) imports [docs/unit-policy.md](docs/unit-policy.md), which requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d This overlaps `tests/**/*.py` and conflicts with `unittest`.\n\nCandidate metadata: category `05-testing`, slug `5-candidate`, description `Test conventions`, paths `[\"tests/**/*.py\"]`. Targets: Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex, OpenCode V2.\n\n```markdown\n# Test conventions\n\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\n```\n\nChoose: keep existing policy, revise candidate, authorize replacing the pytest policy, or cancel.\n\nThe installed skill\u2019s [assessment step](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-cpisqs8a/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires \u201cawait explicit resolution\u201d and \u201cResolve every conflict/uncertainty before proceeding.\u201d Capture confirmation does not resolve this conflict. No files changed.", - "before": { - ".github/copilot-instructions.md": "f499439acb6f5b3504d0435aed5e9b60be5dc5634b90708863370d739e574b14", - "docs/unit-policy.md": "0e5cd2aa19aa90b11d9fd678e85cc137315971a75d68bd2004bf0f48ea63be3d", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".github/copilot-instructions.md": "f499439acb6f5b3504d0435aed5e9b60be5dc5634b90708863370d739e574b14", - "docs/unit-policy.md": "0e5cd2aa19aa90b11d9fd678e85cc137315971a75d68bd2004bf0f48ea63be3d", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "fixtureFiles": { - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n", - "docs/unit-policy.md": "# Unit policy\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", - ".github/copilot-instructions.md": "# Unit tests\n\nFollow @../docs/unit-policy.md.\n" - }, - "installedHashes": { - "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", - "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", - "references/tool-paths.md": "70d7e97bc814d69fb030186ce2f30350001e9c3621b2d40efccabc63105bd70e", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "eventsSHA256": "4b134ee91d40835944296c2d28e4413fd5b91b2302dc7e38560403a493966dd5" - }, - { - "case": "scope-uncertain", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-9q4boz6g", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-9q4boz6g/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-9q4boz6g/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "No files changed. Assessment: **needs review**.\n\n[Existing rule](.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md) applies to `**/*.py` and requires pytest for files selected by `config/unit-test-paths.json`. That config is missing, so overlap with `tests/**/*.py` cannot be resolved; overlapping unit tests would receive conflicting requirements.\n\nRequested candidate:\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\nProvide the missing scope evidence or explicitly resolve the existing pytest requirement, then approve the assessed candidate; alternatively revise or cancel.\n\nThe [skill](../installed/SKILL.md), through [action 02](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md), requires: \u201cResolve every conflict/uncertainty before proceeding\u201d and \u201cawait explicit resolution, even for **new**.\u201d Your confirmed capture choices do not resolve this finding.", - "before": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "49719e0335aa2659637431b09c60a99c7ea7b4792542295e2785bb335b5abcde", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "49719e0335aa2659637431b09c60a99c7ea7b4792542295e2785bb335b5abcde", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "fixtureFiles": { - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n", - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"**/*.py\"\n---\n\n# Unit tests\n\n- For the unit test files selected in config/unit-test-paths.json, use pytest.\n" - }, - "installedHashes": { - "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", - "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", - "references/tool-paths.md": "70d7e97bc814d69fb030186ce2f30350001e9c3621b2d40efccabc63105bd70e", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "eventsSHA256": "2b8aa8dd76c6f63fdff70708f1a20ace490a1fdc98e6ee1aea694cb08135bc5b" - }, - { - "case": "claude-local", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ht1ibk1j", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ht1ibk1j/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ht1ibk1j/project, host project, tool Claude Code only. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Rule creation paused; no files changed.\n\n**Conflict:** [CLAUDE.local.md](CLAUDE.local.md) requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d This overlaps `tests/**/*.py` and contradicts the candidate:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\nChoose **keep existing policy**, **revise candidate**, **replace existing policy with unittest**, or **cancel**. Replacement requires explicit authorization to change `CLAUDE.local.md`.\n\nThe installed [assessment workflow](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cResolve every conflict/uncertainty before proceeding.\u201d Your capture confirmations do not resolve this conflict.", - "before": { - "CLAUDE.local.md": "f6f6bdd0fbb28b7e582991c063f0f4ec4868959cca6aa45e9dc2c8c374d17b2c", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - "CLAUDE.local.md": "f6f6bdd0fbb28b7e582991c063f0f4ec4868959cca6aa45e9dc2c8c374d17b2c", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "fixtureFiles": { - "CLAUDE.local.md": "# Local unit test policy\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" - }, - "installedHashes": { - "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", - "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", - "references/tool-paths.md": "70d7e97bc814d69fb030186ce2f30350001e9c3621b2d40efccabc63105bd70e", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "eventsSHA256": "a0fce1f0aab273f91a6d40f614bc3dca68697f58a53a1f8f6bc31520389c762c" - }, - { - "case": "opencode-v1-config", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-1qr4_na3", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-1qr4_na3/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-1qr4_na3/project, host project, tool OpenCode V1 only, Claude compatibility enabled. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Rule not created. OpenCode V1 explicitly loads `.opencode/rules/unit-policy.md` through `opencode.json`. Its \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d conflicts with the candidate within `tests/**/*.py`.\n\nComplete candidate:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\nThe installed skill\u2019s [assessment workflow](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cResolve every conflict/uncertainty before proceeding.\u201d\n\nChoose: keep existing policy, revise the candidate, explicitly authorize replacing the identified pytest policy, or cancel. Project bytes unchanged.", - "before": { - ".opencode/rules/unit-policy.md": "3bb1e368a3761a67f5d570949701a7971ba43a931230bde9fa04e99e31a1412f", - "opencode.json": "e398d91b37458ae747392d4fdd490571d2e8994374af773a400c3c6883278299", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".opencode/rules/unit-policy.md": "3bb1e368a3761a67f5d570949701a7971ba43a931230bde9fa04e99e31a1412f", - "opencode.json": "e398d91b37458ae747392d4fdd490571d2e8994374af773a400c3c6883278299", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "fixtureFiles": { - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n", - "opencode.json": "{\"instructions\":[\".opencode/rules/unit-policy.md\"]}\n", - ".opencode/rules/unit-policy.md": "# Unit test policy\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n" - }, - "installedHashes": { - "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", - "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", - "references/tool-paths.md": "70d7e97bc814d69fb030186ce2f30350001e9c3621b2d40efccabc63105bd70e", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "eventsSHA256": "5c293b096771062aa298282cc047c63b3eee1d5a0a32fb72a644c724a0f49788" - }, - { - "case": "opencode-v1-fallback", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ix2qi3kg", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ix2qi3kg/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ix2qi3kg/project, host project, tool OpenCode V1 only, Claude compatibility enabled. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Candidate:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\n**Conflict:** [CLAUDE.md](CLAUDE.md) says \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d OpenCode V1 currently loads this fallback because no upward `AGENTS.md` exists and Claude compatibility is enabled. Both requirements apply to unit tests under `tests/**/*.py`.\n\nNo files changed. [Assessment step 5](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires \u201cawait explicit resolution\u201d and resolving every conflict before writing.\n\nChoose **keep**, **revise**, **merge/replace** (identify authorized source changes), or **cancel**.", - "before": { - "CLAUDE.md": "3bb1e368a3761a67f5d570949701a7971ba43a931230bde9fa04e99e31a1412f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - "CLAUDE.md": "3bb1e368a3761a67f5d570949701a7971ba43a931230bde9fa04e99e31a1412f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "fixtureFiles": { - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n", - "CLAUDE.md": "# Unit test policy\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n" - }, - "installedHashes": { - "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", - "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", - "references/tool-paths.md": "70d7e97bc814d69fb030186ce2f30350001e9c3621b2d40efccabc63105bd70e", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "eventsSHA256": "64d9abdeaa5416237f7b5f792bfc7cd3a2216b843f69f5d6d947b9bc0e98360c" - }, - { - "case": "flat-codex-conflict", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-lmi51ec7", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-lmi51ec7/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-lmi51ec7/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Creation paused: candidate conflicts with existing policy over the identical `tests/**/*.py` scope.\n\nComplete candidate:\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\nExisting [canonical rule](aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md) requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d Its publications appear in [AGENTS.md](AGENTS.md), [.claude](.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md), [.cursor](.cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc), and [.github](.github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md). Both requirements cover all Python unit tests within the same scope; no exclusions resolve the conflict.\n\nChoose: replace the identified existing rule and its publications, revise the candidate, or keep existing policy/cancel.\n\n[Skill workflow](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires \u201cawait explicit resolution\u201d and \u201cResolve every conflict/uncertainty before proceeding.\u201d Confirmed capture choices do not resolve this conflict. No files changed.", - "before": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "fixtureFiles": { - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n", - "AGENTS.md": "\nApplies to: `tests/**/*.py`.\n\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "---\napplyTo: \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "---\ndescription: \"Python unit tests\"\nglobs: \"tests/**/*.py\"\nalwaysApply: false\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n" - }, - "installedHashes": { - "SKILL.md": "5e5f4508792c39999467622e1e034bfaa43b4b8325f189726e22d4dcb20d9086", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", - "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", - "references/tool-paths.md": "70d7e97bc814d69fb030186ce2f30350001e9c3621b2d40efccabc63105bd70e", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "eventsSHA256": "61dfcd19de003a13b4e5ba5e1e7349793c6de7cbf47ca4e9da600a017a956f98" - } - ], - "journeys": [ - { - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-vga1bx6l", - "results": [ - { - "case": "new", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-vga1bx6l", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-vga1bx6l/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-vga1bx6l/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"01-standards\", \"slug\": \"1-constants\", \"description\": \"Constants\", \"paths\": [\"src/**/*.ts\"], \"body\": \"# Constants\\n\\n- Name constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Candidate: `01-standards/1-constants`, description `Constants`, scope `src/**/*.ts`, targeting Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2.\n\n```markdown\n# Constants\n\n- Name constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\n```\n\nFinding: **new**. No existing rule or policy files were found in the project or checked ancestors.\n\nNo files changed. [Assessment workflow](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cawait explicit resolution, even for **new**.\u201d\n\nChoose **approve**, **keep**, **revise**, **merge/replace**, or **cancel**. Creation is paused pending that decision.", - "eventsSHA256": "201c7c12b070a900f9aa60aa8fa5af83ee96a5ca827047e4845d52c841c16e56" - }, - { - "turn": "revise", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "before": { - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "prompt": "Change the candidate body to exactly \"# Constants\\n\\n- Name constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n- Export constants using named exports.\\n\" and create it. All earlier capture choices remain confirmed.", - "answer": "Revised candidate: `01-standards/1-constants`, description `Constants`, scope `src/**/*.ts`; targets Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2 in the original confirmed project.\n\n```markdown\n# Constants\n\n- Name constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\n- Export constants using named exports.\n```\n\nFinding: **new**. No existing project policies cover or conflict with either obligation. No files changed.\n\n[Skill workflow]() states: \u201cChanged body, metadata, scope, targets, resolution or source evidence returns to assessment and approval.\u201d\n\nApprove this revised candidate, or choose keep, revise, merge/replace, or cancel. Awaiting explicit resolution before writing.", - "eventsSHA256": "c6e9a93bd0c0c3e4c7787fd2aa991971c67c32fd871a57d5922d9ba9a7ab07ed" - }, - { - "turn": "approve", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": false, - "changed": [ - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md", - "AGENTS.md", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md" - ], - "before": { - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "exactBody": true, - "prompt": "I approve the exact revised candidate you just assessed, with both bullets, the same metadata, src/**/*.ts scope and all five hosts. Publish it now.", - "answer": "Published `01-standards/1-constants` in the original confirmed project for all five hosts.\n\nValidation passed: exact two-bullet body, `src/**/*.ts` scope, one shared Codex/OpenCode contribution, and byte-identical republishing. Host runtime consumption remains unverified.\n\nNo application source changed, packages installed, network tools used, or commits created.", - "eventsSHA256": "af5b4001d27c01b7451a89c25cf039f8af5281d93b400e890087e58123e5299b" - }, - { - "turn": "covered", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "before": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "prompt": "Create another rule: manual host project, all five hosts confirmed, category 01-standards, slug 1-public-values, description Public values, paths [\"src/**/*.ts\"], exact body \"# Public values\\n\\n- Write names of constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n\". Follow the installed skill from capture.", - "answer": "Candidate: `01-standards/1-public-values`, description `Public values`, scope `src/**/*.ts`, all five confirmed hosts in the original project.\n\n```markdown\n# Public values\n\n- Write names of constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\n```\n\nFinding: **covered**. [Existing Constants rule]() already requires \u201cName constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\u201d It has identical scope and publications for every requested host. The candidate adds no obligation.\n\nRecommended resolution: **keep** the existing rule. Alternatively approve the duplicate, revise, merge/replace, or cancel.\n\nNo files changed. [Assessment workflow]() requires explicit resolution after presenting findings. Awaiting that decision.", - "eventsSHA256": "27f03875464afae310f4ccf7c45208ea16449eaf23ee5996150970c3e259c5d7" - }, - { - "turn": "keep", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "before": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "prompt": "Keep the existing policy. Do not create the candidate or modify existing files.", - "answer": "Kept existing Constants policy. Candidate not created; no files changed. Nothing pending.", - "eventsSHA256": "4fc9744bc8420431c5f53636631420dd349faf917900a5186d93150051b7d3f0" - }, - { - "turn": "conflict", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "before": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "prompt": "Create another rule: manual host project, all five hosts confirmed, category 01-standards, slug 1-lowercase-values, description Lowercase values, paths [\"src/**/*.ts\"], exact body \"# Lowercase values\\n\\n- Name every constant in lowerCamelCase.\\n\". Follow the installed skill from capture.", - "answer": "Candidate: `01-standards/1-lowercase-values`, description `Lowercase values`, scope `src/**/*.ts`, all five confirmed hosts in the original project.\n\n```markdown\n# Lowercase values\n\n- Name every constant in lowerCamelCase.\n```\n\nFinding: **conflict**. [Existing Constants rule]() requires \u201cName constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\u201d Both apply to every constant in the identical scope, including future files, across all five hosts. Neither defines an exception or priority.\n\nChoose **keep**, **revise**, **merge/replace**, or **cancel**. Approval requires an explicit resolution of the conflicting naming requirements.\n\nNo files changed. [Assessment workflow]() requires: \u201cResolve every conflict/uncertainty before proceeding.\u201d Awaiting your resolution.", - "eventsSHA256": "5fb6ec97d4dfe71214e4cfa3cfafc11fad96fb738e40e14f90bb76efa08d35b2" - }, - { - "turn": "cancel", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "before": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "prompt": "Cancel this candidate. Keep every existing rule and publication unchanged.", - "answer": "Candidate canceled. Every existing rule and publication remains unchanged. Nothing pending.", - "eventsSHA256": "616d6a444880530699b2dc473e981cc46b3bbf7f0cc3987aa3c92da5e741e5f0" - }, - { - "turn": "publish", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "before": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "prompt": "Explicitly publish the existing canonical rule set to claude,cursor,copilot,codex,opencode using the installed skill. Do not change its body or targets.", - "answer": "Published existing canonical rules to all five hosts. Validation passed: bodies, targets and all project bytes unchanged.\n\nRuntime consumption unverified. Nothing pending.", - "eventsSHA256": "43d2dcbac963206e699f134c493fa857cc6396d16e1aaad014dbbdddabcd2d82" - }, - { - "turn": "delete", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": false, - "changed": [ - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md", - "AGENTS.md", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md" - ], - "before": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - "AGENTS.md": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "prompt": "Explicitly delete existing canonical rule 01-standards/1-constants and its publications on all five confirmed hosts using the installed skill.", - "answer": "Deleted `01-standards/1-constants` and its publications on all five hosts.\n\nValidation passed: canonical and native files absent, shared Codex/OpenCode contribution removed, unrelated files unchanged. Nothing pending.", - "eventsSHA256": "baeaa675ba38b810755e852ee3b8dee0a8646b6c0cb0b9c01b4f63a5b02989fb" - } - ], - "installedHashes": { - "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", - "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", - "references/tool-paths.md": "70d7e97bc814d69fb030186ce2f30350001e9c3621b2d40efccabc63105bd70e", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "initialRequest": null, - "initialBefore": { - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - } - }, - { - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-x38wqtp1", - "results": [ - { - "case": "overlap", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-x38wqtp1", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-x38wqtp1/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-x38wqtp1/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\\n- Put unit test files in tests/unit/.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Creation paused; no files changed.\n\n**Finding: overlap.** [Existing rule](aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md) already requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d for the identical scope, `tests/**/*.py`. Its publications in `.claude/rules`, `.cursor/rules`, `.github/instructions` and root `AGENTS.md` repeat that requirement. The candidate adds the compatible requirement to place unit tests in `tests/unit/`.\n\nComplete candidate:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\\n- Put unit test files in tests/unit/.\\n\"}\n```\n\nTargets: Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex, OpenCode V2.\n\nChoose **approve** to create this exact candidate, **keep** existing rules, **revise**, **merge/replace** the existing rule, or **cancel**.\n\n[Skill action 02](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-x38wqtp1/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cShow complete candidates and findings; await explicit resolution, even for **new**.\u201d Confirmed capture choices do not satisfy this assessment decision.", - "eventsSHA256": "937ab187e5cc16b69e5f03c179cda432d402c4cd2ac446cdc5b080bc98103d52" - }, - { - "turn": "merge", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "before": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "prompt": "Merge this candidate into existing canonical 05-testing/5-existing and update its five confirmed publications. Keep its existing description, category, slug, scope and targets. The proposed complete merged body is exactly \"# Python unit tests\\n\\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\\n- Put unit test files in tests/unit/.\\n\". Do not create 5-candidate.", - "answer": "Reassessment: compatible extension of [5-existing](aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md). The merged body preserves pytest and adds `tests/unit/`; no conflict found with its publications.\n\nComplete merged body:\n\n```markdown\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n- Put unit test files in tests/unit/.\n```\n\nMetadata retained: category `05-testing`, slug `5-existing`, description `Python unit tests`, scope `tests/**/*.py`, and all five existing targets. Codex and OpenCode share root `AGENTS.md`.\n\nApprove this assessed merge and publication update?\n\n[Skill action 02](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-x38wqtp1/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires \u201cChanged body, metadata, scope, targets, resolution or source evidence returns to assessment and approval.\u201d This changed body therefore needs approval after reassessment. No files changed; `5-candidate` was not created.", - "eventsSHA256": "4b22c9bcb34aa29aa28e0935ea1d2392d30c60e8bc6d54e4a68cc5d7ef87d794" - }, - { - "turn": "approve-merge", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": false, - "before": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ea7a6e761e39734447ac1826007f2e6c8121a4aed107a1baa484a92dd7d2e0eb", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "bfea5e988bee2a398325da998ee8c9843d45aed8988ccef9dd6ae88bc07fdca3", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "aa7831807e3e3d618c3e63d75f2e551f84dba6710d2baf91f897a05bea3ab207", - "AGENTS.md": "874a63eb836e5329d50e8b595174bb7a0f6e57ca5a66bf425992f7a8014ce48a", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "5056a2efb84f9cc80e5843b8868390b3d7d662bd42fcdb3c12aa5d09392e51ca", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "prompt": "I approve the exact merged candidate you just reassessed, explicitly updating aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md and its Claude, Cursor, Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2 publications. Write and validate this resolution now.", - "answer": "Updated [5-existing](aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md) with the exact approved body and all five publications. Metadata preserved; no `5-candidate` created.\n\nValidation passed, including byte-idempotent republishing. Runtime host consumption remains unverified.", - "eventsSHA256": "513510834cb9008abe46974148c6829a79b6e4844f9fc05a368a0fc2b2e3fbae" - } - ], - "exactBody": true, - "noDuplicate": true, - "installedHashes": { - "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", - "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", - "references/tool-paths.md": "70d7e97bc814d69fb030186ce2f30350001e9c3621b2d40efccabc63105bd70e", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "initialRequest": { - "category": "05-testing", - "slug": "5-existing", - "description": "Python unit tests", - "paths": [ - "tests/**/*.py" - ], - "body": "# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n" - }, - "initialBefore": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - } - } - ], - "finalSourceHashes": { - "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", - "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", - "references/tool-paths.md": "2232eeb18c56dce6486526b801a1b3945d2fb8e8aa0fb860dc9340fc9a2fe47a", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "finalWords": 1766, - "postReplayChange": "Removed only the nonnormative Checked 2026-10-12: prefix from Official contracts; all policy instructions and links unchanged." -} diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/concise-teardown.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/concise-teardown.json deleted file mode 100644 index 1a8e3714f..000000000 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/concise-teardown.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,24 +0,0 @@ -{ - "archive": "/private/tmp/aidd-791-concise-native-fixtures.tar.gz", - "sha256": "e6fbb48c23eae557d0c679820108515df23a4d1743159ad085572896b697a01f", - "roots": [ - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-x77f_xve", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t2mk22qs", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-2p0h3ldp", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-5qhld3dc", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-3hcgdbdf", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0oqnbaf8", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-y0jh35oc", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k3ov3cw3", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-p4nc5tel", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-cpisqs8a", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-9q4boz6g", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ht1ibk1j", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-1qr4_na3", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ix2qi3kg", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-lmi51ec7", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-vga1bx6l", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-x38wqtp1" - ], - "removed": true -} diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/final-source-hashes.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/final-source-hashes.json deleted file mode 100644 index 5f17f0871..000000000 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/final-source-hashes.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,11 +0,0 @@ -{ - "SKILL.md": "c3fc303ad0a1bf983c32905e264e65db410df09ad6f413924b2daee28edbc425", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "af76ed5a85bcbad4a8a5434a065ec8bacc49e75f2048c0c7ec44ba06065faeba", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "559462a4b12c10cfba8c847e1cb23b02ab4d756fe22003c8adf47d672095bf0c", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "3e63276d6fd1c03894406658a99631e0791c491913faaa188db51aaa36901c2b", - "actions/04-validate.md": "084560d6e6cbd6c3cbe89ba1a7bb2b9abf5427cabae802334a54a88a5e08017b", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "ce299dcd2a80e2debacc312a68af93bc3cccd2fc2d442e0c85daca9d9e7c5fd9", - "references/tool-paths.md": "2232eeb18c56dce6486526b801a1b3945d2fb8e8aa0fb860dc9340fc9a2fe47a", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" -} diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-assessment.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-assessment.json deleted file mode 100644 index 4bf5405e0..000000000 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-assessment.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,915 +0,0 @@ -{ - "codex-flat-conflict": { - "receipt": { - "case": "conflict", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-njf20lfx", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [] - }, - "before": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "skill-hashes": { - "SKILL.md": "ee9890ed4c365b9c4c3f7a85eba140a1d1f606d89cf39a9ca46fcc7c1e3c685d", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", - "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", - "references/tool-paths.md": "ce7a9da327f0f7c3d8a540191de7a223f216a77c6d438e0178dae91ca760d245", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-njf20lfx/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-njf20lfx/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "No files changed. The candidate conflicts with an existing rule.\n\nExact candidate, targeting all five confirmed tools:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\nExisting `aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md` requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d It has the identical `tests/**/*.py` scope. Verified matching publications in:\n\n- `.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md`\n- `.cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc`\n- `.github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md`\n- `AGENTS.md` (Codex and OpenCode V2)\n\nProposed resolution: replace that existing rule and its publications with the exact candidate. Confirm this replacement, keep the existing policy, revise the candidate, or cancel.\n\nThe [skill\u2019s assessment action](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-njf20lfx/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cAn unresolved conflict or needs-review finding requires an explicit resolution of that finding before proceeding.\u201d Your confirmed capture choices do not resolve this conflict, so the workflow stops here.", - "fixtureFiles": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "---\ndescription: \"Python unit tests\"\nglobs: \"tests/**/*.py\"\nalwaysApply: false\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "---\napplyTo: \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - "AGENTS.md": "\nApplies to: `tests/**/*.py`.\n\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" - }, - "rawEventsSHA256": "0becc17d4003e31351dd00fed8ef3c7aa85833ce443b4a0e8fab1b5baa2409d7" - }, - "conflict": { - "receipt": { - "case": "conflict", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-f08cf2dd", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [] - }, - "before": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "skill-hashes": { - "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", - "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", - "references/tool-paths.md": "8f6c12f0c5593ebad9865f7d71be8b9d076168246ba2fb07fa7680713fae57dd", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "commands": [ - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-f08cf2dd/installed/SKILL.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 1600, - "outputSHA256": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-f08cf2dd/installed/actions/01-capture-rule.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 1707, - "outputSHA256": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-f08cf2dd/installed/references/tool-paths.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-f08cf2dd/installed/references/rule-authoring.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-f08cf2dd/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 17908, - "outputSHA256": "15a442337727680f6300d1b092aabc3d8985784935a507db1e4bb66b3c2ecc2e" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"pwd -P\nrg --files --hidden -g '\"'! .git'\"' -g '\"'!node_modules'\"' -g 'AGENTS.md' -g 'AGENTS.override.md' -g 'CLAUDE.md' -g '*.mdc' -g '*instructions.md' -g 'aidd_docs/rules/**' -g '.claude/rules/**' -g '*config*' -g '\"'! .git/**'\"'\ncat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-f08cf2dd/installed/assets/rule-template.md\"", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 537, - "outputSHA256": "0cb8e891413d853c555b3c1ce53f36859022640bc796596276b23363b8b6655f" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"cat AGENTS.md aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md .github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md .claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md .cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc\nrg --files --hidden -g '\"'!.git/**'\"'\n\"", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 1413, - "outputSHA256": "7828bb700e650eb35143227141bef937afb42bf1d38543d14fbff976519c55fc" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"rg --files --hidden --no-ignore -g '\"'!.git/**'\"'\ncat package.json\"", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 210, - "outputSHA256": "ba6cce46787072aace2702dc2d11c4c81a9c223ce4f468e46fe4953509134924" - } - ], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-f08cf2dd/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-f08cf2dd/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Creation paused; no files changed.\n\nComplete candidate for Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\n**Conflict:** `aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md` requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d Its scope is also `tests/**/*.py`. The same requirement appears in `AGENTS.md`, `.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md`, `.cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc`, and `.github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md`.\n\nChoose: keep pytest, revise the candidate, or explicitly replace `05-testing/5-existing` and its listed publications with the unittest candidate.\n\nThe installed skill\u2019s [assessment step](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cAn unresolved conflict or needs-review finding requires an explicit resolution of that finding before proceeding.\u201d Capture confirmation does not resolve this conflict.", - "fixtureFiles": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "---\ndescription: \"Python unit tests\"\nglobs: \"tests/**/*.py\"\nalwaysApply: false\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "---\napplyTo: \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - "AGENTS.md": "\nApplies to: `tests/**/*.py`.\n\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" - }, - "rawEventsSHA256": "1b60175ddbb1d9979aef279d06748827db167c406d7a54bf29020d1b87ea1a6f" - }, - "copilot-guidance": { - "receipt": { - "case": "copilot-guidance", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-pa64pbd1", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [] - }, - "before": { - "GEMINI.md": "84d50ee6955150792d301179bdcf6a4e3c92922a6ebfba6204236df3d6e6dfc1", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - "GEMINI.md": "84d50ee6955150792d301179bdcf6a4e3c92922a6ebfba6204236df3d6e6dfc1", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "skill-hashes": { - "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", - "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", - "references/tool-paths.md": "40bef1b4fc7bdcf2fb6312ef217751bcea67b99899b9423c056c9407e45324a2", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "commands": [ - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-pa64pbd1/installed/SKILL.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 1600, - "outputSHA256": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-pa64pbd1/installed/actions/01-capture-rule.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 1707, - "outputSHA256": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-pa64pbd1/installed/references/tool-paths.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-pa64pbd1/installed/references/rule-authoring.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-pa64pbd1/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 18955, - "outputSHA256": "77f280b1b6aef14ec4e5f30918488b27e061a032433063123d10ff1583193f8d" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"pwd -P; rg --files --hidden -g '\"'!.git'\"' -g '\"'!node_modules'\"' -g '\"'!vendor'\"'; cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-pa64pbd1/installed/assets/rule-template.md\"", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 381, - "outputSHA256": "70e67cb6759c13a64cb99fc02604a92c8a2e34f08714e2baedeafddce919af9b" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat GEMINI.md package.json; ls -la'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 334, - "outputSHA256": "32bfa683e3b2350c1f61e26f9485469779b5b68fcbab49d8adc80fddd691b9e2" - } - ], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-pa64pbd1/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-pa64pbd1/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Creation paused: [GEMINI.md](GEMINI.md:3) says \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d This conflicts with the candidate under Copilot\u2019s discovery rules.\n\nExact candidate, targeting Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\nProposed resolution: replace the pytest requirement in `GEMINI.md` with the unittest requirement, then create the candidate. Alternatively, keep pytest and cancel, or revise the candidate.\n\nThe installed skill\u2019s [action 02](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires \u201can explicit user decision\u201d and explicit resolution of conflicts before writing. Please choose a resolution. No files changed.", - "fixtureFiles": { - "GEMINI.md": "# Unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" - }, - "rawEventsSHA256": "06228605fe0af7a7f31ab311858f9a57668a01319e9334efbb6c12200569f2d4" - }, - "copilot-import": { - "receipt": { - "case": "copilot-import", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t4gu559a", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [] - }, - "before": { - ".github/copilot-instructions.md": "f499439acb6f5b3504d0435aed5e9b60be5dc5634b90708863370d739e574b14", - "docs/unit-policy.md": "0e5cd2aa19aa90b11d9fd678e85cc137315971a75d68bd2004bf0f48ea63be3d", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".github/copilot-instructions.md": "f499439acb6f5b3504d0435aed5e9b60be5dc5634b90708863370d739e574b14", - "docs/unit-policy.md": "0e5cd2aa19aa90b11d9fd678e85cc137315971a75d68bd2004bf0f48ea63be3d", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "skill-hashes": { - "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", - "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", - "references/tool-paths.md": "40bef1b4fc7bdcf2fb6312ef217751bcea67b99899b9423c056c9407e45324a2", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "commands": [ - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t4gu559a/installed/SKILL.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 1600, - "outputSHA256": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t4gu559a/installed/actions/01-capture-rule.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t4gu559a/installed/references/rule-authoring.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t4gu559a/installed/references/tool-paths.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 16346, - "outputSHA256": "183ebd7c0e118a7bf3546751290a17590a2ce7ceee6a334a4f694cc3efb89b17" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t4gu559a/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md\nrg --files --hidden -g '\"'!'\"\\\\.git/**' -g '\"'!node_modules/**'\"' -g '\"'!vendor/**'\"' .\"", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 4387, - "outputSHA256": "64011bdafc21e0a0e75164bd5320ef80e5fc33fc4a6fb62ee4bf9548625b17db" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat .github/copilot-instructions.md docs/unit-policy.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t4gu559a/installed/assets/rule-template.md\nls -la'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 692, - "outputSHA256": "7440301c90f35f2adeb7ca3750dd798be1f61e028e6dd4368c73034dccf72f62" - } - ], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t4gu559a/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t4gu559a/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Creation paused: conflicting policy found. No files changed.\n\n[.github/copilot-instructions.md](.github/copilot-instructions.md) imports [docs/unit-policy.md](docs/unit-policy.md), which requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d That applies to the candidate\u2019s `tests/**/*.py` scope.\n\nComplete candidate for Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\nProposed resolution: explicitly amend `docs/unit-policy.md` to allow unittest under `tests/**/*.py`, then create the candidate. Alternatively, keep pytest, revise the candidate, or cancel. Which resolution do you approve?\n\nThe skill\u2019s [action 02](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires \u201can explicit resolution of that finding before proceeding.\u201d Your capture confirmation does not resolve this discovered conflict.", - "fixtureFiles": { - ".github/copilot-instructions.md": "# Unit tests\n\nFollow @../docs/unit-policy.md.\n", - "docs/unit-policy.md": "# Unit policy\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" - }, - "rawEventsSHA256": "0d7198372928070fe64986b1222554565c8d0884ba2423aa4b43754b400926e1" - }, - "covered": { - "receipt": { - "case": "covered", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [] - }, - "before": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "skill-hashes": { - "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", - "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", - "references/tool-paths.md": "8f6c12f0c5593ebad9865f7d71be8b9d076168246ba2fb07fa7680713fae57dd", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "commands": [ - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/installed/SKILL.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 1600, - "outputSHA256": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/installed/actions/01-capture-rule.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 1707, - "outputSHA256": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/installed/references/tool-paths.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/installed/references/rule-authoring.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 17908, - "outputSHA256": "15a442337727680f6300d1b092aabc3d8985784935a507db1e4bb66b3c2ecc2e" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"rg --files --hidden -g '\"'!'\"\\\\.git/**' -g 'AGENTS*' -g 'CLAUDE.md' -g '*.mdc' -g '*.instructions.md' -g 'copilot-instructions.md' -g 'aidd_docs/rules/**' -g '.claude/**' -g '*config*' -g '*settings*' -g 'opencode*' -g '.github/**' -g '.cursor/**'\"", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 179, - "outputSHA256": "27eb06f4a0dc6ed49a846e0aef8d6043a4c7a1ffde4c0b617403d2923cab27fb" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/installed/assets/rule-template.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 269, - "outputSHA256": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat AGENTS.md aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md .github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md .claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md .cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 1221, - "outputSHA256": "0bef1a1a68bb766c66ab9017300b314d55dea9099ef1bf154b64af6add1c583e" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/installed/scripts/write-rule.cjs'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 15650, - "outputSHA256": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"rg --files --hidden --no-ignore -g '\"'!.git/**'\"'\"", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 192, - "outputSHA256": "3955dca5630e1adfc0386818651b1a17be9203fab6b9460cc61a519fc4d326b2" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"node <<'NODE'\nconst fs = require('node:fs');\nconst vm = require('node:vm');\nconst script = '/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/installed/scripts/write-rule.cjs';\nconst src = fs.readFileSync(script, 'utf8').split('try { main(); }')[0];\nvm.runInNewContext(src + \"'`\nconst name = '\"'aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md';\nconst rule = parseCanonical(readUtf8(name), name);\nfor (const tool of ['claude','cursor','copilot']) {\n const p = nativePath(rule, tool), text = readUtf8(p);\n ownedNative(text, rule, tool, p);\n if (text \"'!== renderNative(rule, tool)) throw new Error('\"'Rendering differs: ' + p);\n}\nconst shared = readUtf8('AGENTS.md');\ncontribution(shared);\nif (shared \"'!== renderShared('\"'', [rule])) throw new Error('Shared rendering differs');\nprocess.stdout.write('Verified canonical scope, targets, native renderings and signatures, shared rendering and signature.\\\\\\\\n');\n\"'`, {require, process, Buffer});\nNODE'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 101, - "outputSHA256": "8993da388c2cf8e1469c447e3a79e346a206c428a002ecca7c5870edeeb23a6f" - } - ], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Write every unit test with pytest.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Assessment: **covered**. Existing `aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md` requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests\u201d under identical scope, `tests/**/*.py`. Verified matching publications in `.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md`, `.cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc`, `.github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md`, and `AGENTS.md`, covering all five confirmed tools.\n\nComplete candidate:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Write every unit test with pytest.\\n\"}\n```\n\nRecommend keeping the existing rule. Choose: keep existing, approve this exact duplicate, revise candidate, or cancel. No files changed.\n\nThe installed skill\u2019s [assessment action](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cShow the complete candidate, findings and proposed resolution, then wait for an explicit user decision.\u201d This further decision is required after assessment, so I stopped as instructed.", - "fixtureFiles": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "---\ndescription: \"Python unit tests\"\nglobs: \"tests/**/*.py\"\nalwaysApply: false\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "---\napplyTo: \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - "AGENTS.md": "\nApplies to: `tests/**/*.py`.\n\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" - }, - "rawEventsSHA256": "5698383e980dbeb0bc2727cf803db05b24abfc2b83c33a1b1e9c441564364d3d" - }, - "disjoint": { - "receipt": { - "case": "disjoint", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [] - }, - "before": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "3ccc5ee40f2a5caea1382ff9da1bb546e2f94a4d3b6eb591603bb5622bb18269", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "df4c9a6cd7512ff24b79d4bfa946a44b0d368c055d680e67883293defde4887d", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "30f0f402e53af81be9950700dcaf05d0a2411bd8f2f1fdbfec2a5b915b39c506", - "AGENTS.md": "209e23b4325e862c45ad5347517553e296662d47a4f794b266ee34336ea50c35", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ceb7c77e195f68130a3302542deac1871a00d963b3ed97dc74b1d3b1473e2d0a", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "3ccc5ee40f2a5caea1382ff9da1bb546e2f94a4d3b6eb591603bb5622bb18269", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "df4c9a6cd7512ff24b79d4bfa946a44b0d368c055d680e67883293defde4887d", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "30f0f402e53af81be9950700dcaf05d0a2411bd8f2f1fdbfec2a5b915b39c506", - "AGENTS.md": "209e23b4325e862c45ad5347517553e296662d47a4f794b266ee34336ea50c35", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ceb7c77e195f68130a3302542deac1871a00d963b3ed97dc74b1d3b1473e2d0a", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "skill-hashes": { - "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", - "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", - "references/tool-paths.md": "8f6c12f0c5593ebad9865f7d71be8b9d076168246ba2fb07fa7680713fae57dd", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "commands": [ - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/installed/SKILL.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 1600, - "outputSHA256": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/installed/actions/01-capture-rule.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 1707, - "outputSHA256": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/installed/references/tool-paths.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/installed/references/rule-authoring.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 17908, - "outputSHA256": "15a442337727680f6300d1b092aabc3d8985784935a507db1e4bb66b3c2ecc2e" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"pwd -P\nrg --files --hidden -g '\"'!node_modules'\"' -g '\"'!.git'\"' -g 'AGENTS*' -g 'CLAUDE.md' -g '*.mdc' -g '*instructions.md' -g '**/rules/**' -g '**/.claude/**' -g '**/.cursor/**' -g '**/.github/**' -g '**/.opencode/**' -g '**/.codex/**'\ncat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/installed/assets/rule-template.md\"", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 537, - "outputSHA256": "1604c20e73ad7df31fa0bf5b80d3835317ee17ada7c2629e23c1a2f006541951" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"cat AGENTS.md aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md .github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md .claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md .cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc\nrg --files --hidden --no-ignore -g '\"'!.git'\"' -g '\"'!node_modules'\"'\n\"", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 1453, - "outputSHA256": "0803a9ff16382840f9029f2e92bff6c88e28ff831c4f78bc2fc0f677df40f876" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"rg -n 'sha256|separator|createHash|aidd_rule_output' /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/installed/scripts/write-rule.cjs\ncat package.json\nfor dir in / /private /private/var /private/var/folders /private/var/folders/xr /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2; do for name in AGENTS.md AGENTS.override.md CLAUDE.md .claude/CLAUDE.md; do if [ -f \\\"\"'$dir/$name\" ]; then printf '\"'\\\\n%s\\\\n' \\\"\"'$dir/$name\"; cat \"$dir/$name\"; fi; done; done'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 953, - "outputSHA256": "813daface96cb8f035d0fb5d86ac1b65780aca9165b9b0963df8886f55f2a27c" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"sed -n '92,150p' /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/installed/scripts/write-rule.cjs\"", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 3962, - "outputSHA256": "e16010c12c2eed8d5f0587f2525e6cade925cffddd60a550e9d5c705f00fea51" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"tokenade exec --lang python --script 'import pathlib,re,hashlib\nh=lambda s:hashlib.sha256(s.encode()).hexdigest()\nfor p in [pathlib.Path(\\\".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md\\\"),pathlib.Path(\\\".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc\\\"),pathlib.Path(\\\".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md\\\")]:\n s=p.read_text(); m=re.search(r\\\"\\\\n<\"'!-- aidd_rule_output:path=('\"\\\\S+) sha256=([a-f0-9]{64}) -->\\\\n\"'$\",s); assert m and m[1]==str(p) and h(s[:m.start()])==m[2]\ns=pathlib.Path(\"AGENTS.md\").read_text(); m=re.fullmatch(r\"'\"\\\\n(.*?)<\"'!-- aidd_rules:end -->'\"\\\\n\\\",s,re.S); assert m and h(\\\"separator=0\\\\n\\\"+m[2])==m[1]\nprint(\\\"All four publication signatures verified; bodies and scopes match the inspected canonical policy.\\\")'\"", - "exit": 127, - "outputBytes": 35, - "outputSHA256": "f6152a2a42ddb7426bc7ac2a615b109c7f0db6a54665375a8e652e1b8f2f89ad" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"python3 - <<'PY'\nimport pathlib,re,hashlib\nh=lambda s:hashlib.sha256(s.encode()).hexdigest()\nfor p in [pathlib.Path('.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md'),pathlib.Path('.cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc'),pathlib.Path('.github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md')]:\n s=p.read_text(); m=re.search(r'\\\\n<\"'!-- aidd_rule_output:path=('\"\\\\S+) sha256=([a-f0-9]{64}) -->\\\\n\"'$'\"',s); assert m and m[1]==str(p) and h(s[:m.start()])==m[2]\ns=pathlib.Path('AGENTS.md').read_text(); m=re.fullmatch(r'<\"'!-- aidd_rules:start sha256=([a-f0-9]{64}) separator=0 -->'\"\\\\n(.*?)<\"'!-- aidd_rules:end -->'\"\\\\n',s,re.S); assert m and h('separator=0\\\\n'+m[2])==m[1]\nprint('All four publication signatures verified; inspected bodies and scopes match canonical policy.')\nPY\"", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 94, - "outputSHA256": "710995a0d4d079edb08b8a770cd04e4f332b8675462e6b5cafe061b78efc2958" - } - ], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"frontend/tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Assessment: **new**. Existing `5-existing` canonical rule and verified Claude, Cursor, Copilot and `AGENTS.md` publications require \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d only under `backend/tests/**/*.py`. That scope is disjoint from `frontend/tests/**/*.py`; no conflict or overlap was found.\n\nComplete candidate for Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"frontend/tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\nProposed resolution: create this exact candidate, preserving existing rules. Approve, revise, or cancel?\n\nThe installed [assessment action](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cwait for an explicit user decision, including for **new**.\u201d Your capture confirmation precedes this assessment, so I\u2019ve stopped without writing any files.", - "fixtureFiles": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"backend/tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "---\ndescription: \"Python unit tests\"\nglobs: \"backend/tests/**/*.py\"\nalwaysApply: false\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "---\napplyTo: \"backend/tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - "AGENTS.md": "\nApplies to: `backend/tests/**/*.py`.\n\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" - }, - "rawEventsSHA256": "890caf005638401b3835507821a53d42611d3810be0cdad8a21270ce315939e6" - }, - "edited-rendering": { - "receipt": { - "case": "edited-rendering", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [] - }, - "before": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "9e8fd9e68a4cc2ec4219a150f7aab51e7562780547d7438f5fdf5aadd44baf32", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "9e8fd9e68a4cc2ec4219a150f7aab51e7562780547d7438f5fdf5aadd44baf32", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "skill-hashes": { - "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", - "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", - "references/tool-paths.md": "2f1e5f4bb3d388b58d3502b6e71a857cd7d98c89ed63795c88b6664699f8106c", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "commands": [ - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt/installed/SKILL.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 1600, - "outputSHA256": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt/installed/actions/01-capture-rule.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt/installed/references/rule-authoring.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt/installed/references/tool-paths.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 16330, - "outputSHA256": "bb6928c48b7ae4e321381cdbd118e639a8549e8988e3a1580c88e812e0cca786" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 4316, - "outputSHA256": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"rg --files --hidden -g '\"'!.git'\"' -g '\"'!node_modules'\"' -g '\"'!vendor'\"'\"", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 192, - "outputSHA256": "c77979eb47f2fa550a98d1a62d675dbb5698da4cfb88aa7035cbbd580053eecc" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat AGENTS.md aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md .github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md .claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md .cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt/installed/assets/rule-template.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt/installed/scripts/write-rule.cjs'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 17142, - "outputSHA256": "1fc2e5e3842da8709c96c6db661d8643fe93750076e485bc45e6c35794d66598" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"node <<'NODE'\nconst fs = require('fs'), crypto = require('crypto');\nconst hash = s => crypto.createHash('sha256').update(s).digest('hex');\nconst canonical = fs.readFileSync('aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md','utf8');\nconst body = canonical.slice(canonical.indexOf('\\\\n')+1);\nfor (const p of ['.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md','.cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc','.github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md']) {\n const s = fs.readFileSync(p,'utf8');\n const m = /\\\\n<\"'!-- aidd_rule_output:path=('\"\\\\S+) sha256=([a-f0-9]+) -->\\\\n\"'$/.exec(s);\n const payload = s.slice(0,m.index);\n console.log(p, JSON.stringify({signatureValid:m[1]===p && hash(payload)===m[2],bodyMatches:payload.slice(payload.indexOf('\"'---\\\\n',4)+4)===body}));\n}\nconst s=fs.readFileSync('AGENTS.md','utf8');\nconst m=/\"'^\\\\n([\\\\s\\\\S]*)<\"'!-- aidd_rules:end -->'\"\\\\n\"'$/.exec(s);\nconsole.log('\"'AGENTS.md',JSON.stringify({signatureValid:hash('separator='+m[2]+'\\\\n'+m[3])===m[1],payloadMatches:m[3]==='Applies to: \"'`tests/**/*.py`.'\"\\\\n\\\\n'+body}));\nNODE\"", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 315, - "outputSHA256": "01aa61c3e73bfbff90f770f01304829ac5419681ef0479933f8faf97a6b29404" - } - ], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Write every unit test with pytest.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "No files changed. Assessment found:\n\n- **Covered:** `aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md` already requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d Its Cursor, Copilot and shared `AGENTS.md` publications match.\n- **Conflict:** `.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md` instead requires \u201cUse unittest for all unit tests.\u201d Its signature is invalid, indicating an edited publication. Both rules cover `tests/**/*.py`.\n\nComplete candidate, targeting all five confirmed tools:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Write every unit test with pytest.\\n\"}\n```\n\nRecommended decision: keep the existing pytest rule and explicitly authorize restoring its Claude publication. Alternatively, specify a revision or cancel.\n\nFurther decision is required by [action 02](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md): \u201cShow the complete candidate, findings and proposed resolution, then wait for an explicit user decision.\u201d The conflict and edited publication require explicit resolution before writing.", - "fixtureFiles": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "---\ndescription: \"Python unit tests\"\nglobs: \"tests/**/*.py\"\nalwaysApply: false\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "---\napplyTo: \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - "AGENTS.md": "\nApplies to: `tests/**/*.py`.\n\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" - }, - "rawEventsSHA256": "ffc4bf4735f227b29abbd717561dc999a849bd6cdc24bbbc65f58fee13f1fc2b" - }, - "new": { - "receipt": { - "case": "new", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [] - }, - "before": { - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "skill-hashes": { - "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", - "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", - "references/tool-paths.md": "8f6c12f0c5593ebad9865f7d71be8b9d076168246ba2fb07fa7680713fae57dd", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "commands": [ - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk/installed/SKILL.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 1600, - "outputSHA256": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk/installed/actions/01-capture-rule.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 1707, - "outputSHA256": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk/installed/references/tool-paths.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk/installed/references/rule-authoring.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 13592, - "outputSHA256": "52a68419a8e07e8bf1e139792b97d9a0027e404ac4918db36b8e1c29e82398d4" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 4316, - "outputSHA256": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"pwd -P\nrg --files --hidden -g '\"'!.git'\"' -g '\"'!node_modules'\"' -g '\"'!vendor'\"'\"", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 102, - "outputSHA256": "59c7cd7e39f9f2d79a3345ae73896df6fe7d3497caec9a82181613deeb217ffe" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk/installed/assets/rule-template.md\nls -la\nfor dir in /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn /private/var/folders/xr /private/var/folders /private/var /private /; do for name in AGENTS.md AGENTS.override.md CLAUDE.md; do if [ -f \"$dir/$name\" ]; then printf '\"'\\\\n%s\\\\n' \\\"\"'$dir/$name\"; cat \"$dir/$name\"; fi; done; done'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 469, - "outputSHA256": "7e681d52e5c1e0a33b28fd6456cb4bf68019b5b075763f7391ed8a851d2be200" - } - ], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"01-standards\", \"slug\": \"1-constants\", \"description\": \"Constants\", \"paths\": [\"src/**/*.ts\"], \"body\": \"# Constants\\n\\n- Name constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Assessment: **new**. No existing project rules or ancestor instructions were found. Supplied guidance does not overlap. All five selected tools are supported.\n\nExact candidate for Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"01-standards\",\"slug\":\"1-constants\",\"description\":\"Constants\",\"paths\":[\"src/**/*.ts\"],\"body\":\"# Constants\\n\\n- Name constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n\"}\n```\n\nApprove this exact candidate, revise it, or cancel?\n\n[Skill action 02](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cwait for an explicit user decision, including for **new**.\u201d This decision follows assessment, so capture confirmation does not satisfy it. No files were changed.", - "fixtureFiles": { - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" - }, - "rawEventsSHA256": "812bd835fe71021c6b5c6496916e1ad859ff66463226780e4926926e08a62767" - }, - "overlap": { - "receipt": { - "case": "overlap", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [] - }, - "before": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "skill-hashes": { - "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", - "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", - "references/tool-paths.md": "8f6c12f0c5593ebad9865f7d71be8b9d076168246ba2fb07fa7680713fae57dd", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "commands": [ - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg/installed/SKILL.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 1600, - "outputSHA256": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg/installed/actions/01-capture-rule.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 1707, - "outputSHA256": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg/installed/references/tool-paths.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg/installed/references/rule-authoring.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 17908, - "outputSHA256": "15a442337727680f6300d1b092aabc3d8985784935a507db1e4bb66b3c2ecc2e" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"pwd -P\nrg --files --hidden -g '\"'!node_modules'\"' -g '\"'!.git'\"' -g '\"'!vendor'\"'\ncat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg/installed/assets/rule-template.md\"", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 550, - "outputSHA256": "1dc64d98135d3069f3c81060f0b9b2e1bf77b6f48c9d88b451051449c4f04d3b" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat AGENTS.md aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md .github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md .claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md .cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc\ncat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg/installed/scripts/write-rule.cjs'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 16871, - "outputSHA256": "6dbbb7a93947693e07bed78c4dfdb983e61fb8cd6faedfcc6cb9e0cb90833905" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"rg --files --hidden --no-ignore -g '\"'!.git'\"'\nnode <<'NODE'\nconst fs = require('node:fs');\nconst vm = require('node:vm');\nconst script = fs.readFileSync('/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg/installed/scripts/write-rule.cjs', 'utf8');\nconst checks = \"'`\nconst source = '\"'aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md';\nconst rule = parseCanonical(readUtf8(source), source);\nfor (const tool of ['claude', 'cursor', 'copilot']) {\n const file = nativePath(rule, tool), actual = readUtf8(file);\n ownedNative(actual, rule, tool, file);\n if (actual \"'!== renderNative(rule, tool)) throw new Error('\"'Rendering differs: ' + file);\n}\nconst shared = readUtf8('AGENTS.md');\ncontribution(shared);\nif (shared \"'!== renderShared('\"'', [rule])) throw new Error('Shared rendering differs');\nconsole.log('All four publications match canonical body, scope and ownership.');\n\"'`;\nvm.runInNewContext(script.slice(0, script.lastIndexOf('\"'try { main(); }')) + checks, {require, console, Buffer});\nNODE\"", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 257, - "outputSHA256": "2b0e5ea95a5a3dbedd3e4527412ea0fcb7148d33ad54c76878a55ec9b0e1f14d" - } - ], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\\n- Put unit test files in tests/unit/.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Assessment: **overlap**. [Existing rule](aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md) already requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d for the identical scope, `tests/**/*.py`. Its Claude, Cursor, Copilot and shared AGENTS.md publications match and have valid ownership. The `tests/unit/` requirement is new.\n\nComplete candidate, targeting all five confirmed tools:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\\n- Put unit test files in tests/unit/.\\n\"}\n```\n\nApprove creating this exact candidate alongside the existing rule, revise it to omit the repeated pytest requirement, or keep the existing rule?\n\nNo files changed. [Action 02](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cShow the complete candidate, findings and proposed resolution, then wait for an explicit user decision, including for **new**.\u201d Your confirmed capture choices do not resolve this overlap.", - "fixtureFiles": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "---\ndescription: \"Python unit tests\"\nglobs: \"tests/**/*.py\"\nalwaysApply: false\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "---\napplyTo: \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n\n", - "AGENTS.md": "\nApplies to: `tests/**/*.py`.\n\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n\n", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" - }, - "rawEventsSHA256": "17167fe5ae27c615366969ac6ae73727aabf1236c24195c5373e3b8faf6e557a" - }, - "plugin-conflict": { - "receipt": { - "case": "plugin-conflict", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-qb2gmmss", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [] - }, - "before": { - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae", - "plugins/example/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "c83fa98fc86980237fca5bc0d216c3cb089770f2e4499744b306a509111368bf" - }, - "after": { - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae", - "plugins/example/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "c83fa98fc86980237fca5bc0d216c3cb089770f2e4499744b306a509111368bf" - }, - "skill-hashes": { - "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", - "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", - "references/tool-paths.md": "40bef1b4fc7bdcf2fb6312ef217751bcea67b99899b9423c056c9407e45324a2", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "commands": [ - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-qb2gmmss/installed/SKILL.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 1600, - "outputSHA256": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat ../installed/actions/01-capture-rule.md ../installed/references/rule-authoring.md ../installed/references/tool-paths.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 16346, - "outputSHA256": "183ebd7c0e118a7bf3546751290a17590a2ce7ceee6a334a4f694cc3efb89b17" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"cat ../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md\nrg --files --hidden -g '\"'!'\"\\\\.git/**' -g 'AGENTS*' -g '*.md' -g '*.mdc' plugins .\"", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 4412, - "outputSHA256": "32ae694d2d8eddde93c0cee2363a1fc803f61ed5a842ca7cf09db9b3a6b417c9" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat plugins/example/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md ../installed/assets/rule-template.md\npwd -P\nls -a'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 467, - "outputSHA256": "6ebbec183488b44318c16767096686c112a11db13dcb7a60e627424796d02399" - } - ], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-qb2gmmss/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-qb2gmmss/project, plugin source in plugins/example, no host publication. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Conflict: [5-existing.md](plugins/example/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md) requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d Both rules cover `tests/**/*.py`.\n\nCandidate destination: `plugins/example/rules/05-testing/5-candidate.md` \nDescription: `Test conventions`\n\n```markdown\n---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n\n# Test conventions\n\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\n```\n\nChoose: replace the existing pytest rule with this candidate, keep the existing rule, revise the candidate, or cancel. No files changed.\n\nThe [skill\u2019s assessment step](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cAn unresolved conflict or needs-review finding requires an explicit resolution of that finding before proceeding.\u201d Your confirmed capture choices do not resolve this conflict.", - "fixtureFiles": { - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n", - "plugins/example/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n\n# Unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n" - }, - "rawEventsSHA256": "dc15f99f8c5b170fd1ccef7f0bec0c129efcbc4d0571bf6be74102bd7887b7c7" - }, - "uncertain": { - "receipt": { - "case": "uncertain", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [] - }, - "before": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "97b20713c5f281632ce97c6304250b4a1b1988ca32a3df0ccf544cbe2d74171a", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "97b20713c5f281632ce97c6304250b4a1b1988ca32a3df0ccf544cbe2d74171a", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "skill-hashes": { - "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", - "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", - "references/tool-paths.md": "8f6c12f0c5593ebad9865f7d71be8b9d076168246ba2fb07fa7680713fae57dd", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "commands": [ - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo/installed/SKILL.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 1600, - "outputSHA256": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo/installed/actions/01-capture-rule.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 1707, - "outputSHA256": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc 'cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo/installed/references/tool-paths.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo/installed/references/rule-authoring.md /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 17908, - "outputSHA256": "15a442337727680f6300d1b092aabc3d8985784935a507db1e4bb66b3c2ecc2e" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"pwd; rg --files --hidden -g '\"'!'\"\\\\.git/**' -g 'AGENTS*' -g 'CLAUDE.md' -g '*.md' -g '*.mdc' -g '*config*' -g '*settings*'; cat /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo/installed/assets/rule-template.md\"", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 397, - "outputSHA256": "d3887ff7afe9267e6ef328ba27f7b429c32eeb5a7abc23fb69555e114e31c4a9" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"cat .claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md; rg --files --hidden --no-ignore -g '\"'!.git/**'\"'; for d in /private /private/var /private/var/folders /private/var/folders/xr /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo; do for n in AGENTS.md AGENTS.override.md CLAUDE.md; do if test -f \\\"\"'$d/$n\"; then printf '\"'\\\\n%s\\\\n' \\\"\"'$d/$n\"; cat \"$d/$n\"; fi; done; done'", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 163, - "outputSHA256": "ed100f83f46a28d7464474e94ffefc3d597a54e15b6e8538243f78ea827eb798" - }, - { - "command": "/bin/zsh -lc \"cat package.json; if test -f docs/test-framework.md; then cat docs/test-framework.md; else printf '%s\\\\n' 'Missing: docs/test-framework.md'; fi\"", - "exit": 0, - "outputBytes": 50, - "outputSHA256": "b8c1adad295009e4413ca16467d856d8ec4bc27152a6b92521e36ff8c608078a" - } - ], - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "No files changed. Assessment: **needs review**.\n\nExisting [.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md](.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md) applies to `tests/**/*.py` and requires: \u201cUse the test framework approved in docs/test-framework.md.\u201d That document is missing, so compatibility with `unittest` cannot be established.\n\nComplete candidate for Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\nDecision required: confirm `unittest` is the approved framework and approve this exact candidate, supply the missing policy for reassessment, or cancel.\n\nThe installed [workflow](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cAn unresolved conflict or needs-review finding requires an explicit resolution of that finding before proceeding.\u201d Your capture confirmation does not resolve this finding.", - "fixtureFiles": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"tests/**/*.py\"\n---\n\n# Unit tests\n\n- Use the test framework approved in docs/test-framework.md.\n", - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" - }, - "rawEventsSHA256": "9d4eb838fccc831d7c10c54eb44878911a02ef5c532389b1547ca3cd07d87f31" - }, - "scope-uncertain": { - "receipt": { - "case": "scope-uncertain", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ofdnwunc", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [] - }, - "before": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "49719e0335aa2659637431b09c60a99c7ea7b4792542295e2785bb335b5abcde", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "49719e0335aa2659637431b09c60a99c7ea7b4792542295e2785bb335b5abcde", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "skill-hashes": { - "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", - "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", - "references/tool-paths.md": "ce7a9da327f0f7c3d8a540191de7a223f216a77c6d438e0178dae91ca760d245", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ofdnwunc/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ofdnwunc/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "No files changed. Assessment: **needs review**.\n\nExisting `.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md` applies to `**/*.py` and requires: \u201cFor the unit test files selected in config/unit-test-paths.json, use pytest.\u201d That config is missing, so overlap with your unittest requirement cannot be determined.\n\nComplete candidate, targeting all five confirmed tools:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}\n```\n\nPlease resolve the missing scope evidence, explicitly authorize replacing the existing pytest policy with this candidate, or cancel.\n\n[Action 02](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cAn unresolved conflict or needs-review finding requires an explicit resolution of that finding before proceeding.\u201d Your capture confirmation does not resolve this finding, so the workflow stops here.", - "fixtureFiles": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "---\npaths:\n - \"**/*.py\"\n---\n\n# Unit tests\n\n- For the unit test files selected in config/unit-test-paths.json, use pytest.\n", - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" - }, - "rawEventsSHA256": "6221c3dfd327e42db48b44501b8ca05b1104fdf1c02c0da35023515ef18d4fd3" - }, - "claude-local": { - "receipt": { - "case": "claude-local", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-mdm66onm", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [] - }, - "before": { - "CLAUDE.local.md": "f6f6bdd0fbb28b7e582991c063f0f4ec4868959cca6aa45e9dc2c8c374d17b2c", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - "CLAUDE.local.md": "f6f6bdd0fbb28b7e582991c063f0f4ec4868959cca6aa45e9dc2c8c374d17b2c", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "skill-hashes": { - "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", - "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", - "references/tool-paths.md": "8b985e2a360c5fa44d13742e8f79c92afb8ddf2c8e2a6b0083fffbd84bf0f13e", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-mdm66onm/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-mdm66onm/project, host project, tool Claude Code only. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Creation paused; no files changed.\n\nConflict: [CLAUDE.local.md](CLAUDE.local.md) requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d Its project-wide scope includes `tests/**/*.py`, where the candidate requires unittest.\n\nExact candidate: `05-testing/5-candidate`, description `Test conventions`, scope `tests/**/*.py`, Claude Code only.\n\n```markdown\n# Test conventions\n\n- Use unittest for all unit tests.\n```\n\nChoose: keep pytest, revise the candidate, or explicitly authorize changing `CLAUDE.local.md` to resolve the conflict.\n\nThe installed skill\u2019s [action 02](../installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cAn unresolved conflict or needs-review finding requires an explicit resolution of that finding before proceeding.\u201d", - "rawEventsSHA256": "6091cb2da7042580de5b85d590c946958d01910d45e4e55a9f702e8e987cbfd3", - "fixtureFiles": { - "CLAUDE.local.md": "# Local unit test policy\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n", - "package.json": "{\"type\":\"module\"}\n" - } - } -} diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-lifecycle.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-lifecycle.json deleted file mode 100644 index 72ce75e60..000000000 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-lifecycle.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,220 +0,0 @@ -{ - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q", - "results": [ - { - "case": "new", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [] - }, - { - "turn": "revise", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "before": { - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - } - }, - { - "turn": "approve", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": false, - "changed": [ - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md", - "AGENTS.md", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md" - ], - "before": { - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "exactBody": true - }, - { - "turn": "covered", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "before": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - } - }, - { - "turn": "keep", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "before": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - } - }, - { - "turn": "conflict", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "before": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - } - }, - { - "turn": "cancel", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "before": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - } - }, - { - "turn": "publish", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [], - "before": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - } - }, - { - "turn": "delete", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": false, - "changed": [ - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md", - "AGENTS.md", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md" - ], - "before": { - ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "008fb111bfead91b1f90fdb6d218174767fd720beca647362b627579ba965a92", - ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-constants.mdc": "59cf252d499beaecc5031ca6a425403a54617c070f64091e343ae265a0ee4db3", - ".github/instructions/01-constants.instructions.md": "8be35973070cc661c1bb078fc1a9f2e773a072564b115f3c1ac8a72876f23085", - "AGENTS.md": "65761db1d62d159a0fab4a0aabe282c88cf04550fd2f1ecbe561ca3e3fa62812", - "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md": "050dc7f373b52cacbe5761e7c4ddf2426b4c32cd7f1544605b1937deddd1fcfa", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - "AGENTS.md": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - } - } - ], - "turns": { - "initial": { - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"01-standards\", \"slug\": \"1-constants\", \"description\": \"Constants\", \"paths\": [\"src/**/*.ts\"], \"body\": \"# Constants\\n\\n- Name constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Assessment: **new**. Project contains only `package.json`; no existing rule sources or ancestor guidance were found. Supplied AGENTS.md instructions contain no competing constants policy. All five selected tools are supported.\n\nExact candidate:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"01-standards\",\"slug\":\"1-constants\",\"description\":\"Constants\",\"paths\":[\"src/**/*.ts\"],\"body\":\"# Constants\\n\\n- Name constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n\"}\n```\n\nProposed resolution: create this candidate for Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2.\n\n**Approve this exact candidate, revise it, or cancel?** No files changed.\n\n[Skill action 02](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cwait for an explicit user decision, including for **new**.\u201d Your confirmed capture choices do not satisfy this separate assessment decision." - }, - "revise": { - "prompt": "Change the candidate body to exactly \"# Constants\\n\\n- Name constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n- Export constants using named exports.\\n\" and create it. All earlier capture choices remain confirmed.", - "answer": "Reassessment: **new**. Original project still contains only `package.json`; no applicable existing rule covers or contradicts either bullet. No files changed.\n\nRevised candidate, targeting Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"01-standards\",\"slug\":\"1-constants\",\"description\":\"Constants\",\"paths\":[\"src/**/*.ts\"],\"body\":\"# Constants\\n\\n- Name constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n- Export constants using named exports.\\n\"}\n```\n\nApprove this reassessed candidate for creation?\n\nThe installed skill\u2019s [action 02, step 6](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cAny change to body, metadata, scope, destinations or replacement/merge resolution returns to Draft and comparison, then requires a new decision.\u201d Creation awaits that decision." - }, - "approve": { - "prompt": "I approve the exact revised candidate you just assessed, with both bullets, the same metadata, src/**/*.ts scope and all five hosts. Publish it now.", - "answer": "Published exact approved rule in the original project for all five hosts.\n\n- PASS canonical `aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md`\n- PASS Claude Code publication\n- PASS Cursor publication\n- PASS GitHub Copilot publication\n- PASS shared `AGENTS.md` for Codex/OpenCode V2\n\nExact body and scope verified; repeat publication byte-identical. Runtime consumption not tested. No application changes, installs, network calls or commits. Nothing pending." - }, - "covered": { - "prompt": "Create another rule: manual host project, all five hosts confirmed, category 01-standards, slug 1-public-values, description Public values, paths [\"src/**/*.ts\"], exact body \"# Public values\\n\\n- Write names of constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n\". Follow the installed skill from capture.", - "answer": "Assessment: **covered**. Existing [1-constants.md](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q/project/aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md) already requires \u201cName constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\u201d for the identical `src/**/*.ts` scope and all five hosts. Its Claude, Cursor, Copilot and shared `AGENTS.md` publications match canonical content and scope; signatures are intact.\n\nComplete candidate:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"01-standards\",\"slug\":\"1-public-values\",\"description\":\"Public values\",\"paths\":[\"src/**/*.ts\"],\"body\":\"# Public values\\n\\n- Write names of constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\\n\"}\n```\n\nProposed resolution: keep the existing rule, including its named-export requirement, without adding a duplicate. No files changed.\n\n**Confirm keeping the existing rule?**\n\nThe installed skill\u2019s [action 02](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires \u201can explicit user decision\u201d after assessment. Awaiting that resolution." - }, - "keep": { - "prompt": "Keep the existing policy. Do not create the candidate or modify existing files.", - "answer": "Existing policy retained. Candidate not created; no files changed. Nothing pending." - }, - "conflict": { - "prompt": "Create another rule: manual host project, all five hosts confirmed, category 01-standards, slug 1-lowercase-values, description Lowercase values, paths [\"src/**/*.ts\"], exact body \"# Lowercase values\\n\\n- Name every constant in lowerCamelCase.\\n\". Follow the installed skill from capture.", - "answer": "Assessment: **conflict**. Existing [1-constants.md](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q/project/aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-constants.md) requires \u201cName constants in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE.\u201d Its verified publications cover the same `src/**/*.ts` scope across all five hosts. Requiring `lowerCamelCase` contradicts that obligation.\n\nComplete candidate:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"01-standards\",\"slug\":\"1-lowercase-values\",\"description\":\"Lowercase values\",\"paths\":[\"src/**/*.ts\"],\"body\":\"# Lowercase values\\n\\n- Name every constant in lowerCamelCase.\\n\"}\n```\n\nProposed resolution: keep the existing policy. No files changed.\n\n**Keep the existing policy, or replace its naming requirement across all five hosts while preserving its named-export requirement?**\n\nThe installed skill\u2019s [action 02](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) states: \u201cAn unresolved conflict or needs-review finding requires an explicit resolution of that finding before proceeding.\u201d Awaiting your resolution." - }, - "cancel": { - "prompt": "Cancel this candidate. Keep every existing rule and publication unchanged.", - "answer": "Candidate cancelled. Every existing rule and publication remains unchanged. Nothing pending." - }, - "publish": { - "prompt": "Explicitly publish the existing canonical rule set to claude,cursor,copilot,codex,opencode using the installed skill. Do not change its body or targets.", - "answer": "Published existing canonical rule set to all five hosts.\n\n- PASS canonical `1-constants.md`\n- PASS Claude publication\n- PASS Cursor publication\n- PASS Copilot publication\n- PASS shared Codex/OpenCode `AGENTS.md`\n\nBody and targets unchanged. Repeat publication byte-identical; runtime consumption not tested. Nothing pending." - }, - "delete": { - "prompt": "Explicitly delete existing canonical rule 01-standards/1-constants and its publications on all five confirmed hosts using the installed skill.", - "answer": "Deleted `01-standards/1-constants` using the installed skill.\n\n- PASS canonical source removed\n- PASS Claude publication removed\n- PASS Cursor publication removed\n- PASS Copilot publication removed\n- PASS Codex/OpenCode shared contribution removed\n\n`package.json` unchanged. Repeat publication preserved deletion. Nothing pending." - } - } -} diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-merge.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-merge.json deleted file mode 100644 index d2a0afba7..000000000 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/native-merge.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,97 +0,0 @@ -{ - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-kyf8vbhs", - "results": [ - { - "case": "overlap", - "root": "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-kyf8vbhs", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "changed": [] - }, - { - "turn": "merge", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": true, - "before": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - } - }, - { - "turn": "approve-merge", - "exit": 0, - "unchanged": false, - "before": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "after": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ea7a6e761e39734447ac1826007f2e6c8121a4aed107a1baa484a92dd7d2e0eb", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "bfea5e988bee2a398325da998ee8c9843d45aed8988ccef9dd6ae88bc07fdca3", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "aa7831807e3e3d618c3e63d75f2e551f84dba6710d2baf91f897a05bea3ab207", - "AGENTS.md": "874a63eb836e5329d50e8b595174bb7a0f6e57ca5a66bf425992f7a8014ce48a", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "5056a2efb84f9cc80e5843b8868390b3d7d662bd42fcdb3c12aa5d09392e51ca", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - } - } - ], - "exactBody": true, - "noDuplicate": true, - "initialBefore": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "initialAfter": { - ".claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "e7503bd2e08ec2a94e0e4cac90c64901aa2c742ff3520c59e7d73801e98bad72", - ".cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc": "85a56abf468ef2578ac65fe9b702ec34c7fc90a35fb95d8dd7b9e46c711dde02", - ".github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md": "c562d21203ca82b0a5cccf763ab19c0790d584eae1176206aa8e3c853bde1e52", - "AGENTS.md": "6faf9ca19dac27f2accb7ebe8c53fe4f8485f4662fa0d5896de76b6b2528a320", - "aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md": "ab3b5271d9bdd20d5fc32566d7a1e4cc8e8e7df534c09aea542248e8f966019f", - "package.json": "1239d4d885dcad42201a27ed9324f8f0f760b78700d8db9ced39a511cffe7eae" - }, - "skill-hashes": { - "SKILL.md": "e4fe536c192b0eb7c39e20d497efc9f70702bc0e07a20eafed82e409fe3125d4", - "actions/01-capture-rule.md": "2978eb702cf523cacbad78f858ff4e24c198fc0c410240e3a6b2ac0fbd142d06", - "actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md": "f02e015b9848ab9526a829936beb105a5e945259f78e5e045e80076322332c81", - "actions/03-write-rule.md": "14ab835edc8f036e05053609e4caa422998d831ba045c2f58d0897152a3180cc", - "actions/04-validate.md": "98dcfaa62dce513756c0a11bfa8620df5341057c25e20c2a7b85dcfef1f8231e", - "assets/rule-template.md": "bfccef5e957e8d2de7aefe818196e82bf7691c8631452f4cc5b6e5ea526cdb47", - "references/rule-authoring.md": "965cfb21d94cd928ecae6436d85f4c489207dc1a88ef35a16ae5af04dc69e982", - "references/tool-paths.md": "ce7a9da327f0f7c3d8a540191de7a223f216a77c6d438e0178dae91ca760d245", - "scripts/write-rule.cjs": "70783e579b75b9e22760239cbfd4309641bdd73840b17e7dfd606a252679a420" - }, - "turns": { - "initial": { - "prompt": "Use the installed rule-generation skill at /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-kyf8vbhs/installed/SKILL.md. Follow its workflow for creating a rule. All capture choices are confirmed: manual mode, real project root /private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-kyf8vbhs/project, host project, tools Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2. The complete requested candidate metadata and body are exactly this JSON: {\"category\": \"05-testing\", \"slug\": \"5-candidate\", \"description\": \"Test conventions\", \"paths\": [\"tests/**/*.py\"], \"body\": \"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\\n- Put unit test files in tests/unit/.\\n\"}. Create this rule. Do not change application source, install packages, use network tools, or commit. This invocation supplies no later user message. If the workflow requires a further user decision, stop and present it.", - "answer": "Assessment: **overlap**. Existing `aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md` already requires \u201cUse pytest for all unit tests.\u201d for the identical scope, `tests/**/*.py`. The same requirement appears in `AGENTS.md` and the Claude Code, Cursor, and Copilot publications. Requiring `tests/unit/` adds a new obligation.\n\nComplete candidate, targeting all five confirmed tools:\n\n```json\n{\"category\":\"05-testing\",\"slug\":\"5-candidate\",\"description\":\"Test conventions\",\"paths\":[\"tests/**/*.py\"],\"body\":\"# Test conventions\\n\\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\\n- Put unit test files in tests/unit/.\\n\"}\n```\n\nProposed resolution: revise the candidate to contain only the new `tests/unit/` requirement. Alternatively, approve the exact candidate despite overlap, keep the existing rule, or cancel. Which resolution do you choose?\n\nNo files changed. The installed skill\u2019s [action 02](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-kyf8vbhs/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) requires: \u201cShow the complete candidate, findings and proposed resolution, then wait for an explicit user decision, including for **new**.\u201d Your capture confirmations do not satisfy this later decision, so the workflow stops here." - }, - "merge": { - "prompt": "Merge this candidate into existing canonical 05-testing/5-existing and update its five confirmed publications. Keep its existing description, category, slug, scope and targets. The proposed complete merged body is exactly \"# Python unit tests\\n\\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\\n- Put unit test files in tests/unit/.\\n\". Do not create 5-candidate.", - "answer": "Reassessment: merging into `05-testing/5-existing` resolves the overlap. It preserves the existing pytest requirement and adds the unit-test directory requirement. No conflict found in the inspected sources.\n\nMetadata and all five targets remain unchanged. Complete merged body:\n\n```markdown\n# Python unit tests\n\n- Use pytest for all unit tests.\n- Put unit test files in tests/unit/.\n```\n\nApprove this assessed merge and its publication updates?\n\nNo files changed; `5-candidate` was not created. The skill\u2019s [action 02, step 6](/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-kyf8vbhs/installed/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) says a changed merge resolution \u201creturns to Draft and comparison, then requires a new decision.\u201d This requires confirmation after reassessment." - }, - "approve-merge": { - "prompt": "I approve the exact merged candidate you just reassessed, explicitly updating aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md and its Claude, Cursor, Copilot, Codex and OpenCode V2 publications. Write and validate this resolution now.", - "answer": "Merged the exact approved body; existing metadata and targets preserved.\n\n- PASS `aidd_docs/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md`\n- PASS `.claude/rules/05-testing/5-existing.md`\n- PASS `.cursor/rules/05-testing/5-existing.mdc`\n- PASS `.github/instructions/05-existing.instructions.md`\n- PASS `AGENTS.md` \u2014 shared Codex/OpenCode V2 publication\n\nRepublishing was byte-identical. No `5-candidate` created. Runtime host consumption was not tested." - } - } -} diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/runtime.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/runtime.json deleted file mode 100644 index 02a7880fd..000000000 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/runtime.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,6 +0,0 @@ -{ - "executable": "/opt/homebrew/bin/codex", - "version": "codex-cli 0.154.0", - "auth": "Logged in using ChatGPT", - "platform": "Darwin arm64" -} diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/teardown.json b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/teardown.json deleted file mode 100644 index caddbf643..000000000 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/receipts/teardown.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,23 +0,0 @@ -{ - "localArchive": "/private/tmp/aidd-791-reviewed-native-fixtures.tar.gz", - "archiveSHA256": "22aafc552fcca61833cdc6e37535ba1278923585dff72c5596b1c7125e2e6dfe", - "removedReviewedFixtures": [ - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-baseline-JPnRpI", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-0og_z8lk", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-avswso51", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-d40ne3yt", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-f08cf2dd", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-jzb3gnq2", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-k7al9tlo", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-kyf8vbhs", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-mdm66onm", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-njf20lfx", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ofdnwunc", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-ojh5c01q", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-pa64pbd1", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-qb2gmmss", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-sq2s6hvg", - "/private/var/folders/xr/1vw6jx411dxf789cdlv_jg4c0000gn/T/aidd-791-probe-t4gu559a" - ], - "projectBaseline": "Original workspace personal changes preserved; all native project fixtures were disposable." -} diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/review.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/review.md deleted file mode 100644 index cda8a5f11..000000000 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/review.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,41 +0,0 @@ -# Review: Rule assessment and concision - -- **Verdict**: approve -- **Diff**: `ce80635221266dd7529d0bdc4fa98d15b9ddeb6c...57ab25319943c0ef8018dabd77fe55c555a6964d` -- **Axes run**: code, functional, relevancy -- **Date**: 2026_10_12 -- **Findings**: 0 critical, 0 warning, 0 minor -- **Score**: 100% of scoped criteria fulfilled - -## Phases - -### Phase 1 — Assess, resolve, preserve publication - -- [x] Complete candidate assessed and explicitly approved before create/update writes: `actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md:13`, `actions/03-write-rule.md:13`. -- [x] Five classifications cite sources and justify scope/rendering exclusions: `actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md:17`, `references/tool-paths.md:24`. -- [x] Changed resolutions require reassessment/approval; keep/cancel preserves bytes: `actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md:32`, `receipts/concise-native.json:614`, `:681`, `:731`, `:838`. -- [x] Publish/delete bypass preserved; five-host writer and CLI unchanged versus base: `SKILL.md:13`, `actions/01-capture-rule.md:14`, `references/tool-paths.md:46`; empty writer/CLI diff. -- [x] Native evidence covers required cases and uncertainty: `receipts/concise-native.json:29`. Read all 27 answers; verified event hashes, installed assets and 15 unchanged project snapshots against disk. -- [x] Required gates green; no unresolved blocker: final commit log `# pass 681`, `# fail 0`; pre-push Knip green, 7,025 CLI tests passed, one skipped. -- [x] User's concision revision preserves contracts and newer host support: seven runtime files total 1,766 words; assessment 236. Router owns flow, references own shared constraints; OpenCode V1/V2 discovery retained. - -## Findings - -| Sev | Kind | Phase | Location | Issue | Fix | -| --- | ---- | ----- | -------- | ----- | --- | - -None. - -## Verification - -| Metric | Value | -| --- | --- | -| Verified | 100% (7/7 acceptance criteria) | -| Files checked | Seven runtime Markdown files under `plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/`; unchanged template; both catalogs; plan, phase, verification and receipt evidence; writer/CLI diff | -| Checklist | DRY, coherence, minimality, no dead/debug content: fulfilled; architecture and applicable authoring rules checked | -| Gates | `/private/tmp/aidd-791-short-cleanup-commit.log`, `/private/tmp/aidd-791-short-push.log`; no duplicate test/model runs | -| Distribution | Final Codex flat and Claude marketplace actions, references, template and writer byte-identical; flat router changes only frontmatter serialization/name | -| Replay boundary | Tested hashes retained separately from final hashes. Only post-replay runtime difference removes the verification-date prefix; all final hashes checked | -| Limits | Semantic judgment and approval remain instructions, not writer locks. Native execution: Codex only; other hosts' native consumption unproven | -| Unchecked | none | -| Unplanned | none | diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md deleted file mode 100644 index be830ac3c..000000000 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_12_rule-conflict-assessment/verification.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,27 +0,0 @@ -# Verification: pre-write rule assessment - -Issue [#791](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/framework/issues/791); current base `ce80635221266dd7529d0bdc4fa98d15b9ddeb6c`. - -## Concision - -Following Alex’s [#981](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/framework/pull/981) and [#950](https://github.com/ai-driven-dev/framework/pull/950): seven runtime Markdown files, 3,480 → 1,766 whitespace-delimited words (−49%). Assessment: 597 → 236. The unchanged 43-word template is excluded from both totals. Flow belongs to the router; each action or reference owns its constraints. - -## Evidence - -[Concise replay](receipts/concise-native.json) records tested/final-source hashes, prompts, answers, fixture data and project snapshots. Codex 0.162.1 used ChatGPT login with API keys unset: 27 successful calls across 17 sessions. - -- Fifteen fresh assessments stop without changing project bytes: new, covered, overlap, conflict, disjoint, uncertain meaning/scope, edited rendering, plugin source, Copilot guidance/import, Claude local guidance, OpenCode V1 configured instructions/fallback, and actual CLI flat Codex distribution. -- Nine-turn lifecycle: reassess changed body, require subsequent approval, publish exact body to five hosts, covered/keep, conflict/cancel, byte-identical republish, delete. Existing deletion behavior retains empty AGENTS.md. -- Three-turn merge: reassess the changed resolution, require subsequent approval, update the selected source with the exact merged body; no duplicate source. - -Root regression command: `node scripts/check-tests-leave-git-alone.js -- node --test 'scripts/__tests__/**/*.test.js'`: 681 passed, zero failures/skips. Focused checks: 107 passed, including 61 writer tests. CLI flat Codex and Claude marketplace translations preserve action, reference, template and writer bytes. Writer and CLI have no diff against the current base. - -Pre-push gates: Knip passed; CLI suite passed 7,025 tests across 540 files, with one test/file skipped. - -The only post-replay runtime edit removes a nonnormative verification-date prefix. Policy instructions and official links remain byte-identical; receipts distinguish both hashes. - -## Limits - -Semantic comparison remains model judgment. Approval is a skill instruction, not a script lock. Native replay uses Codex; publication to five hosts does not prove their native runtime consumption. Official discovery sources are linked in `plan.md` and the skill’s tool-path reference. Historical receipts retain their earlier source/runtime hashes and are not evidence for the shortened version. - -Independent verdict: [review](review.md), [challenge](challenge.md). Independent review approves all seven criteria; outcome confidence 95%, no deal breaker. The 17 replay fixtures were archived locally and removed: [teardown](receipts/concise-teardown.json). diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md index 1e42d6ad5..a71137aea 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md @@ -21,7 +21,7 @@ flowchart LR ## Actions -Read each action file in `actions/` before executing it. +Read each numbered action file in `actions/` before executing it. | Action | Does | | --- | --- | diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md index 6e1333e60..fafbb3450 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md @@ -2,19 +2,12 @@ ## Input -A topic, `auto`, or an existing publish/delete selection. Empty means manual. - -## Output - -Confirmed operation, topic, category, slug, description, scope and destinations. +Topic, `auto`, or publish/delete selection. Empty means manual. ## Process 1. **Gate.** Read [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). - - For publish/delete, confirm existing sources and hosts; continue to action 03. - - Publishing manual canonical body edits uses this bypass. -2. **Topic.** Confirm the topic, or scan and propose rules in auto mode. -3. **Place.** Choose category and slug through [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md). -4. **Scope.** State literal globs or all files, with a one-line description. -5. **Destinations.** Confirm detected supported hosts or the plugin source directory. - - Report unsupported hosts and alternatives. + - Publish/delete: confirm sources and hosts, then action 03; manual canonical body edits remain publishable. +2. **Capture.** Confirm topic, category/slug, description and scope through [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md). + - Auto: scan and propose rules first. +3. **Target.** Confirm supported hosts or plugin directory; report unsupported hosts and alternatives. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md index 3a6ec292a..1971fdf27 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md @@ -2,37 +2,27 @@ ## Input -Confirmed intent and destinations. - -## Output - -Approved candidate and resolution, or no write. +Confirmed intent and targets. ## Process -1. **Draft.** Prepare complete bodies and metadata in context using [rule-template.md](../assets/rule-template.md) and [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md). - - Strip scaffolding; settle splits before assessment. - - Write no rules, requests or publications yet. -2. **Discover.** Read applicable sources through [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). -3. **Compare.** Compare obligations, prohibitions, scope, conditions, exceptions and priority, regardless of names. - - Include an update's prior source and intended changes. - - Prove disjointness independently of current file matches. - - Uncertain applicability, meaning or precedence means **needs review**. -4. **Report.** Cite paths, decisive text, exclusions and scope reasoning for each finding. - - Never hide conflict/uncertainty behind new/covered. +1. **Draft.** Prepare complete bodies, metadata, scope and targets in context through [rule-template.md](../assets/rule-template.md) and [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md). + - Remove scaffolding; settle splits. Write no rules, requests or publications. +2. **Discover.** Read sources through [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). +3. **Compare.** Compare obligations, prohibitions, scope, conditions, exceptions and priority, including prior sources for updates. + - Exclude only proven disjoint scopes, independently of current files. +4. **Report.** Cite source paths, decisive text, exclusions and reasoning for every finding. | Finding | Meaning | | --- | --- | - | new | no applicable coverage, overlap or conflict | - | covered | all obligations already supplied throughout candidate scope | - | overlap | compatible partial repetition or extension | + | new | no coverage, overlap or conflict | + | covered | obligations already supplied throughout scope | + | overlap | compatible partial repetition/extension | | conflict | incompatible obligations or unjustified weakening | - | needs review | missing evidence or decision | + | needs review | uncertain applicability/meaning/precedence or missing evidence | -5. **Decide.** Show complete candidates and findings; await explicit resolution, even for **new**. - - Offer approve, keep, revise, merge/replace or cancel. - - Topic approval is insufficient. - - Keep/cancel leaves project bytes unchanged. - - Existing-source changes require identified sources and publication permissions. - - Resolve every conflict/uncertainty before proceeding. - - Changed body, metadata, scope, targets, resolution or source evidence returns to assessment and approval. +5. **Resolve.** Show full candidates; await explicit approve, keep, revise, merge/replace or cancel, including for new. + - Topic approval is insufficient; never hide conflict/uncertainty or proceed unresolved. + - Existing-source changes require explicit identified-source/publication permissions. + - Changes to body, metadata, scope, targets, resolution or source evidence require reassessment and reapproval. + - Keep/cancel changes no project bytes. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-write-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-write-rule.md index 892c22cd3..9e5d8d8fb 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-write-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-write-rule.md @@ -2,17 +2,10 @@ ## Input -Approved candidates and source changes, or confirmed publish/delete selection. - -## Output - -Affected sources, publications and refusals. +Approved candidates/resolution, or confirmed publish/delete. ## Process -1. **Prepare.** Carry the exact approved bodies and metadata without regeneration. - - For host create/update, prepare the JSON request through [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). - - Publish/delete needs no candidate request. -2. **Write.** Execute the confirmed mode and operations from `tool-paths.md`. - - Apply only approved source changes, including merge/replacement deletions. - - Report script refusals verbatim. +1. **Write.** Apply [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md) using exact approved bodies, metadata, scope and targets; never regenerate. + - Execute only approved source changes, including merge/replacement deletions. + - Report refusals verbatim. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/04-validate.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/04-validate.md index 40a33d61a..bb4c20e1c 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/04-validate.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/04-validate.md @@ -2,16 +2,10 @@ ## Input -Affected files and approved resolution. - -## Output - -One pass/fail result per affected rule. +Affected files and resolution. ## Process -1. **Operation.** Confirm expected sources/publications exist, or selected deletions are absent. - - Remaining rules and user bytes must survive. -2. **Content.** Check [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md), exact approved body, scope, destinations and resolution. -3. **Publication.** Check [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md), including native syntax, shared-body uniqueness, last-rule cleanup, memory preservation and byte-idempotent republishing. -4. **Report.** Separate publication from runtime consumption; only actual host evidence proves consumption. +1. **Check.** Verify [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md), approved body/scope/targets and [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). + - Check existence/deletion, shared uniqueness/cleanup, surviving user/memory bytes and byte-idempotent republishing. +2. **Report.** Give pass/fail per affected rule; publication does not prove runtime consumption. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/assets/rule-template.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/assets/rule-template.md index a2f28fa3f..96e338271 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/assets/rule-template.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/assets/rule-template.md @@ -1,8 +1,5 @@ -# +Replace placeholders; remove this instruction and unused lines. - +# -- <Concise rule preserving exact requirements.> -- <Another.> - -<!-- Several themes? Group the bullets under `## headings` (skip groups for a short rule). One tiny example per group, only if it removes ambiguity. --> +- <Requirement.> diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md index 574e835aa..f92cbd8b5 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md @@ -2,34 +2,29 @@ ## Rules -- **R1.** One topic per file; split crowded rules. -- **R2.** Concise bullets; preserve literals, conditions and exceptions. -- **R3.** Scope to applicable files or all files. +- **R1.** One topic per file. +- **R2.** Concise bullets preserving literals, conditions and exceptions. +- **R3.** Explicit file scope or all files. - **R4.** English only. -- **R5.** Never repeat, weaken or contradict active bullets within a rule; resolve cross-rule findings in action 02. +- **R5.** Never repeat, weaken or contradict active bullets within a rule. ## Naming -`#-slug[@version][-specificity]`: single-digit category index, no zero-padding. Examples: `2-typescript-naming`, `3-react@19-hooks`. +`#-slug[@version][-specificity]`: single-digit category prefix, no zero-padding. -## Categories +| Index | Category | +| --- | --- | +| 00 | architecture | +| 01 | standards | +| 02 | programming-languages | +| 03 | frameworks-and-libraries | +| 04 | tooling | +| 05 | testing | +| 06 | design-patterns | +| 07 | quality | +| 08 | domain | +| 09 | other | -| Index | Category | Covers | -| --- | --- | --- | -| 00 | architecture | Clean, Hexagonal, API design | -| 01 | standards | naming, imports, style | -| 02 | programming-languages | language syntax | -| 03 | frameworks-and-libraries | React, Prisma | -| 04 | tooling | ESLint, Docker, CI | -| 05 | testing | fixtures, mocking | -| 06 | design-patterns | Repository, Factory | -| 07 | quality | performance, security | -| 08 | domain | entities, DTOs | -| 09 | other | miscellaneous | +Prefer framework `03`, syntax `02`, style `01`, architecture `00`, then `04`–`08`, else `09`. -Pick the most specific: framework `03`, syntax `02`, style `01`, architecture `00`, then `04`–`08`, else `09`. - -## Content - -- Group related bullets under `## group` only for multiple themes. -- Add a tiny good-code example only to remove ambiguity. +- Group multiple themes under `## group`; examples must be tiny, clarifying good code. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md index 1671386d9..0884d8f4e 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md @@ -1,96 +1,58 @@ # Tool paths -## Gate - -- Missing/unreadable installed reference: stop and name it. -- Confirm mode and hosts; shared `AGENTS.md` does not identify installations. - ## Publications | Host / ID | Target | Scope | | --- | --- | --- | -| Claude / `claude` | `.claude/rules/<category>/<slug>.md` | YAML `paths`; omit for all files | +| Claude / `claude` | `.claude/rules/<category>/<slug>.md` | YAML `paths` array; omit for all files | | Cursor / `cursor` | `.cursor/rules/<category>/<slug>.mdc` | `description`, comma-joined `globs`, `alwaysApply: false`; all-files omits globs, uses true | | Copilot / `copilot` | `.github/instructions/<NN>-<name>.instructions.md` | comma-joined `applyTo`; all-files `**` | -| Codex / `codex` | root `AGENTS.md` | shared signed `aidd_rules`; textual scope | +| Codex / `codex` | root `AGENTS.md` | shared signed `aidd_rules`, textual scope | | OpenCode / `opencode` | same root `AGENTS.md` | same contribution, V1/V2 | -- Naming follows `rule-authoring.md`; Copilot replaces the slug prefix with the two-digit category: `01-standards/1-naming` → `01-naming.instructions.md`. -- Shared presentation: `Applies to:` with literal code-span globs or `all files`; complete body unchanged, no identity heading. -- Preserve leading ATX/single-line Setext titles; otherwise add the description heading. Detection excludes fenced/indented examples, not a full Markdown parser. -- Codex/OpenCode share one physical contribution; hosts discovering multiple surfaces may receive duplicate context. -- Plugin source: `plugins/<plugin>/rules/<category>/<slug>.md`, YAML `paths` for scoped rules, otherwise no frontmatter; no project metadata/fan-out. +- Copilot renames `01-standards/1-naming` → `01-naming.instructions.md`. -## Assessment discovery +## Discovery -- Read-only: never invoke the writer to discover/compare. -- Host mode: inspect `aidd_docs/rules/**/*.md`, recorded targets and sources below, including user text outside generated blocks. -- Plugin mode: inspect confirmed plugin rules, project authoring guidance and known companion policies; do not assume other plugins installed. +- Read-only; never invoke the writer for assessment. +- Host mode: canonical `aidd_docs/rules/**/*.md`, recorded targets, native directories recursively at relevant root/nested locations, and guidance below. +- Plugin mode: confirmed plugin rules, project authoring guidance and known companion policies. -| Host | Project sources | +| Host | Additional project guidance | | --- | --- | -| Claude | `.claude/rules/**/*.md`; cwd/project ancestors/relevant descendants: `CLAUDE.md`, `.claude/CLAUDE.md`, `CLAUDE.local.md`. Conditional cwd/ancestors `AGENTS.md`, `.claude/AGENTS.md`, nested `AGENTS.md`: verify version, built-in plugin, Project instructions mode and competing Claude files. | -| Cursor | root/relevant nested `.cursor/rules/**/*.mdc`, `AGENTS.md`; CLI also root `CLAUDE.md` | -| Copilot | root/cwd/intermediate/relevant file-path descendants: `.github/copilot-instructions.md`, `AGENTS.md`, `CLAUDE.md`, `.claude/CLAUDE.md`, `GEMINI.md`; `.github/instructions/**/*.instructions.md` except intermediate directories, matching `applyTo` | -| Codex | root/relevant nested directories: first nonempty `AGENTS.override.md`, `AGENTS.md`, configured fallbacks, in order | -| OpenCode | V2: project/upward/nested `AGENTS.md`. V1: nearest upward `AGENTS.md`, enabled `CLAUDE.md` fallback when absent, explicit project config `instructions` sources. | +| Claude | cwd/project ancestors/relevant descendants: `CLAUDE.md`, `.claude/CLAUDE.md`, `CLAUDE.local.md`; conditional cwd/ancestors `AGENTS.md`, `.claude/AGENTS.md`, nested `AGENTS.md`: verify version, built-in plugin, Project instructions mode and competing Claude files | +| Cursor | root/nested `AGENTS.md`, nested `.cursor/rules`; CLI also root `CLAUDE.md` | +| Copilot | root/cwd/intermediate/relevant file-path descendants: `.github/copilot-instructions.md`, `AGENTS.md`, `CLAUDE.md`, `.claude/CLAUDE.md`, `GEMINI.md`; modular instructions exclude intermediate directories, require matching `applyTo` | +| Codex | root/nested: first nonempty `AGENTS.override.md`, `AGENTS.md`, configured fallbacks, in order | +| OpenCode | V2: project/upward/nested `AGENTS.md`; V1: nearest upward AGENTS, enabled `CLAUDE.md` fallback when absent, explicit project config `instructions` sources | -- Include loaded ancestor guidance and explicit configured sources; no home/account scan or completeness claim. -- Use documented scope/inheritance, including future files. Shared textual scope is not a directory boundary. -- Relevant unknown activation, configuration, unreadable sources, meaning or precedence requires **needs review**; existence alone proves no activation. -- Deduplicate only verified canonical body/scope renderings with intact ownership; retain every path. Keep differing native edits, unsigned user rules and outside-block guidance separate. Missing publication does not exclude canonical intent. -- Follow documented host imports read-only. Copilot recursively expands `@relative-path` in repository-wide/agent sources except `GEMINI.md`, never modular instructions; absolute/home-relative paths are not loaded. -- Bound imports to the repository with cycle detection; unsafe/outside/symlink escapes or uncertainty requires review when relevant. Never execute imported content. OpenCode V1 plain references are not automatically expanded. -- Disabled Copilot sources are inactive; applicable repository/agent files have no general precedence. +- Include loaded ancestors, configured sources, future-file scopes and user text outside generated blocks; no home/account scan or completeness claim. +- Relevant unknown activation/configuration, unreadable sources or precedence means **needs review**; existence proves no activation. +- Deduplicate only canonical body/scope renderings with verified ownership, retaining every path. Differing native edits and unsigned user policies remain separate; missing publications do not exclude canonical intent. +- Follow documented host imports, bounded to the repository with cycle detection; unsafe/external/symlink escapes or uncertainty requires review when relevant. Never execute imported content. +- Copilot recursively imports `@relative-path` from repository-wide/agent sources except GEMINI, never modular instructions or absolute/home-relative paths. Disabled sources are inactive; repository/agent sources lack general precedence. +- V1 plain references are not automatically expanded. -## Installed writer +## Write -- Resolve absolute `scripts/write-rule.cjs` beside loaded installed `SKILL.md`, native or flat; never assume checkout/project paths or AIDD CLI. -- Node built-ins only; supports ES-module projects. -- After approval, prepare JSON outside rule destinations: +- Missing/unreadable installed reference: stop. +- **Plugin mode**: directly write/delete approved `plugins/<plugin>/rules/<category>/<slug>.md` sources; scoped YAML `paths` or no frontmatter. No writer/fan-out/project metadata. -```json -{ - "category": "01-standards", - "slug": "1-naming", - "description": "Naming conventions", - "paths": ["src/**/*.ts", "test/**/*.ts"], - "body": "# Naming\n\n- Keep names clear.\n" -} -``` +### Host mode -- Use a real absolute project, explicit confirmed IDs and the operation: +- Shared AGENTS identifies no installation. +- Resolve absolute `scripts/write-rule.cjs` beside loaded installed `SKILL.md`; no checkout/project-relative/CLI assumption. +- After approval, prepare JSON outside destinations: category, slug, description, body strings; optional paths array. Description: one line. Empty/omitted paths: all files. Body: no leading YAML frontmatter. Comma globs: refuse; split alternatives. ```sh -node "$installed_rule_script" --project "$project_root" --tools claude,cursor,copilot,codex,opencode --input "$request_json" -node "$installed_rule_script" --project "$project_root" --tools claude,cursor,copilot,codex,opencode --publish -node "$installed_rule_script" --project "$project_root" --tools claude,cursor,copilot,codex,opencode --delete 01-standards/1-naming +node "$installed_rule_script" --project "$project_root" --tools "$confirmed_ids" --input "$request_json" ``` -- JSON accepts exactly category, slug, description, optional paths, body. Empty/omitted paths means all files; description is one line; body must not start with YAML frontmatter. -- Reject comma globs, including brace alternatives; supply separate patterns. Host parsers determine actual matching. -- Create/update stores confirmed targets in `aidd_docs/rules/<category>/<slug>.md`; target changes clean removed targets. -- Publish synchronizes named native hosts and complete canonical-target shared contribution. Delete cleans the source and previous publications; last shared deletion removes its contribution. -- Never replace/remove generated outputs manually. - -## Ownership and refusals - -- Canonical JSON comment owns version/category/slug/description/paths/targets: preserve syntax and key/target order. Manual body edits remain explicitly publishable. -- Native signatures or exact prior canonical rendering prove ownership. Differing unowned/edited native outputs and edited/duplicate/incomplete shared contributions refuse the entire operation before writes. -- Restore intact generated outputs; move authorized edits into canonical bodies before retrying. -- Signatures detect edits, not hostile recomputation; shared signature covers payload and separator. -- Preflight the complete prospective set: reject symlinks/ancestors, traversal, reserved markers outside fenced examples, unclosed fences, invalid UTF-8 and unpaired Unicode surrogates. -- Preserve full bodies, valid Unicode, CRLF, memory and every byte outside the shared contribution; republishing is byte-idempotent. -- File replacement is atomic, not a multi-file transaction against disk failure/concurrent writers. -- Codex refuses root `AGENTS.override.md` even empty, and prospective local AGENTS over default 32 KiB. Other project documents share configurable budget; global guidance is separate ([implementation](https://github.com/openai/codex/blob/092d3acd6bec3e3a14bdc7e7a2810ab628ab759d/codex-rs/core/src/agents_md.rs#L63)). No configuration changes or remaining-budget guarantee. -- No automatic legacy migration: `.opencode/rules`, `.codex/rules` stay untouched. Legacy `aidd_opencode_rules` refuses with `Ambiguous or legacy AIDD rule contribution; no automatic migration.` or incomplete-block error; resolve explicitly. Standalone-rule archives remain unsupported. - -## Runtime verification - -- Publication is not consumption. Check matching/nonmatching files in actual hosts; malformed/unmatched patterns may activate nothing. -- Fresh sessions: Codex loads instructions at startup; Copilot needs new/resumed sessions; V2 refreshes ambient AGENTS before requests but nested guidance needs restart. -- Claude rules require project settings; Cursor rules concern Agent, not Tab/Inline Edit. -- Codex `.codex/rules` is not Markdown guidance; OpenCode publication uses root AGENTS only, never `.opencode/rules`. +- Project: real absolute directory; confirmed IDs comma-separated. `--publish` or `--delete category/slug` replaces `--input "$request_json"`. +- Never edit generated outputs or canonical metadata manually. Manual canonical body edits remain publishable. +- Writer preflights ownership and targets, cleans removed publications and preserves unrelated bytes. Never bypass refusals or silently migrate legacy rules. +- Root Codex override refuses even empty; local 32 KiB check cannot guarantee total instruction budget. +- Host parsers determine applicability; check actual matching/nonmatching files in fresh sessions. Physical deduplication does not guarantee deduplicated host context. ## Official contracts From f303acfc3834d355a8f04244e95719ce9e212f4e Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE <baptiste.lafourcade@gmail.com> Date: Mon, 12 Oct 2026 22:31:57 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 07/24] refactor(aidd-context): remove duplicate publication guidance --- .../skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md index fafbb3450..f06c0d613 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md @@ -7,7 +7,7 @@ Topic, `auto`, or publish/delete selection. Empty means manual. ## Process 1. **Gate.** Read [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). - - Publish/delete: confirm sources and hosts, then action 03; manual canonical body edits remain publishable. + - Publish/delete: confirm sources and hosts, then action 03. 2. **Capture.** Confirm topic, category/slug, description and scope through [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md). - Auto: scan and propose rules first. 3. **Target.** Confirm supported hosts or plugin directory; report unsupported hosts and alternatives. From c822d9d51ce90ba7998c8bebcbdfa13530faa299 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE <baptiste.lafourcade@gmail.com> Date: Tue, 13 Oct 2026 04:41:44 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 08/24] refactor(aidd-context): simplify rule assessment actions --- .../actions/01-capture-rule.md | 6 +++- .../actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md | 30 ++++++++----------- .../05-rule-generate/actions/03-write-rule.md | 10 +++++-- .../05-rule-generate/actions/04-validate.md | 6 +++- 4 files changed, 29 insertions(+), 23 deletions(-) diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md index f06c0d613..8c600e8f1 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md @@ -10,4 +10,8 @@ Topic, `auto`, or publish/delete selection. Empty means manual. - Publish/delete: confirm sources and hosts, then action 03. 2. **Capture.** Confirm topic, category/slug, description and scope through [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md). - Auto: scan and propose rules first. -3. **Target.** Confirm supported hosts or plugin directory; report unsupported hosts and alternatives. +3. **Target.** Confirm supported hosts or plugin directory. + +## Rules + +- Report unsupported hosts and alternatives. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md index 1971fdf27..97b58a74d 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md @@ -6,23 +6,17 @@ Confirmed intent and targets. ## Process -1. **Draft.** Prepare complete bodies, metadata, scope and targets in context through [rule-template.md](../assets/rule-template.md) and [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md). - - Remove scaffolding; settle splits. Write no rules, requests or publications. -2. **Discover.** Read sources through [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). -3. **Compare.** Compare obligations, prohibitions, scope, conditions, exceptions and priority, including prior sources for updates. - - Exclude only proven disjoint scopes, independently of current files. -4. **Report.** Cite source paths, decisive text, exclusions and reasoning for every finding. +1. **Draft.** Prepare complete bodies, metadata, scope and targets in context from [rule-template.md](../assets/rule-template.md) and [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md). +2. **Compare.** Read sources through [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md); compare obligations, prohibitions, scope, conditions, exceptions and priority, including prior sources for updates. +3. **Report.** Classify new, covered, overlap, conflict or needs review; cite paths, decisive text and scope reasoning. +4. **Resolve.** Show full candidates; await explicit approval or keep/revise/merge/replace/cancel. - | Finding | Meaning | - | --- | --- | - | new | no coverage, overlap or conflict | - | covered | obligations already supplied throughout scope | - | overlap | compatible partial repetition/extension | - | conflict | incompatible obligations or unjustified weakening | - | needs review | uncertain applicability/meaning/precedence or missing evidence | +## Rules -5. **Resolve.** Show full candidates; await explicit approve, keep, revise, merge/replace or cancel, including for new. - - Topic approval is insufficient; never hide conflict/uncertainty or proceed unresolved. - - Existing-source changes require explicit identified-source/publication permissions. - - Changes to body, metadata, scope, targets, resolution or source evidence require reassessment and reapproval. - - Keep/cancel changes no project bytes. +- No rule/request/publication writes before explicit resolution, including new. +- Topic approval is insufficient. +- Exclude only proven disjoint scopes, independently of current files. +- Never proceed with unresolved conflicts/uncertainty. +- Existing changes require explicit identified-source/publication permissions. +- After candidate, resolution or source-evidence changes, reassess and await fresh user approval before writing. +- Keep/cancel leaves project bytes unchanged. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-write-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-write-rule.md index 9e5d8d8fb..3f4f8a95a 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-write-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-write-rule.md @@ -6,6 +6,10 @@ Approved candidates/resolution, or confirmed publish/delete. ## Process -1. **Write.** Apply [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md) using exact approved bodies, metadata, scope and targets; never regenerate. - - Execute only approved source changes, including merge/replacement deletions. - - Report refusals verbatim. +1. **Write.** Apply [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). +2. **Report.** Report refusals verbatim. + +## Rules + +- Preserve exact approved bodies, metadata, scope and targets; never regenerate. +- Execute only approved source changes, including merge/replacement deletions. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/04-validate.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/04-validate.md index bb4c20e1c..6623fe495 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/04-validate.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/04-validate.md @@ -8,4 +8,8 @@ Affected files and resolution. 1. **Check.** Verify [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md), approved body/scope/targets and [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). - Check existence/deletion, shared uniqueness/cleanup, surviving user/memory bytes and byte-idempotent republishing. -2. **Report.** Give pass/fail per affected rule; publication does not prove runtime consumption. +2. **Report.** Give pass/fail per affected rule. + +## Rules + +- Publication does not prove runtime consumption. From 5ee78e3fc7225759dcf346c3c88ff6cd882e043f Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE <baptiste.lafourcade@gmail.com> Date: Tue, 13 Oct 2026 05:10:03 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 09/24] refactor(aidd-context): fold rule assessment into capture --- docs/CATALOG.md | 2 +- plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md | 5 ++--- .../skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md | 17 ++++++++------ .../actions/01-capture-rule.md | 11 ++++++---- .../actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md | 22 ------------------- .../{03-write-rule.md => 02-write-rule.md} | 3 +-- .../{04-validate.md => 03-validate.md} | 2 +- 7 files changed, 22 insertions(+), 40 deletions(-) delete mode 100644 plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md rename plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/{03-write-rule.md => 02-write-rule.md} (74%) rename plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/{04-validate.md => 03-validate.md} (96%) diff --git a/docs/CATALOG.md b/docs/CATALOG.md index 292d67934..a32432450 100644 --- a/docs/CATALOG.md +++ b/docs/CATALOG.md @@ -25,7 +25,7 @@ Bootstrap, project init, context-artifact generation, diagrams, learning, and ex | `02-project-memory` | Give the AI a memory of the project, wired into the tools you use | `01-scan`, `02-write`, `03-check`, `04-sync` | | `03-context-generate` | Router that dispatches an artifact-generation request to the dedicated generator below | delegates to `04`–`08` (and plugins / marketplaces) | | `04-skill-generate` | Generate a router-based skill across the host AI tool(s) | `01-scope`, `02-plan`, `03-write`, `04-validate` | -| `05-rule-generate` | Generate a coding rule that governs editor and agent behavior | `01-capture-rule`, `02-assess-existing-rules`, `03-write-rule`, `04-validate` | +| `05-rule-generate` | Generate a coding rule that governs editor and agent behavior | `01-capture-rule`, `02-write-rule`, `03-validate` | | `06-agent-generate` | Generate an agent across the host AI tool(s) | `01-capture-agent`, `02-write-agent`, `03-validate` | | `07-command-generate` | Generate a flat slash command across the host AI tool(s) | `01-capture-command`, `02-write-command`, `03-validate` | | `08-hook-generate` | Generate a lifecycle hook across the host AI tool(s) | `01-capture-hook`, `02-write-hook`, `03-validate` | diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md b/plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md index a685ef29e..06c1317db 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md @@ -117,9 +117,8 @@ Auto-generated index of skills, agents, references and assets shipped by the `ai | Group | File | Description | |-------|------|---| | `actions` | [01-capture-rule.md](skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md) | - | -| `actions` | [02-assess-existing-rules.md](skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md) | - | -| `actions` | [03-write-rule.md](skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-write-rule.md) | - | -| `actions` | [04-validate.md](skills/05-rule-generate/actions/04-validate.md) | - | +| `actions` | [02-write-rule.md](skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md) | - | +| `actions` | [03-validate.md](skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md) | - | | `assets` | [rule-template.md](skills/05-rule-generate/assets/rule-template.md) | - | | `references` | [rule-authoring.md](skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md) | - | | `references` | [tool-paths.md](skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md) | - | diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md index a71137aea..69381bb5d 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md @@ -9,11 +9,9 @@ argument-hint: topic | auto ```mermaid flowchart LR request --> capture-rule - capture-rule -->|create/update| assess-existing-rules - capture-rule -->|publish/delete| write-rule - assess-existing-rules -->|revise| assess-existing-rules - assess-existing-rules -->|approve| write-rule - assess-existing-rules -->|keep/cancel| stop + capture-rule -->|approve/publish/delete| write-rule + capture-rule -->|revise| capture-rule + capture-rule -->|keep/cancel| stop write-rule -->|written| validate write-rule -->|refused| stop validate --> result @@ -25,7 +23,12 @@ Read each numbered action file in `actions/` before executing it. | Action | Does | | --- | --- | -| capture-rule | confirm intent and destinations | -| assess-existing-rules | compare policies and resolve findings | +| capture-rule | prepare, compare and resolve | | write-rule | publish the approved result | | validate | check affected files | + +## Transversal rules + +- Create/update: present the full assessed candidate, including new; await subsequent user approval before any rule/request/publication write. Repeat after candidate/resolution/evidence changes. +- Existing changes require explicit identified-source/publication permissions. +- Keep/cancel leaves project bytes unchanged. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md index 8c600e8f1..a37a1ab81 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md @@ -6,12 +6,15 @@ Topic, `auto`, or publish/delete selection. Empty means manual. ## Process -1. **Gate.** Read [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). - - Publish/delete: confirm sources and hosts, then action 03. -2. **Capture.** Confirm topic, category/slug, description and scope through [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md). +1. **Prepare.** Confirm intent and targets through [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). + - Publish/delete: confirm sources and hosts, then action 02. - Auto: scan and propose rules first. -3. **Target.** Confirm supported hosts or plugin directory. + - Create/update: draft complete bodies, metadata and scope in context using [rule-template.md](../assets/rule-template.md) and [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md). +2. **Compare.** Read sources from `tool-paths.md`; compare obligations, prohibitions, scope, conditions, exceptions and priority, including prior sources for updates. +3. **Resolve.** Classify new, covered, overlap, conflict or needs review; show full candidates with paths, decisive text and scope reasoning, then request a decision. ## Rules - Report unsupported hosts and alternatives. +- Exclude only proven disjoint scopes, independently of current files. +- Never proceed with unresolved conflicts/uncertainty. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md deleted file mode 100644 index 97b58a74d..000000000 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-assess-existing-rules.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,22 +0,0 @@ -# 02 - Assess existing rules - -## Input - -Confirmed intent and targets. - -## Process - -1. **Draft.** Prepare complete bodies, metadata, scope and targets in context from [rule-template.md](../assets/rule-template.md) and [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md). -2. **Compare.** Read sources through [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md); compare obligations, prohibitions, scope, conditions, exceptions and priority, including prior sources for updates. -3. **Report.** Classify new, covered, overlap, conflict or needs review; cite paths, decisive text and scope reasoning. -4. **Resolve.** Show full candidates; await explicit approval or keep/revise/merge/replace/cancel. - -## Rules - -- No rule/request/publication writes before explicit resolution, including new. -- Topic approval is insufficient. -- Exclude only proven disjoint scopes, independently of current files. -- Never proceed with unresolved conflicts/uncertainty. -- Existing changes require explicit identified-source/publication permissions. -- After candidate, resolution or source-evidence changes, reassess and await fresh user approval before writing. -- Keep/cancel leaves project bytes unchanged. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-write-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md similarity index 74% rename from plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-write-rule.md rename to plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md index 3f4f8a95a..8dfdb2813 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-write-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md @@ -1,4 +1,4 @@ -# 03 - Write rule +# 02 - Write rule ## Input @@ -12,4 +12,3 @@ Approved candidates/resolution, or confirmed publish/delete. ## Rules - Preserve exact approved bodies, metadata, scope and targets; never regenerate. -- Execute only approved source changes, including merge/replacement deletions. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/04-validate.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md similarity index 96% rename from plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/04-validate.md rename to plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md index 6623fe495..3547992c4 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/04-validate.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md @@ -1,4 +1,4 @@ -# 04 - Validate +# 03 - Validate ## Input From a0bc73e6fc439eee5b904b49f4d0aaf393240e49 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE <baptiste.lafourcade@gmail.com> Date: Tue, 13 Oct 2026 09:55:07 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 10/24] fix(aidd-context): preserve rule capture contracts Keep category and workflow semantics lost during compression. Make assessed approval, explicit artifact language and host applicability unambiguous. Refs #791 --- .../skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md | 4 +- .../actions/01-capture-rule.md | 13 +++--- .../05-rule-generate/assets/rule-template.md | 2 +- .../references/rule-authoring.md | 44 +++++++++++-------- .../05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md | 8 ++-- 5 files changed, 40 insertions(+), 31 deletions(-) diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md index 69381bb5d..786dd5b36 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md @@ -8,7 +8,7 @@ argument-hint: topic | auto ```mermaid flowchart LR - request --> capture-rule + manual & auto & publish & delete --> capture-rule capture-rule -->|approve/publish/delete| write-rule capture-rule -->|revise| capture-rule capture-rule -->|keep/cancel| stop @@ -29,6 +29,6 @@ Read each numbered action file in `actions/` before executing it. ## Transversal rules -- Create/update: present the full assessed candidate, including new; await subsequent user approval before any rule/request/publication write. Repeat after candidate/resolution/evidence changes. +- Create/update: capture confirmation is not approval. Present the full assessed candidate, including new; await subsequent user approval before any rule/request/publication write. Repeat after candidate/resolution/evidence changes. - Existing changes require explicit identified-source/publication permissions. - Keep/cancel leaves project bytes unchanged. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md index a37a1ab81..da624aafd 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md @@ -2,16 +2,17 @@ ## Input -Topic, `auto`, or publish/delete selection. Empty means manual. +A free-form rule request. ## Process -1. **Prepare.** Confirm intent and targets through [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). +1. **Prepare.** Read [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md) and [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md). - Publish/delete: confirm sources and hosts, then action 02. - - Auto: scan and propose rules first. - - Create/update: draft complete bodies, metadata and scope in context using [rule-template.md](../assets/rule-template.md) and [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md). -2. **Compare.** Read sources from `tool-paths.md`; compare obligations, prohibitions, scope, conditions, exceptions and priority, including prior sources for updates. -3. **Resolve.** Classify new, covered, overlap, conflict or needs review; show full candidates with paths, decisive text and scope reasoning, then request a decision. + - Manual (default): ask for a missing topic before drafting. + - `auto`: scan/propose, then await user selection before drafting. + - Create/update: confirm topic, category/slug, description, scope and mode/hosts; draft complete bodies and metadata in context using [rule-template.md](../assets/rule-template.md). +2. **Compare.** Read sources from `tool-paths.md`; verify host/interface applicability, then compare obligations, prohibitions, scope, conditions, exceptions and priority, including prior sources for updates. +3. **Resolve.** Classify through `rule-authoring.md`; show all findings and full candidates with paths, decisive text and scope reasoning; propose relevant create/keep/update/merge/scope/priority/cancel resolutions, then request a decision. ## Rules diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/assets/rule-template.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/assets/rule-template.md index 96e338271..cee8bc90c 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/assets/rule-template.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/assets/rule-template.md @@ -1,4 +1,4 @@ -Replace placeholders; remove this instruction and unused lines. +<!-- Replace placeholders; delete this comment and unused lines. --> # <Title> diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md index f92cbd8b5..66f1b00fc 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md @@ -3,28 +3,36 @@ ## Rules - **R1.** One topic per file. -- **R2.** Concise bullets preserving literals, conditions and exceptions. +- **R2.** Concise bullets only; preserve literals, conditions and exceptions. - **R3.** Explicit file scope or all files. -- **R4.** English only. +- **R4.** Rule text in English unless explicitly requested otherwise. - **R5.** Never repeat, weaken or contradict active bullets within a rule. ## Naming `#-slug[@version][-specificity]`: single-digit category prefix, no zero-padding. -| Index | Category | -| --- | --- | -| 00 | architecture | -| 01 | standards | -| 02 | programming-languages | -| 03 | frameworks-and-libraries | -| 04 | tooling | -| 05 | testing | -| 06 | design-patterns | -| 07 | quality | -| 08 | domain | -| 09 | other | - -Prefer framework `03`, syntax `02`, style `01`, architecture `00`, then `04`–`08`, else `09`. - -- Group multiple themes under `## group`; examples must be tiny, clarifying good code. +| Index | Category | Covers | +| --- | --- | --- | +| 00 | architecture | system design | +| 01 | standards | style/naming | +| 02 | programming-languages | language rules | +| 03 | frameworks-and-libraries | framework/library patterns | +| 04 | tooling | tools/configuration | +| 05 | testing | test patterns | +| 06 | design-patterns | code design patterns | +| 07 | quality | performance/security | +| 08 | domain | business logic | +| 09 | other | miscellaneous | + +Prefer framework `03`, syntax `02`, style `01`, architecture `00`, then `04`–`08` in order, else `09`. + +- Group multiple themes under `## group`; use at most one tiny clarifying good-code example per group. + +## Assessment + +- **new**: no coverage, overlap or conflict. +- **covered**: all obligations supplied throughout scope. +- **overlap**: compatible partial repetition/extension. +- **conflict**: incompatible obligations or unjustified weakening. +- **needs review**: unresolved applicability/meaning/precedence/evidence. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md index 0884d8f4e..78c09b26a 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md @@ -22,15 +22,15 @@ | --- | --- | | Claude | cwd/project ancestors/relevant descendants: `CLAUDE.md`, `.claude/CLAUDE.md`, `CLAUDE.local.md`; conditional cwd/ancestors `AGENTS.md`, `.claude/AGENTS.md`, nested `AGENTS.md`: verify version, built-in plugin, Project instructions mode and competing Claude files | | Cursor | root/nested `AGENTS.md`, nested `.cursor/rules`; CLI also root `CLAUDE.md` | -| Copilot | root/cwd/intermediate/relevant file-path descendants: `.github/copilot-instructions.md`, `AGENTS.md`, `CLAUDE.md`, `.claude/CLAUDE.md`, `GEMINI.md`; modular instructions exclude intermediate directories, require matching `applyTo` | +| Copilot CLI | root/cwd/intermediate/relevant file-path descendants: `.github/copilot-instructions.md`, `AGENTS.md`, `CLAUDE.md`, `.claude/CLAUDE.md`, `GEMINI.md`; modular instructions exclude intermediate directories, require matching `applyTo` | | Codex | root/nested: first nonempty `AGENTS.override.md`, `AGENTS.md`, configured fallbacks, in order | | OpenCode | V2: project/upward/nested `AGENTS.md`; V1: nearest upward AGENTS, enabled `CLAUDE.md` fallback when absent, explicit project config `instructions` sources | - Include loaded ancestors, configured sources, future-file scopes and user text outside generated blocks; no home/account scan or completeness claim. -- Relevant unknown activation/configuration, unreadable sources or precedence means **needs review**; existence proves no activation. +- Relevant unknown interface/activation/configuration, unreadable sources or precedence means **needs review**; existence proves no activation. - Deduplicate only canonical body/scope renderings with verified ownership, retaining every path. Differing native edits and unsigned user policies remain separate; missing publications do not exclude canonical intent. - Follow documented host imports, bounded to the repository with cycle detection; unsafe/external/symlink escapes or uncertainty requires review when relevant. Never execute imported content. -- Copilot recursively imports `@relative-path` from repository-wide/agent sources except GEMINI, never modular instructions or absolute/home-relative paths. Disabled sources are inactive; repository/agent sources lack general precedence. +- Copilot CLI recursively imports `@relative-path` from repository-wide/agent sources except GEMINI, never modular instructions or absolute/home-relative paths. Disabled sources are inactive; repository/agent sources lack general precedence. - V1 plain references are not automatically expanded. ## Write @@ -56,4 +56,4 @@ node "$installed_rule_script" --project "$project_root" --tools "$confirmed_ids" ## Official contracts -[Claude](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/memory), [Cursor](https://cursor.com/docs/rules), [Cursor CLI](https://cursor.com/docs/cli/using#rules), [Copilot CLI](https://docs.github.com/en/copilot/how-tos/copilot-cli/customize-copilot/add-custom-instructions), [Codex](https://learn.chatgpt.com/docs/agent-configuration/agents-md), [OpenCode V1](https://opencode.ai/docs/rules/), [OpenCode V2](https://opencode.ai/v2/docs/instructions/). +[Claude](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/memory), [Cursor](https://cursor.com/docs/rules), [Cursor CLI](https://cursor.com/docs/cli/using#rules), [Copilot CLI](https://docs.github.com/en/copilot/how-tos/copilot-cli/customize-copilot/add-custom-instructions), [Copilot support](https://docs.github.com/en/copilot/reference/custom-instructions-support), [Codex](https://learn.chatgpt.com/docs/agent-configuration/agents-md), [OpenCode V1](https://opencode.ai/docs/rules/), [OpenCode V2](https://opencode.ai/v2/docs/instructions/). From f692182036bf158142e5e021c471db1f06ca8de3 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE <baptiste.lafourcade@gmail.com> Date: Tue, 13 Oct 2026 11:22:28 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 11/24] refactor(aidd-context): clarify rule generation handoffs Keep routing in the skill and detailed contracts in existing references. Give each action an explicit input and output without repeating the frame or assessment fields in its process. Refs #791 --- .../skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md | 19 ++++++++++++------- .../actions/01-capture-rule.md | 16 +++++++--------- .../05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md | 10 +++++++--- .../05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md | 10 ++++++---- .../references/rule-authoring.md | 12 +++++++++++- .../05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md | 15 ++++++++++++--- 6 files changed, 55 insertions(+), 27 deletions(-) diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md index 786dd5b36..79240a685 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md @@ -7,11 +7,15 @@ argument-hint: topic | auto # Rule Generate ```mermaid -flowchart LR - manual & auto & publish & delete --> capture-rule - capture-rule -->|approve/publish/delete| write-rule - capture-rule -->|revise| capture-rule - capture-rule -->|keep/cancel| stop +flowchart TD + manual[Manual: topic] --> capture-rule + auto[Auto: propose then select] --> capture-rule + publish & delete --> capture-rule + capture-rule -->|create/update| decision[Assessed candidate] + decision -->|revise/clarify| capture-rule + decision -->|keep/cancel| stop + decision -->|approved| write-rule + capture-rule -->|publish/delete confirmed| write-rule write-rule -->|written| validate write-rule -->|refused| stop validate --> result @@ -19,16 +23,17 @@ flowchart LR ## Actions -Read each numbered action file in `actions/` before executing it. +Read only the next action in `actions/` and its cited reference sections. | Action | Does | | --- | --- | -| capture-rule | prepare, compare and resolve | +| capture-rule | frame, compare and decide | | write-rule | publish the approved result | | validate | check affected files | ## Transversal rules +- Missing/unreadable installed reference: stop. - Create/update: capture confirmation is not approval. Present the full assessed candidate, including new; await subsequent user approval before any rule/request/publication write. Repeat after candidate/resolution/evidence changes. - Existing changes require explicit identified-source/publication permissions. - Keep/cancel leaves project bytes unchanged. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md index da624aafd..829ece13a 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md @@ -4,18 +4,16 @@ A free-form rule request. +## Output + +Approved candidates/resolution or confirmed sources, with operation and destinations. + ## Process -1. **Prepare.** Read [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md) and [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md). - - Publish/delete: confirm sources and hosts, then action 02. - - Manual (default): ask for a missing topic before drafting. - - `auto`: scan/propose, then await user selection before drafting. - - Create/update: confirm topic, category/slug, description, scope and mode/hosts; draft complete bodies and metadata in context using [rule-template.md](../assets/rule-template.md). -2. **Compare.** Read sources from `tool-paths.md`; verify host/interface applicability, then compare obligations, prohibitions, scope, conditions, exceptions and priority, including prior sources for updates. -3. **Resolve.** Classify through `rule-authoring.md`; show all findings and full candidates with paths, decisive text and scope reasoning; propose relevant create/keep/update/merge/scope/priority/cancel resolutions, then request a decision. +1. **Frame.** Apply [Framing](../references/rule-authoring.md#framing). +2. **Compare.** Assess candidates through [Discovery](../references/tool-paths.md#discovery) and [Assessment](../references/rule-authoring.md#assessment). +3. **Decide.** Present the assessment and request the user's decision. ## Rules -- Report unsupported hosts and alternatives. -- Exclude only proven disjoint scopes, independently of current files. - Never proceed with unresolved conflicts/uncertainty. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md index 8dfdb2813..201c030cc 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md @@ -2,12 +2,16 @@ ## Input -Approved candidates/resolution, or confirmed publish/delete. +Approved capture. + +## Output + +Changed files and per-rule results, or refusal. ## Process -1. **Write.** Apply [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). -2. **Report.** Report refusals verbatim. +1. **Write.** Apply [Write](../references/tool-paths.md#write). +2. **Report.** Report refusals verbatim and stop. ## Rules diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md index 3547992c4..f497564ab 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md @@ -2,13 +2,15 @@ ## Input -Affected files and resolution. +Approved capture and write results. + +## Output + +Pass/fail per affected rule, with failures explained. ## Process -1. **Check.** Verify [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md), approved body/scope/targets and [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). - - Check existence/deletion, shared uniqueness/cleanup, surviving user/memory bytes and byte-idempotent republishing. -2. **Report.** Give pass/fail per affected rule. +1. **Check.** Apply [Validation](../references/tool-paths.md#validation). ## Rules diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md index 66f1b00fc..8e4f6c5df 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md @@ -1,8 +1,14 @@ # Rule authoring +## Framing + +- Manual is default; ask for a missing topic. `auto`: scan/propose, then await selection before drafting. +- Confirm operation and destinations: [host IDs](tool-paths.md#publications) or plugin. Publish/delete: confirm existing sources through [Write](tool-paths.md#write); skip drafting/assessment. +- Create/update: confirm topic, category/slug, description and scope; draft complete bodies and metadata in context using [Rules](#rules), [Naming](#naming) and [rule-template.md](../assets/rule-template.md). + ## Rules -- **R1.** One topic per file. +- **R1.** One topic per file; split multiple topics into independent rules. - **R2.** Concise bullets only; preserve literals, conditions and exceptions. - **R3.** Explicit file scope or all files. - **R4.** Rule text in English unless explicitly requested otherwise. @@ -31,6 +37,10 @@ Prefer framework `03`, syntax `02`, style `01`, architecture `00`, then `04`–` ## Assessment +- Compare obligations, prohibitions, scope, conditions, exceptions and priority, including prior sources for updates. +- Exclude only proven disjoint scopes, independently of current files. +- Classify and show all findings and full candidates with paths, decisive text and scope reasoning; propose relevant create/keep/update/merge/scope/priority/cancel resolutions. + - **new**: no coverage, overlap or conflict. - **covered**: all obligations supplied throughout scope. - **overlap**: compatible partial repetition/extension. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md index 78c09b26a..c75404f1a 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md @@ -2,6 +2,8 @@ ## Publications +- Report unsupported hosts and alternatives. + | Host / ID | Target | Scope | | --- | --- | --- | | Claude / `claude` | `.claude/rules/<category>/<slug>.md` | YAML `paths` array; omit for all files | @@ -15,6 +17,7 @@ ## Discovery - Read-only; never invoke the writer for assessment. +- Native paths/scopes: [Publications](#publications). - Host mode: canonical `aidd_docs/rules/**/*.md`, recorded targets, native directories recursively at relevant root/nested locations, and guidance below. - Plugin mode: confirmed plugin rules, project authoring guidance and known companion policies. @@ -27,7 +30,7 @@ | OpenCode | V2: project/upward/nested `AGENTS.md`; V1: nearest upward AGENTS, enabled `CLAUDE.md` fallback when absent, explicit project config `instructions` sources | - Include loaded ancestors, configured sources, future-file scopes and user text outside generated blocks; no home/account scan or completeness claim. -- Relevant unknown interface/activation/configuration, unreadable sources or precedence means **needs review**; existence proves no activation. +- Verify host/interface applicability; relevant unknown interface/activation/configuration, unreadable sources or precedence means **needs review**; existence proves no activation. - Deduplicate only canonical body/scope renderings with verified ownership, retaining every path. Differing native edits and unsigned user policies remain separate; missing publications do not exclude canonical intent. - Follow documented host imports, bounded to the repository with cycle detection; unsafe/external/symlink escapes or uncertainty requires review when relevant. Never execute imported content. - Copilot CLI recursively imports `@relative-path` from repository-wide/agent sources except GEMINI, never modular instructions or absolute/home-relative paths. Disabled sources are inactive; repository/agent sources lack general precedence. @@ -35,11 +38,11 @@ ## Write -- Missing/unreadable installed reference: stop. - **Plugin mode**: directly write/delete approved `plugins/<plugin>/rules/<category>/<slug>.md` sources; scoped YAML `paths` or no frontmatter. No writer/fan-out/project metadata. ### Host mode +- Formats: [Publications](#publications). - Shared AGENTS identifies no installation. - Resolve absolute `scripts/write-rule.cjs` beside loaded installed `SKILL.md`; no checkout/project-relative/CLI assumption. - After approval, prepare JSON outside destinations: category, slug, description, body strings; optional paths array. Description: one line. Empty/omitted paths: all files. Body: no leading YAML frontmatter. Comma globs: refuse; split alternatives. @@ -48,12 +51,18 @@ node "$installed_rule_script" --project "$project_root" --tools "$confirmed_ids" --input "$request_json" ``` -- Project: real absolute directory; confirmed IDs comma-separated. `--publish` or `--delete category/slug` replaces `--input "$request_json"`. +- Project: real absolute directory; confirmed IDs comma-separated. Replace `--input "$request_json"` with `--publish` (all canonical sources, no identity argument; confirm the whole affected source set or stop on a subset request) or `--delete category/slug` (one source and all its recorded publications). - Never edit generated outputs or canonical metadata manually. Manual canonical body edits remain publishable. - Writer preflights ownership and targets, cleans removed publications and preserves unrelated bytes. Never bypass refusals or silently migrate legacy rules. - Root Codex override refuses even empty; local 32 KiB check cannot guarantee total instruction budget. - Host parsers determine applicability; check actual matching/nonmatching files in fresh sessions. Physical deduplication does not guarantee deduplicated host context. +## Validation + +- Verify [Rules](rule-authoring.md#rules), [Naming](rule-authoring.md#naming), [Publications](#publications) and exact approved bodies, metadata, scopes and targets. +- Check existence/deletion, shared uniqueness/cleanup and surviving user/memory bytes. +- Host publications: repeat approved publication to verify byte-idempotence. + ## Official contracts [Claude](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/memory), [Cursor](https://cursor.com/docs/rules), [Cursor CLI](https://cursor.com/docs/cli/using#rules), [Copilot CLI](https://docs.github.com/en/copilot/how-tos/copilot-cli/customize-copilot/add-custom-instructions), [Copilot support](https://docs.github.com/en/copilot/reference/custom-instructions-support), [Codex](https://learn.chatgpt.com/docs/agent-configuration/agents-md), [OpenCode V1](https://opencode.ai/docs/rules/), [OpenCode V2](https://opencode.ai/v2/docs/instructions/). From 9f7039966a66522bf11b9f84f3177692fca8bf58 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE <baptiste.lafourcade@gmail.com> Date: Tue, 13 Oct 2026 11:33:42 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 12/24] fix(aidd-context): restore host selection discovery Preserve installed-tool discovery when destinations are unspecified. Shared AGENTS guidance alone cannot identify an installed host. Refs #791 --- .../skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md | 2 +- .../skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md | 2 +- 2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md index 8e4f6c5df..ce85b8465 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md @@ -3,7 +3,7 @@ ## Framing - Manual is default; ask for a missing topic. `auto`: scan/propose, then await selection before drafting. -- Confirm operation and destinations: [host IDs](tool-paths.md#publications) or plugin. Publish/delete: confirm existing sources through [Write](tool-paths.md#write); skip drafting/assessment. +- Confirm operation and destinations: [host IDs](tool-paths.md#publications) or plugin. Unspecified hosts: detect/propose supported installed tools before confirmation. Publish/delete: confirm existing sources through [Write](tool-paths.md#write); skip drafting/assessment. - Create/update: confirm topic, category/slug, description and scope; draft complete bodies and metadata in context using [Rules](#rules), [Naming](#naming) and [rule-template.md](../assets/rule-template.md). ## Rules diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md index c75404f1a..f421a2370 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md @@ -3,6 +3,7 @@ ## Publications - Report unsupported hosts and alternatives. +- Shared AGENTS identifies no installation. | Host / ID | Target | Scope | | --- | --- | --- | @@ -43,7 +44,6 @@ ### Host mode - Formats: [Publications](#publications). -- Shared AGENTS identifies no installation. - Resolve absolute `scripts/write-rule.cjs` beside loaded installed `SKILL.md`; no checkout/project-relative/CLI assumption. - After approval, prepare JSON outside destinations: category, slug, description, body strings; optional paths array. Description: one line. Empty/omitted paths: all files. Body: no leading YAML frontmatter. Comma globs: refuse; split alternatives. From c16bbebdaaa165c6cbc82dcaa843e8f3804b34c8 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE <baptiste.lafourcade@gmail.com> Date: Tue, 13 Oct 2026 20:52:19 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 13/24] fix(aidd-context): clarify capture decision order Await missing destination confirmation before assessing candidates. Give unresolved applicability priority over conflict resolution so unknown Copilot interfaces cannot justify changing imported policies. Scope that uncertainty to existing-policy comparisons rather than requiring activation proof for future publications. Refs #791 --- .../skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md | 4 ++-- .../skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md | 2 +- 2 files changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md index ce85b8465..2929a53ef 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md @@ -3,7 +3,7 @@ ## Framing - Manual is default; ask for a missing topic. `auto`: scan/propose, then await selection before drafting. -- Confirm operation and destinations: [host IDs](tool-paths.md#publications) or plugin. Unspecified hosts: detect/propose supported installed tools before confirmation. Publish/delete: confirm existing sources through [Write](tool-paths.md#write); skip drafting/assessment. +- Confirm operation and destinations: [host IDs](tool-paths.md#publications) or plugin. Unspecified hosts: detect/propose supported installed tools, then await confirmation before drafting/assessment. Publish/delete: confirm existing sources through [Write](tool-paths.md#write); skip drafting/assessment. - Create/update: confirm topic, category/slug, description and scope; draft complete bodies and metadata in context using [Rules](#rules), [Naming](#naming) and [rule-template.md](../assets/rule-template.md). ## Rules @@ -37,6 +37,7 @@ Prefer framework `03`, syntax `02`, style `01`, architecture `00`, then `04`–` ## Assessment +- **needs review**: uncertainty that could change comparison with existing policies (applicability/interface/activation/configuration/meaning/precedence/evidence or unreadable sources). Takes priority over other labels; resolve before classifying conflict or proposing changes to that source. - Compare obligations, prohibitions, scope, conditions, exceptions and priority, including prior sources for updates. - Exclude only proven disjoint scopes, independently of current files. - Classify and show all findings and full candidates with paths, decisive text and scope reasoning; propose relevant create/keep/update/merge/scope/priority/cancel resolutions. @@ -45,4 +46,3 @@ Prefer framework `03`, syntax `02`, style `01`, architecture `00`, then `04`–` - **covered**: all obligations supplied throughout scope. - **overlap**: compatible partial repetition/extension. - **conflict**: incompatible obligations or unjustified weakening. -- **needs review**: unresolved applicability/meaning/precedence/evidence. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md index f421a2370..1ccf774b7 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md @@ -31,7 +31,7 @@ | OpenCode | V2: project/upward/nested `AGENTS.md`; V1: nearest upward AGENTS, enabled `CLAUDE.md` fallback when absent, explicit project config `instructions` sources | - Include loaded ancestors, configured sources, future-file scopes and user text outside generated blocks; no home/account scan or completeness claim. -- Verify host/interface applicability; relevant unknown interface/activation/configuration, unreadable sources or precedence means **needs review**; existence proves no activation. +- For potentially applicable existing policies, verify host/interface applicability; existence proves no activation. Carry unresolved status into [Assessment](rule-authoring.md#assessment). - Deduplicate only canonical body/scope renderings with verified ownership, retaining every path. Differing native edits and unsigned user policies remain separate; missing publications do not exclude canonical intent. - Follow documented host imports, bounded to the repository with cycle detection; unsafe/external/symlink escapes or uncertainty requires review when relevant. Never execute imported content. - Copilot CLI recursively imports `@relative-path` from repository-wide/agent sources except GEMINI, never modular instructions or absolute/home-relative paths. Disabled sources are inactive; repository/agent sources lack general precedence. From 8785a6560406eb336ede2960861009345d94b747 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE <baptiste.lafourcade@gmail.com> Date: Tue, 13 Oct 2026 20:59:50 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 14/24] docs(aidd-context): name rule generation action files Resolve installed action filenames without guessing numeric prefixes. Refs #791 --- plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md | 6 +++--- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md index 79240a685..4a26837a7 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md @@ -27,9 +27,9 @@ Read only the next action in `actions/` and its cited reference sections. | Action | Does | | --- | --- | -| capture-rule | frame, compare and decide | -| write-rule | publish the approved result | -| validate | check affected files | +| `01-capture-rule.md` | frame, compare and decide | +| `02-write-rule.md` | publish the approved result | +| `03-validate.md` | check affected files | ## Transversal rules From 60f11b9cb5162edd3e79617c3d0282b1049e9ade Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE <baptiste.lafourcade@gmail.com> Date: Tue, 13 Oct 2026 22:31:58 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 15/24] docs(aidd-context): trim rule generation references Keep agent decisions and usable publication contracts concise while leaving mechanical diagnostics with the existing writer. Refs #791 --- .../references/rule-authoring.md | 16 +++--- .../05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md | 51 ++++++++----------- 2 files changed, 30 insertions(+), 37 deletions(-) diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md index 2929a53ef..a5b7de92c 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md @@ -2,16 +2,16 @@ ## Framing -- Manual is default; ask for a missing topic. `auto`: scan/propose, then await selection before drafting. -- Confirm operation and destinations: [host IDs](tool-paths.md#publications) or plugin. Unspecified hosts: detect/propose supported installed tools, then await confirmation before drafting/assessment. Publish/delete: confirm existing sources through [Write](tool-paths.md#write); skip drafting/assessment. -- Create/update: confirm topic, category/slug, description and scope; draft complete bodies and metadata in context using [Rules](#rules), [Naming](#naming) and [rule-template.md](../assets/rule-template.md). +- Default manual: ask for missing topic. `auto`: scan/propose; await selection before drafting. +- Confirm operation and [hosts](tool-paths.md#publications) or plugin. Unspecified hosts: detect/propose supported installations; await confirmation before drafting/assessment. Publish/delete: confirm existing sources through [Write](tool-paths.md#write); no drafting/assessment. +- Create/update: confirm topic, category/slug, description and scope; draft full bodies and metadata in context using [Rules](#rules), [Naming](#naming) and [rule-template.md](../assets/rule-template.md). ## Rules - **R1.** One topic per file; split multiple topics into independent rules. - **R2.** Concise bullets only; preserve literals, conditions and exceptions. - **R3.** Explicit file scope or all files. -- **R4.** Rule text in English unless explicitly requested otherwise. +- **R4.** English unless explicitly requested otherwise. - **R5.** Never repeat, weaken or contradict active bullets within a rule. ## Naming @@ -33,14 +33,14 @@ Prefer framework `03`, syntax `02`, style `01`, architecture `00`, then `04`–`08` in order, else `09`. -- Group multiple themes under `## group`; use at most one tiny clarifying good-code example per group. +- Multiple themes: `## group`; at most one tiny clarifying good-code example per group. ## Assessment -- **needs review**: uncertainty that could change comparison with existing policies (applicability/interface/activation/configuration/meaning/precedence/evidence or unreadable sources). Takes priority over other labels; resolve before classifying conflict or proposing changes to that source. +- **needs review**: uncertainty that could affect comparison with existing policies (applicability/interface/activation/configuration/meaning/precedence/evidence or unreadable sources). Overrides other labels; resolve before classifying conflict or proposing changes to that source. - Compare obligations, prohibitions, scope, conditions, exceptions and priority, including prior sources for updates. -- Exclude only proven disjoint scopes, independently of current files. -- Classify and show all findings and full candidates with paths, decisive text and scope reasoning; propose relevant create/keep/update/merge/scope/priority/cancel resolutions. +- Exclude only proven disjoint scopes, regardless of current files. +- Show all classified findings and full candidates: paths, decisive text, scope reasoning; propose relevant create/keep/update/merge/scope/priority/cancel resolutions. - **new**: no coverage, overlap or conflict. - **covered**: all obligations supplied throughout scope. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md index 1ccf774b7..58d6fcf64 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md @@ -2,66 +2,59 @@ ## Publications -- Report unsupported hosts and alternatives. -- Shared AGENTS identifies no installation. +- Report unsupported hosts and alternatives; AGENTS alone identifies no installed host. | Host / ID | Target | Scope | | --- | --- | --- | | Claude / `claude` | `.claude/rules/<category>/<slug>.md` | YAML `paths` array; omit for all files | -| Cursor / `cursor` | `.cursor/rules/<category>/<slug>.mdc` | `description`, comma-joined `globs`, `alwaysApply: false`; all-files omits globs, uses true | +| Cursor / `cursor` | `.cursor/rules/<category>/<slug>.mdc` | `description`, comma-joined `globs`, `alwaysApply: false`; all-files: no globs, true | | Copilot / `copilot` | `.github/instructions/<NN>-<name>.instructions.md` | comma-joined `applyTo`; all-files `**` | | Codex / `codex` | root `AGENTS.md` | shared signed `aidd_rules`, textual scope | -| OpenCode / `opencode` | same root `AGENTS.md` | same contribution, V1/V2 | - -- Copilot renames `01-standards/1-naming` → `01-naming.instructions.md`. +| OpenCode / `opencode` | root `AGENTS.md` | same contribution | ## Discovery -- Read-only; never invoke the writer for assessment. -- Native paths/scopes: [Publications](#publications). -- Host mode: canonical `aidd_docs/rules/**/*.md`, recorded targets, native directories recursively at relevant root/nested locations, and guidance below. -- Plugin mode: confirmed plugin rules, project authoring guidance and known companion policies. +- Read-only; no writer. [Native paths/scopes](#publications). +- Hosts: canonical `aidd_docs/rules/**/*.md`, recorded targets, recursive native directories at relevant root/nested locations and guidance below. +- Plugin: confirmed rules, project authoring guidance, known companion policies. | Host | Additional project guidance | | --- | --- | -| Claude | cwd/project ancestors/relevant descendants: `CLAUDE.md`, `.claude/CLAUDE.md`, `CLAUDE.local.md`; conditional cwd/ancestors `AGENTS.md`, `.claude/AGENTS.md`, nested `AGENTS.md`: verify version, built-in plugin, Project instructions mode and competing Claude files | +| Claude | cwd/project ancestors/relevant descendants: `CLAUDE.md`, `.claude/CLAUDE.md`, `CLAUDE.local.md`; conditional cwd/ancestor `AGENTS.md`, `.claude/AGENTS.md`, nested `AGENTS.md`: verify version, built-in plugin, Project instructions mode, competing Claude files | | Cursor | root/nested `AGENTS.md`, nested `.cursor/rules`; CLI also root `CLAUDE.md` | -| Copilot CLI | root/cwd/intermediate/relevant file-path descendants: `.github/copilot-instructions.md`, `AGENTS.md`, `CLAUDE.md`, `.claude/CLAUDE.md`, `GEMINI.md`; modular instructions exclude intermediate directories, require matching `applyTo` | +| Copilot CLI | root/cwd/intermediate/relevant file-path descendants: `.github/copilot-instructions.md`, `AGENTS.md`, `CLAUDE.md`, `.claude/CLAUDE.md`, `GEMINI.md`; modular: no intermediate directories, matching `applyTo` required | | Codex | root/nested: first nonempty `AGENTS.override.md`, `AGENTS.md`, configured fallbacks, in order | -| OpenCode | V2: project/upward/nested `AGENTS.md`; V1: nearest upward AGENTS, enabled `CLAUDE.md` fallback when absent, explicit project config `instructions` sources | +| OpenCode | V2: project/upward/nested `AGENTS.md`; V1: nearest upward AGENTS, enabled `CLAUDE.md` fallback if absent, explicit project config `instructions` sources | -- Include loaded ancestors, configured sources, future-file scopes and user text outside generated blocks; no home/account scan or completeness claim. -- For potentially applicable existing policies, verify host/interface applicability; existence proves no activation. Carry unresolved status into [Assessment](rule-authoring.md#assessment). -- Deduplicate only canonical body/scope renderings with verified ownership, retaining every path. Differing native edits and unsigned user policies remain separate; missing publications do not exclude canonical intent. -- Follow documented host imports, bounded to the repository with cycle detection; unsafe/external/symlink escapes or uncertainty requires review when relevant. Never execute imported content. -- Copilot CLI recursively imports `@relative-path` from repository-wide/agent sources except GEMINI, never modular instructions or absolute/home-relative paths. Disabled sources are inactive; repository/agent sources lack general precedence. +- Include loaded ancestors, configured sources, future-file scopes, user text outside generated blocks; no home/account scan or completeness claim. +- Potentially applicable existing policies: verify host/interface applicability; existence proves no activation. Unresolved: [Assessment](rule-authoring.md#assessment). +- Deduplicate canonical body/scope renderings only with verified ownership; retain every path. Keep differing native edits and unsigned policies separate; missing publications never exclude canonical intent. +- Follow documented imports within repository, detecting cycles. Relevant unsafe/external/symlink escapes or uncertainty need review. Never execute imports. +- Copilot CLI recursively imports `@relative-path` from repository-wide/agent sources except GEMINI; never modular or absolute/home-relative. Disabled sources are inactive; repository/agent sources lack general precedence. - V1 plain references are not automatically expanded. ## Write -- **Plugin mode**: directly write/delete approved `plugins/<plugin>/rules/<category>/<slug>.md` sources; scoped YAML `paths` or no frontmatter. No writer/fan-out/project metadata. +- **Plugin**: directly write/delete approved `plugins/<plugin>/rules/<category>/<slug>.md`; scoped YAML `paths` or no frontmatter. No writer/fan-out/project metadata. ### Host mode -- Formats: [Publications](#publications). - Resolve absolute `scripts/write-rule.cjs` beside loaded installed `SKILL.md`; no checkout/project-relative/CLI assumption. -- After approval, prepare JSON outside destinations: category, slug, description, body strings; optional paths array. Description: one line. Empty/omitted paths: all files. Body: no leading YAML frontmatter. Comma globs: refuse; split alternatives. +- After approval, JSON outside destinations: category, slug, description, body strings; optional paths array. One-line description; empty/omitted paths: all files; no leading body frontmatter. Refuse comma globs; split alternatives. ```sh node "$installed_rule_script" --project "$project_root" --tools "$confirmed_ids" --input "$request_json" ``` -- Project: real absolute directory; confirmed IDs comma-separated. Replace `--input "$request_json"` with `--publish` (all canonical sources, no identity argument; confirm the whole affected source set or stop on a subset request) or `--delete category/slug` (one source and all its recorded publications). -- Never edit generated outputs or canonical metadata manually. Manual canonical body edits remain publishable. -- Writer preflights ownership and targets, cleans removed publications and preserves unrelated bytes. Never bypass refusals or silently migrate legacy rules. -- Root Codex override refuses even empty; local 32 KiB check cannot guarantee total instruction budget. -- Host parsers determine applicability; check actual matching/nonmatching files in fresh sessions. Physical deduplication does not guarantee deduplicated host context. +- Project: real absolute directory; comma-separated confirmed IDs. Replace `--input "$request_json"` with `--publish` (all canonical sources, no identity argument; confirm whole affected set or stop subset requests) or `--delete category/slug` (one source, all recorded publications). +- Never manually edit generated outputs or canonical metadata, bypass refusals or silently migrate legacy rules. Canonical body edits remain publishable. +- Physical deduplication does not ensure unique host context; local 32 KiB passes do not ensure total instruction budget. ## Validation -- Verify [Rules](rule-authoring.md#rules), [Naming](rule-authoring.md#naming), [Publications](#publications) and exact approved bodies, metadata, scopes and targets. -- Check existence/deletion, shared uniqueness/cleanup and surviving user/memory bytes. -- Host publications: repeat approved publication to verify byte-idempotence. +- Verify [Rules](rule-authoring.md#rules), [Naming](rule-authoring.md#naming), [Publications](#publications), exact approved bodies, metadata, scopes and targets. +- Check existence/deletion, shared uniqueness/cleanup, surviving user/memory bytes. +- Hosts: repeat approved publication for byte-idempotence; check actual matching/nonmatching files in fresh sessions. ## Official contracts From 571fa9a280a824330bafd00e8e2c0a9c1a7cfc68 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE <baptiste.lafourcade@gmail.com> Date: Wed, 14 Oct 2026 06:42:35 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 16/24] docs(aidd-context): restore concrete rule generation actions Keep the workflow in actions and reusable contracts in references so the agent can follow the process without chasing procedural redirects. Refs #791 --- .../skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md | 8 +++---- .../actions/01-capture-rule.md | 14 ++++++----- .../05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md | 9 +++---- .../05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md | 9 ++++--- .../references/rule-authoring.md | 18 ++++---------- .../05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md | 24 +++++++------------ 6 files changed, 35 insertions(+), 47 deletions(-) diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md index 4a26837a7..63c08855a 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md @@ -8,9 +8,7 @@ argument-hint: topic | auto ```mermaid flowchart TD - manual[Manual: topic] --> capture-rule - auto[Auto: propose then select] --> capture-rule - publish & delete --> capture-rule + request[Rule request] --> capture-rule capture-rule -->|create/update| decision[Assessed candidate] decision -->|revise/clarify| capture-rule decision -->|keep/cancel| stop @@ -23,7 +21,7 @@ flowchart TD ## Actions -Read only the next action in `actions/` and its cited reference sections. +Read the next action in `actions/` and its references. | Action | Does | | --- | --- | @@ -34,6 +32,6 @@ Read only the next action in `actions/` and its cited reference sections. ## Transversal rules - Missing/unreadable installed reference: stop. -- Create/update: capture confirmation is not approval. Present the full assessed candidate, including new; await subsequent user approval before any rule/request/publication write. Repeat after candidate/resolution/evidence changes. +- Create/update: present full assessed candidates, including new; await approval after capture confirmation before any rule/request/publication write. Renew after candidate/resolution/evidence changes. - Existing changes require explicit identified-source/publication permissions. - Keep/cancel leaves project bytes unchanged. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md index 829ece13a..703cf188f 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md @@ -2,18 +2,20 @@ ## Input -A free-form rule request. +Topic, `auto`, or publish/delete; default manual. ## Output -Approved candidates/resolution or confirmed sources, with operation and destinations. +Approved candidates or confirmed sources, operation and destinations. ## Process -1. **Frame.** Apply [Framing](../references/rule-authoring.md#framing). -2. **Compare.** Assess candidates through [Discovery](../references/tool-paths.md#discovery) and [Assessment](../references/rule-authoring.md#assessment). -3. **Decide.** Present the assessment and request the user's decision. +1. **Confirm destination.** Confirm operation, hosts or plugin per [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). Missing hosts: detect/propose installations; await selection before drafting/assessment. +2. **Select.** Manual: ask for missing topic. Auto: scan/propose topics; await selection. Publish/delete: confirm identified sources and affected publications, including the whole publish set; continue to Write without drafting/assessment. +3. **Draft.** Create/update: confirm topic, category/slug, description, scope per [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md); draft complete candidates with [rule-template.md](../assets/rule-template.md). +4. **Assess.** Apply Discovery in tool-paths; compare obligations, prohibitions, scopes, conditions, exceptions and priority, including prior sources and future files; apply Assessment. Exclude only proven disjoint scopes. +5. **Decide.** Show full candidates and findings: sources, decisive text, scope reasons; offer create/keep/update/merge/scope/priority/cancel choices. Await resolution, then explicit approval. ## Rules -- Never proceed with unresolved conflicts/uncertainty. +- Unresolved conflicts/uncertainty prevent proceeding. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md index 201c030cc..7020366b7 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md @@ -6,13 +6,14 @@ Approved capture. ## Output -Changed files and per-rule results, or refusal. +Recorded files/results or refusal. ## Process -1. **Write.** Apply [Write](../references/tool-paths.md#write). -2. **Report.** Report refusals verbatim and stop. +1. **Prepare.** Host create/update: serialize approved fields into JSON outside destinations per [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). +2. **Publish.** Invoke the installed absolute writer with project, confirmed IDs and operation arguments. Plugin: directly write/delete only the approved source; no host fan-out. +3. **Report.** Record results; report refusals verbatim and stop. ## Rules -- Preserve exact approved bodies, metadata, scope and targets; never regenerate. +- Preserve exact approved bodies, metadata, scope and targets; never regenerate, manually edit canonical metadata/generated outputs, migrate legacy rules or bypass refusals. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md index f497564ab..f989f796e 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md @@ -6,12 +6,15 @@ Approved capture and write results. ## Output -Pass/fail per affected rule, with failures explained. +Explained pass/fail per affected rule. ## Process -1. **Check.** Apply [Validation](../references/tool-paths.md#validation). +1. **Operation.** Check expected existence/deletion against reported files. +2. **Contract.** Check approved bodies, metadata and scope against [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md); targets and host schemas against [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). +3. **Preservation.** For affected shared publications, check signed uniqueness and last-rule cleanup. Verify surviving rules, user guidance and memory bytes. +4. **Repeat.** Hosts: repeat approved publication; require byte-identical results. ## Rules -- Publication does not prove runtime consumption. +- Publication does not prove runtime consumption; only matching/nonmatching file evidence in fresh host sessions does. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md index a5b7de92c..689180ac8 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md @@ -1,16 +1,10 @@ # Rule authoring -## Framing - -- Default manual: ask for missing topic. `auto`: scan/propose; await selection before drafting. -- Confirm operation and [hosts](tool-paths.md#publications) or plugin. Unspecified hosts: detect/propose supported installations; await confirmation before drafting/assessment. Publish/delete: confirm existing sources through [Write](tool-paths.md#write); no drafting/assessment. -- Create/update: confirm topic, category/slug, description and scope; draft full bodies and metadata in context using [Rules](#rules), [Naming](#naming) and [rule-template.md](../assets/rule-template.md). - ## Rules -- **R1.** One topic per file; split multiple topics into independent rules. +- **R1.** One topic per file; split multiple topics. - **R2.** Concise bullets only; preserve literals, conditions and exceptions. -- **R3.** Explicit file scope or all files. +- **R3.** Explicit scope or all files. - **R4.** English unless explicitly requested otherwise. - **R5.** Never repeat, weaken or contradict active bullets within a rule. @@ -33,15 +27,11 @@ Prefer framework `03`, syntax `02`, style `01`, architecture `00`, then `04`–`08` in order, else `09`. -- Multiple themes: `## group`; at most one tiny clarifying good-code example per group. +- Themes: `## group`; one tiny clarifying good-code example per group maximum. ## Assessment -- **needs review**: uncertainty that could affect comparison with existing policies (applicability/interface/activation/configuration/meaning/precedence/evidence or unreadable sources). Overrides other labels; resolve before classifying conflict or proposing changes to that source. -- Compare obligations, prohibitions, scope, conditions, exceptions and priority, including prior sources for updates. -- Exclude only proven disjoint scopes, regardless of current files. -- Show all classified findings and full candidates: paths, decisive text, scope reasoning; propose relevant create/keep/update/merge/scope/priority/cancel resolutions. - +- **needs review**: uncertainty that could affect comparison with existing policies. Overrides other labels; resolve before classifying conflict or proposing changes to that source. - **new**: no coverage, overlap or conflict. - **covered**: all obligations supplied throughout scope. - **overlap**: compatible partial repetition/extension. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md index 58d6fcf64..46869c0d3 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md @@ -14,7 +14,7 @@ ## Discovery -- Read-only; no writer. [Native paths/scopes](#publications). +- Read-only policy discovery; no writer. - Hosts: canonical `aidd_docs/rules/**/*.md`, recorded targets, recursive native directories at relevant root/nested locations and guidance below. - Plugin: confirmed rules, project authoring guidance, known companion policies. @@ -33,29 +33,23 @@ - Copilot CLI recursively imports `@relative-path` from repository-wide/agent sources except GEMINI; never modular or absolute/home-relative. Disabled sources are inactive; repository/agent sources lack general precedence. - V1 plain references are not automatically expanded. -## Write +## Input and operations -- **Plugin**: directly write/delete approved `plugins/<plugin>/rules/<category>/<slug>.md`; scoped YAML `paths` or no frontmatter. No writer/fan-out/project metadata. +Writer: absolute `scripts/write-rule.cjs` beside loaded installed `SKILL.md`; no checkout/project-relative/CLI assumption. -### Host mode - -- Resolve absolute `scripts/write-rule.cjs` beside loaded installed `SKILL.md`; no checkout/project-relative/CLI assumption. -- After approval, JSON outside destinations: category, slug, description, body strings; optional paths array. One-line description; empty/omitted paths: all files; no leading body frontmatter. Refuse comma globs; split alternatives. +JSON fields: category, slug, description, body strings; optional paths array. Description: one line; empty/omitted paths: all files; no body frontmatter. Reject comma globs; split alternatives. ```sh node "$installed_rule_script" --project "$project_root" --tools "$confirmed_ids" --input "$request_json" ``` -- Project: real absolute directory; comma-separated confirmed IDs. Replace `--input "$request_json"` with `--publish` (all canonical sources, no identity argument; confirm whole affected set or stop subset requests) or `--delete category/slug` (one source, all recorded publications). -- Never manually edit generated outputs or canonical metadata, bypass refusals or silently migrate legacy rules. Canonical body edits remain publishable. +- Project: real absolute directory; tools: comma-separated confirmed IDs. +- Replace `--input "$request_json"` with `--publish`: all canonical sources, no identity argument; subset requests unsupported. +- Or `--delete category/slug`: one source, all recorded publications; reports `files`. +- Plugin: `plugins/<plugin>/rules/<category>/<slug>.md`; scoped YAML `paths` or no frontmatter. No writer, project metadata or host fan-out. +- Canonical body edits beneath intact metadata remain publishable. - Physical deduplication does not ensure unique host context; local 32 KiB passes do not ensure total instruction budget. -## Validation - -- Verify [Rules](rule-authoring.md#rules), [Naming](rule-authoring.md#naming), [Publications](#publications), exact approved bodies, metadata, scopes and targets. -- Check existence/deletion, shared uniqueness/cleanup, surviving user/memory bytes. -- Hosts: repeat approved publication for byte-idempotence; check actual matching/nonmatching files in fresh sessions. - ## Official contracts [Claude](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/memory), [Cursor](https://cursor.com/docs/rules), [Cursor CLI](https://cursor.com/docs/cli/using#rules), [Copilot CLI](https://docs.github.com/en/copilot/how-tos/copilot-cli/customize-copilot/add-custom-instructions), [Copilot support](https://docs.github.com/en/copilot/reference/custom-instructions-support), [Codex](https://learn.chatgpt.com/docs/agent-configuration/agents-md), [OpenCode V1](https://opencode.ai/docs/rules/), [OpenCode V2](https://opencode.ai/v2/docs/instructions/). From 9f37842cb6bed0492286aebea08c751b6de66132 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE <baptiste.lafourcade@gmail.com> Date: Wed, 14 Oct 2026 07:03:06 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 17/24] docs(aidd-context): clarify review before resolution Put clarification and reassessment before policy-change choices when comparison evidence is missing; keep label definitions in the reference. Refs #791 --- .../skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md | 2 +- .../skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md | 2 +- 2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md index 703cf188f..392866781 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md @@ -14,7 +14,7 @@ Approved candidates or confirmed sources, operation and destinations. 2. **Select.** Manual: ask for missing topic. Auto: scan/propose topics; await selection. Publish/delete: confirm identified sources and affected publications, including the whole publish set; continue to Write without drafting/assessment. 3. **Draft.** Create/update: confirm topic, category/slug, description, scope per [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md); draft complete candidates with [rule-template.md](../assets/rule-template.md). 4. **Assess.** Apply Discovery in tool-paths; compare obligations, prohibitions, scopes, conditions, exceptions and priority, including prior sources and future files; apply Assessment. Exclude only proven disjoint scopes. -5. **Decide.** Show full candidates and findings: sources, decisive text, scope reasons; offer create/keep/update/merge/scope/priority/cancel choices. Await resolution, then explicit approval. +5. **Decide.** Show full candidates and findings: sources, decisive text, scope reasons. If needs review, ask for missing evidence and return to Assess before proposing source changes. Otherwise offer create/keep/update/merge/scope/priority/cancel choices; await resolution, then explicit approval. ## Rules diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md index 689180ac8..484455bb4 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md @@ -31,7 +31,7 @@ Prefer framework `03`, syntax `02`, style `01`, architecture `00`, then `04`–` ## Assessment -- **needs review**: uncertainty that could affect comparison with existing policies. Overrides other labels; resolve before classifying conflict or proposing changes to that source. +- **needs review**: uncertainty that could affect comparison with existing policies. Overrides other labels. - **new**: no coverage, overlap or conflict. - **covered**: all obligations supplied throughout scope. - **overlap**: compatible partial repetition/extension. From f23d2ad7e206e9177a91b854103d1e7fb20f2e23 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE <baptiste.lafourcade@gmail.com> Date: Wed, 14 Oct 2026 07:39:39 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 18/24] docs(aidd-context): shorten rule actions and split responsibilities Keep the action flow readable while loading assessment, discovery and publication contracts only when needed. Preserve approval and host-format safeguards. Refs #791 --- .../official-contracts.md | 2 +- plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md | 4 +- .../skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md | 1 + .../actions/01-capture-rule.md | 10 ++--- .../05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md | 10 ++--- .../05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md | 14 +++---- .../references/rule-assessment.md | 19 +++++++++ .../references/rule-authoring.md | 8 ---- .../{tool-paths.md => rule-discovery.md} | 40 ++----------------- .../references/rule-publication.md | 28 +++++++++++++ 10 files changed, 73 insertions(+), 63 deletions(-) create mode 100644 plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-assessment.md rename plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/{tool-paths.md => rule-discovery.md} (53%) create mode 100644 plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-publication.md diff --git a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_11_rule-contracts/official-contracts.md b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_11_rule-contracts/official-contracts.md index 49a44cd67..e9146506e 100644 --- a/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_11_rule-contracts/official-contracts.md +++ b/aidd_docs/tasks/2026_10/2026_10_11_rule-contracts/official-contracts.md @@ -22,4 +22,4 @@ Native instruction text guides model behavior; it does not guarantee compliance. [6] [Codex 0.162.1 implementation](https://github.com/openai/codex/blob/092d3acd6bec3e3a14bdc7e7a2810ab628ab759d/codex-rs/core/src/agents_md.rs#L63) and [0.160.1 implementation](https://github.com/openai/codex/blob/d27764b82f7118f674371e6d6e76271d9d606edb/codex-rs/core/src/agents_md.rs#L63): separate global assembly and project budget. [HTTP receipts and hashes](evidence/official/http-receipts.json). -[7] [Skill host contract](../../../../plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md) and [publication script](../../../../plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/scripts/write-rule.cjs): restricted serialization, body ownership and shared publication. +[7] [Skill host contract](../../../../plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-publication.md) and [publication script](../../../../plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/scripts/write-rule.cjs): restricted serialization, body ownership and shared publication. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md b/plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md index 06c1317db..96673d976 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md @@ -120,8 +120,10 @@ Auto-generated index of skills, agents, references and assets shipped by the `ai | `actions` | [02-write-rule.md](skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md) | - | | `actions` | [03-validate.md](skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md) | - | | `assets` | [rule-template.md](skills/05-rule-generate/assets/rule-template.md) | - | +| `references` | [rule-assessment.md](skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-assessment.md) | - | | `references` | [rule-authoring.md](skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md) | - | -| `references` | [tool-paths.md](skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md) | - | +| `references` | [rule-discovery.md](skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-discovery.md) | - | +| `references` | [rule-publication.md](skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-publication.md) | - | | `-` | [SKILL.md](skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md) | `Create, update, publish or delete a coding rule across host AI tools. Use when adding, changing or removing a rule, convention or coding standard. Not for skills, agents or hooks.` | #### `skills/06-agent-generate` diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md index 63c08855a..8c7cdff55 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md @@ -31,6 +31,7 @@ Read the next action in `actions/` and its references. ## Transversal rules +- Report unsupported hosts and alternatives; AGENTS alone identifies no installed host. - Missing/unreadable installed reference: stop. - Create/update: present full assessed candidates, including new; await approval after capture confirmation before any rule/request/publication write. Renew after candidate/resolution/evidence changes. - Existing changes require explicit identified-source/publication permissions. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md index 392866781..e862e1907 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md @@ -10,11 +10,11 @@ Approved candidates or confirmed sources, operation and destinations. ## Process -1. **Confirm destination.** Confirm operation, hosts or plugin per [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). Missing hosts: detect/propose installations; await selection before drafting/assessment. -2. **Select.** Manual: ask for missing topic. Auto: scan/propose topics; await selection. Publish/delete: confirm identified sources and affected publications, including the whole publish set; continue to Write without drafting/assessment. -3. **Draft.** Create/update: confirm topic, category/slug, description, scope per [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md); draft complete candidates with [rule-template.md](../assets/rule-template.md). -4. **Assess.** Apply Discovery in tool-paths; compare obligations, prohibitions, scopes, conditions, exceptions and priority, including prior sources and future files; apply Assessment. Exclude only proven disjoint scopes. -5. **Decide.** Show full candidates and findings: sources, decisive text, scope reasons. If needs review, ask for missing evidence and return to Assess before proposing source changes. Otherwise offer create/keep/update/merge/scope/priority/cancel choices; await resolution, then explicit approval. +1. Confirm operation and [destination](../references/rule-publication.md). Missing hosts: detect and propose installations; await selection before drafting/assessment. +2. Manual: request missing topic. Auto: scan/propose topics; await selection. Publish/delete: confirm sources and whole publications; skip drafting/assessment to Write. +3. Create/update: confirm topic and [fields](../references/rule-publication.md#operations); draft full [candidates](../assets/rule-template.md) per [authoring](../references/rule-authoring.md). +4. [Discover policies](../references/rule-discovery.md) read-only; [compare](../references/rule-assessment.md). +5. Show full candidates and all findings. Needs review: request evidence; reassess before proposing source changes. Otherwise offer relevant choices; await resolution, then explicit subsequent approval. ## Rules diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md index 7020366b7..a3fff96cc 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md @@ -6,14 +6,14 @@ Approved capture. ## Output -Recorded files/results or refusal. +Files or refusal. ## Process -1. **Prepare.** Host create/update: serialize approved fields into JSON outside destinations per [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). -2. **Publish.** Invoke the installed absolute writer with project, confirmed IDs and operation arguments. Plugin: directly write/delete only the approved source; no host fan-out. -3. **Report.** Record results; report refusals verbatim and stop. +1. Host create/update: serialize approved JSON outside destinations per [publication](../references/rule-publication.md). +2. Invoke installed absolute writer per publication. Plugin: directly write/delete approved source only; no fan-out. +3. Record results; stop on verbatim refusals. ## Rules -- Preserve exact approved bodies, metadata, scope and targets; never regenerate, manually edit canonical metadata/generated outputs, migrate legacy rules or bypass refusals. +- Preserve approved capture exactly. Never regenerate, edit canonical metadata or generated outputs manually, migrate legacy rules or bypass refusals. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md index f989f796e..0514acca0 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md @@ -2,19 +2,19 @@ ## Input -Approved capture and write results. +Approved capture; write results. ## Output -Explained pass/fail per affected rule. +Per-rule pass/fail reasons. ## Process -1. **Operation.** Check expected existence/deletion against reported files. -2. **Contract.** Check approved bodies, metadata and scope against [rule-authoring.md](../references/rule-authoring.md); targets and host schemas against [tool-paths.md](../references/tool-paths.md). -3. **Preservation.** For affected shared publications, check signed uniqueness and last-rule cleanup. Verify surviving rules, user guidance and memory bytes. -4. **Repeat.** Hosts: repeat approved publication; require byte-identical results. +1. Check reported existence/deletion. +2. Match approved fields and host schemas against [authoring](../references/rule-authoring.md) and [publication](../references/rule-publication.md). +3. Affected shared publications only: check signed uniqueness and last-rule cleanup. Verify survivors, user guidance and memory bytes. +4. Hosts: repeat approved publication; require identical bytes. ## Rules -- Publication does not prove runtime consumption; only matching/nonmatching file evidence in fresh host sessions does. +- Consumption requires matching/nonmatching file evidence in fresh host sessions. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-assessment.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-assessment.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..420a72861 --- /dev/null +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-assessment.md @@ -0,0 +1,19 @@ +# Rule assessment + +## Labels + +- **needs review**: uncertainty that could affect comparison with existing policies. Overrides other labels. +- **new**: no coverage, overlap or conflict. +- **covered**: all obligations supplied throughout scope. +- **overlap**: compatible partial repetition/extension. +- **conflict**: incompatible obligations or unjustified weakening. + +## Comparison + +- Compare obligations, prohibitions, scopes, conditions, exceptions and priority, including prior sources when updating and future files. +- Exclude only proven disjoint scopes. +- Findings include source paths, decisive quotes and scope reasons. + +## Choices + +Choices: create, keep, update, merge, scope, priority or cancel. Needs review: evidence, keep or cancel; no source-change choice. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md index 484455bb4..985f76728 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md @@ -28,11 +28,3 @@ Prefer framework `03`, syntax `02`, style `01`, architecture `00`, then `04`–`08` in order, else `09`. - Themes: `## group`; one tiny clarifying good-code example per group maximum. - -## Assessment - -- **needs review**: uncertainty that could affect comparison with existing policies. Overrides other labels. -- **new**: no coverage, overlap or conflict. -- **covered**: all obligations supplied throughout scope. -- **overlap**: compatible partial repetition/extension. -- **conflict**: incompatible obligations or unjustified weakening. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-discovery.md similarity index 53% rename from plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md rename to plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-discovery.md index 46869c0d3..a336e73db 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/tool-paths.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-discovery.md @@ -1,21 +1,6 @@ -# Tool paths +# Rule discovery -## Publications - -- Report unsupported hosts and alternatives; AGENTS alone identifies no installed host. - -| Host / ID | Target | Scope | -| --- | --- | --- | -| Claude / `claude` | `.claude/rules/<category>/<slug>.md` | YAML `paths` array; omit for all files | -| Cursor / `cursor` | `.cursor/rules/<category>/<slug>.mdc` | `description`, comma-joined `globs`, `alwaysApply: false`; all-files: no globs, true | -| Copilot / `copilot` | `.github/instructions/<NN>-<name>.instructions.md` | comma-joined `applyTo`; all-files `**` | -| Codex / `codex` | root `AGENTS.md` | shared signed `aidd_rules`, textual scope | -| OpenCode / `opencode` | root `AGENTS.md` | same contribution | - -## Discovery - -- Read-only policy discovery; no writer. -- Hosts: canonical `aidd_docs/rules/**/*.md`, recorded targets, recursive native directories at relevant root/nested locations and guidance below. +- Hosts: [native paths and scopes](rule-publication.md#publications), canonical `aidd_docs/rules/**/*.md`, recorded targets, recursive native directories at relevant root/nested locations and guidance below. - Plugin: confirmed rules, project authoring guidance, known companion policies. | Host | Additional project guidance | @@ -27,29 +12,12 @@ | OpenCode | V2: project/upward/nested `AGENTS.md`; V1: nearest upward AGENTS, enabled `CLAUDE.md` fallback if absent, explicit project config `instructions` sources | - Include loaded ancestors, configured sources, future-file scopes, user text outside generated blocks; no home/account scan or completeness claim. -- Potentially applicable existing policies: verify host/interface applicability; existence proves no activation. Unresolved: [Assessment](rule-authoring.md#assessment). +- Potentially applicable existing policies: verify host/interface applicability; existence proves no activation. Unresolved: [assessment](rule-assessment.md). - Deduplicate canonical body/scope renderings only with verified ownership; retain every path. Keep differing native edits and unsigned policies separate; missing publications never exclude canonical intent. - Follow documented imports within repository, detecting cycles. Relevant unsafe/external/symlink escapes or uncertainty need review. Never execute imports. - Copilot CLI recursively imports `@relative-path` from repository-wide/agent sources except GEMINI; never modular or absolute/home-relative. Disabled sources are inactive; repository/agent sources lack general precedence. - V1 plain references are not automatically expanded. -## Input and operations - -Writer: absolute `scripts/write-rule.cjs` beside loaded installed `SKILL.md`; no checkout/project-relative/CLI assumption. - -JSON fields: category, slug, description, body strings; optional paths array. Description: one line; empty/omitted paths: all files; no body frontmatter. Reject comma globs; split alternatives. - -```sh -node "$installed_rule_script" --project "$project_root" --tools "$confirmed_ids" --input "$request_json" -``` - -- Project: real absolute directory; tools: comma-separated confirmed IDs. -- Replace `--input "$request_json"` with `--publish`: all canonical sources, no identity argument; subset requests unsupported. -- Or `--delete category/slug`: one source, all recorded publications; reports `files`. -- Plugin: `plugins/<plugin>/rules/<category>/<slug>.md`; scoped YAML `paths` or no frontmatter. No writer, project metadata or host fan-out. -- Canonical body edits beneath intact metadata remain publishable. -- Physical deduplication does not ensure unique host context; local 32 KiB passes do not ensure total instruction budget. - -## Official contracts +## Contracts [Claude](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/memory), [Cursor](https://cursor.com/docs/rules), [Cursor CLI](https://cursor.com/docs/cli/using#rules), [Copilot CLI](https://docs.github.com/en/copilot/how-tos/copilot-cli/customize-copilot/add-custom-instructions), [Copilot support](https://docs.github.com/en/copilot/reference/custom-instructions-support), [Codex](https://learn.chatgpt.com/docs/agent-configuration/agents-md), [OpenCode V1](https://opencode.ai/docs/rules/), [OpenCode V2](https://opencode.ai/v2/docs/instructions/). diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-publication.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-publication.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6616bfc47 --- /dev/null +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-publication.md @@ -0,0 +1,28 @@ +# Rule publication + +## Publications + +| Host / ID | Target | Scope | +| --- | --- | --- | +| Claude / `claude` | `.claude/rules/<category>/<slug>.md` | YAML `paths` array; omit for all files | +| Cursor / `cursor` | `.cursor/rules/<category>/<slug>.mdc` | `description`, comma-joined `globs`, `alwaysApply: false`; all-files: no globs, true | +| Copilot / `copilot` | `.github/instructions/<NN>-<name>.instructions.md` | comma-joined `applyTo`; all-files `**` | +| Codex / `codex` | root `AGENTS.md` | shared signed `aidd_rules`, textual scope | +| OpenCode / `opencode` | root `AGENTS.md` | same contribution | + +## Operations + +Writer: absolute `scripts/write-rule.cjs` beside loaded installed `SKILL.md`; no checkout/project-relative/CLI assumption. + +JSON fields: category, slug, description, body strings; optional paths array. One-line description; empty/omitted paths: all files; no body frontmatter. Reject comma globs; split alternatives. + +```sh +node "$installed_rule_script" --project "$project_root" --tools "$confirmed_ids" --input "$request_json" +``` + +- Project: real absolute directory; tools: comma-separated confirmed IDs. +- Replace `--input "$request_json"` with `--publish`: all canonical sources, no identity argument; subset requests unsupported. +- Or `--delete category/slug`: one source, all recorded publications; reports `files`. +- Plugin: `plugins/<plugin>/rules/<category>/<slug>.md`; scoped YAML `paths` or no frontmatter. No writer, project metadata or host fan-out. +- Canonical body edits beneath intact metadata remain publishable. +- Physical deduplication does not ensure unique host context; local 32 KiB passes do not ensure total instruction budget. From 13e7cf059d85c1a22bef489d458a0ee16c845552 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE <baptiste.lafourcade@gmail.com> Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2026 06:14:23 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 19/24] docs(aidd-context): align rule generation with the lean skill style Give each action a one-line purpose and bold-led imperative steps, keep the approval gate in the router, and phrase rules positively. References stay self-contained. Refs #791 Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> --- .../skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md | 18 ++++++------- .../actions/01-capture-rule.md | 26 +++++++++++-------- .../05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md | 17 +++++++----- .../05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md | 16 +++++++----- .../references/rule-assessment.md | 21 ++++++++------- .../references/rule-authoring.md | 2 +- .../references/rule-discovery.md | 12 ++++----- .../references/rule-publication.md | 2 ++ 8 files changed, 65 insertions(+), 49 deletions(-) diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md index 8c7cdff55..4161c1a8a 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md @@ -21,18 +21,18 @@ flowchart TD ## Actions -Read the next action in `actions/` and its references. +Run the flow above. Read only the next action file and its references. | Action | Does | | --- | --- | -| `01-capture-rule.md` | frame, compare and decide | -| `02-write-rule.md` | publish the approved result | -| `03-validate.md` | check affected files | +| capture-rule | frame, compare and decide | +| write-rule | publish the approved result | +| validate | check the affected files | ## Transversal rules -- Report unsupported hosts and alternatives; AGENTS alone identifies no installed host. -- Missing/unreadable installed reference: stop. -- Create/update: present full assessed candidates, including new; await approval after capture confirmation before any rule/request/publication write. Renew after candidate/resolution/evidence changes. -- Existing changes require explicit identified-source/publication permissions. -- Keep/cancel leaves project bytes unchanged. +- **Report unsupported hosts** with alternatives; a lone AGENTS file identifies no installed host. +- **If an installed reference cannot be read**, stop and report the missing file. +- **Await approval** of the full assessed candidate, new rules included, before any rule, request or publication write; renew it when the candidate, resolution or evidence changes. +- **Change existing sources or publications** only with explicit permission naming them. +- **Keep or cancel** leaves project bytes unchanged. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md index e862e1907..ec67d9f05 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md @@ -1,21 +1,25 @@ # 01 - Capture rule +Frame the request, compare it with existing policies and decide with the user. + ## Input -Topic, `auto`, or publish/delete; default manual. +**Request.** A topic, `auto`, or a publish/delete; default manual. ## Output -Approved candidates or confirmed sources, operation and destinations. +Approved candidates, or confirmed sources, operation and destinations. ## Process -1. Confirm operation and [destination](../references/rule-publication.md). Missing hosts: detect and propose installations; await selection before drafting/assessment. -2. Manual: request missing topic. Auto: scan/propose topics; await selection. Publish/delete: confirm sources and whole publications; skip drafting/assessment to Write. -3. Create/update: confirm topic and [fields](../references/rule-publication.md#operations); draft full [candidates](../assets/rule-template.md) per [authoring](../references/rule-authoring.md). -4. [Discover policies](../references/rule-discovery.md) read-only; [compare](../references/rule-assessment.md). -5. Show full candidates and all findings. Needs review: request evidence; reassess before proposing source changes. Otherwise offer relevant choices; await resolution, then explicit subsequent approval. - -## Rules - -- Unresolved conflicts/uncertainty prevent proceeding. +1. **Confirm.** Confirm the operation and [destination](../references/rule-publication.md). + - **Missing hosts.** Detect them, propose installations and await selection before drafting. +2. **Frame.** Settle the topic. + - **Manual.** Ask for the missing topic. + - **Auto.** Scan, propose topics and await selection. + - **Publish/delete.** Confirm sources and whole publications, then go to write-rule. +3. **Draft.** Fill the [template](../assets/rule-template.md) per [authoring](../references/rule-authoring.md), once the topic and [fields](../references/rule-publication.md#operations) are confirmed. +4. **Compare.** [Discover policies](../references/rule-discovery.md) read-only in the project and loaded ancestors, skip home and account scans, then [assess](../references/rule-assessment.md) each candidate. +5. **Present.** Show full candidates, exact publication paths and every finding, new rules included. + - **Needs review.** Ask for evidence and reassess before offering source changes. + - **Resolved.** Await the resolution, then the explicit approval. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md index a3fff96cc..a195dbdd5 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md @@ -1,19 +1,24 @@ # 02 - Write rule +Publish the approved result. + ## Input -Approved capture. +The approved capture. ## Output -Files or refusal. +The written files, or the refusal. ## Process -1. Host create/update: serialize approved JSON outside destinations per [publication](../references/rule-publication.md). -2. Invoke installed absolute writer per publication. Plugin: directly write/delete approved source only; no fan-out. -3. Record results; stop on verbatim refusals. +1. **Match.** For create/update, check body, fields, publication paths, resolution and evidence against the last approved capture; on any difference, return to capture-rule. +2. **Serialize.** For host create/update, write the JSON request outside the destinations per [publication](../references/rule-publication.md). +3. **Write.** Apply the approved result. + - **Host.** Resolve the installed writer to an absolute path and reuse it for every call. + - **Plugin.** Write or delete the approved source only. +4. **Report.** List the written files; on refusal, stop and quote it verbatim. ## Rules -- Preserve approved capture exactly. Never regenerate, edit canonical metadata or generated outputs manually, migrate legacy rules or bypass refusals. +- **Leave generated files to the writer.** Canonical metadata and generated outputs stay writer-owned, and legacy rules stay unchanged. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md index 0514acca0..e5983697f 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md @@ -1,20 +1,22 @@ # 03 - Validate +Check the affected files against the approved capture. + ## Input -Approved capture; write results. +The approved capture and the write results. ## Output -Per-rule pass/fail reasons. +A pass or fail with reasons, one row per rule. ## Process -1. Check reported existence/deletion. -2. Match approved fields and host schemas against [authoring](../references/rule-authoring.md) and [publication](../references/rule-publication.md). -3. Affected shared publications only: check signed uniqueness and last-rule cleanup. Verify survivors, user guidance and memory bytes. -4. Hosts: repeat approved publication; require identical bytes. +1. **Check.** Check existence or deletion, approved fields and host schemas against [authoring](../references/rule-authoring.md) and [publication](../references/rule-publication.md). +2. **Share.** For affected shared publications, check signed uniqueness and last-rule cleanup, then verify survivors, user guidance and memory bytes. +3. **Repeat.** For hosts, republish through the same absolute writer path (`--publish` after a deletion) and require identical bytes. +4. **Report.** Deliver the rows, even when all pass. ## Rules -- Consumption requires matching/nonmatching file evidence in fresh host sessions. +- **Claim consumption** only with matching and nonmatching file evidence from fresh host sessions. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-assessment.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-assessment.md index 420a72861..3173930d9 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-assessment.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-assessment.md @@ -2,18 +2,21 @@ ## Labels -- **needs review**: uncertainty that could affect comparison with existing policies. Overrides other labels. -- **new**: no coverage, overlap or conflict. -- **covered**: all obligations supplied throughout scope. -- **overlap**: compatible partial repetition/extension. -- **conflict**: incompatible obligations or unjustified weakening. +| Label | Means | +| --- | --- | +| needs review | uncertainty that could change the comparison; overrides every other label | +| new | no coverage, overlap or conflict | +| covered | existing policies supply every obligation throughout the scope | +| overlap | compatible partial repetition or extension | +| conflict | incompatible obligations, or an unjustified weakening | ## Comparison -- Compare obligations, prohibitions, scopes, conditions, exceptions and priority, including prior sources when updating and future files. -- Exclude only proven disjoint scopes. -- Findings include source paths, decisive quotes and scope reasons. +- **Compare** obligations, prohibitions, scopes, conditions, exceptions and priority, including prior sources on update and future files. +- **Exclude** only scopes proven disjoint. +- **Cite** source paths, decisive quotes and scope reasons in every finding. ## Choices -Choices: create, keep, update, merge, scope, priority or cancel. Needs review: evidence, keep or cancel; no source-change choice. +- **Offer** create, keep, update, merge, scope, priority or cancel as applicable. +- **On needs review**, request evidence and reassess before offering source changes; keep and cancel stay available. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md index 985f76728..d84a83b76 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md @@ -6,7 +6,7 @@ - **R2.** Concise bullets only; preserve literals, conditions and exceptions. - **R3.** Explicit scope or all files. - **R4.** English unless explicitly requested otherwise. -- **R5.** Never repeat, weaken or contradict active bullets within a rule. +- **R5.** Keep bullets distinct: repeat, weaken or contradict no active bullet within a rule. ## Naming diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-discovery.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-discovery.md index a336e73db..ccd7279e6 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-discovery.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-discovery.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # Rule discovery -- Hosts: [native paths and scopes](rule-publication.md#publications), canonical `aidd_docs/rules/**/*.md`, recorded targets, recursive native directories at relevant root/nested locations and guidance below. +- Hosts: native paths and scopes from `rule-publication.md`, canonical `aidd_docs/rules/**/*.md`, recorded targets, recursive native directories at relevant root/nested locations and guidance below. - Plugin: confirmed rules, project authoring guidance, known companion policies. | Host | Additional project guidance | @@ -11,11 +11,11 @@ | Codex | root/nested: first nonempty `AGENTS.override.md`, `AGENTS.md`, configured fallbacks, in order | | OpenCode | V2: project/upward/nested `AGENTS.md`; V1: nearest upward AGENTS, enabled `CLAUDE.md` fallback if absent, explicit project config `instructions` sources | -- Include loaded ancestors, configured sources, future-file scopes, user text outside generated blocks; no home/account scan or completeness claim. -- Potentially applicable existing policies: verify host/interface applicability; existence proves no activation. Unresolved: [assessment](rule-assessment.md). -- Deduplicate canonical body/scope renderings only with verified ownership; retain every path. Keep differing native edits and unsigned policies separate; missing publications never exclude canonical intent. -- Follow documented imports within repository, detecting cycles. Relevant unsafe/external/symlink escapes or uncertainty need review. Never execute imports. -- Copilot CLI recursively imports `@relative-path` from repository-wide/agent sources except GEMINI; never modular or absolute/home-relative. Disabled sources are inactive; repository/agent sources lack general precedence. +- Include loaded ancestors, configured sources, future-file scopes and user text outside generated blocks; make no completeness claim. +- Potentially applicable existing policies: verify host/interface applicability; existence proves no activation. Unresolved cases go to `rule-assessment.md`. +- Deduplicate canonical body/scope renderings only with verified ownership; retain every path. Keep differing native edits and unsigned policies separate; a missing publication leaves canonical intent in scope. +- Follow documented imports within repository, detecting cycles. Relevant unsafe/external/symlink escapes or uncertainty need review. Treat imports as text and execute none. +- Copilot CLI recursively imports `@relative-path` from repository-wide/agent sources except GEMINI; not modular or absolute/home-relative. Disabled sources are inactive; repository/agent sources lack general precedence. - V1 plain references are not automatically expanded. ## Contracts diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-publication.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-publication.md index 6616bfc47..60e8bee06 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-publication.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-publication.md @@ -10,6 +10,8 @@ | Codex / `codex` | root `AGENTS.md` | shared signed `aidd_rules`, textual scope | | OpenCode / `opencode` | root `AGENTS.md` | same contribution | +Copilot `<name>` drops the slug's numeric prefix: category `01-standards`, slug `1-local-names` → `01-local-names.instructions.md`. + ## Operations Writer: absolute `scripts/write-rule.cjs` beside loaded installed `SKILL.md`; no checkout/project-relative/CLI assumption. From 840a9c8ea90d20a8fda4ff2adb7d161c98a28c40 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE <baptiste.lafourcade@gmail.com> Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2026 06:37:30 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 20/24] feat(aidd-context): plan and verify rule publication in the writer Add --plan (dry run listing exact paths, same refusals) and --check --publish (drift report, non-zero on drift) to the standalone writer. Rule generation drops its validate action: capture plans before approval, write verifies after publishing. Refs #791 Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> --- docs/CATALOG.md | 2 +- plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md | 1 - .../skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md | 10 ++- .../actions/01-capture-rule.md | 9 +-- .../05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md | 17 ++--- .../05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md | 22 ------ .../references/rule-publication.md | 5 +- .../05-rule-generate/scripts/write-rule.cjs | 11 ++- scripts/__tests__/rule-generation.test.js | 69 +++++++++++++++++++ 9 files changed, 100 insertions(+), 46 deletions(-) delete mode 100644 plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md diff --git a/docs/CATALOG.md b/docs/CATALOG.md index a32432450..c833e13d3 100644 --- a/docs/CATALOG.md +++ b/docs/CATALOG.md @@ -25,7 +25,7 @@ Bootstrap, project init, context-artifact generation, diagrams, learning, and ex | `02-project-memory` | Give the AI a memory of the project, wired into the tools you use | `01-scan`, `02-write`, `03-check`, `04-sync` | | `03-context-generate` | Router that dispatches an artifact-generation request to the dedicated generator below | delegates to `04`–`08` (and plugins / marketplaces) | | `04-skill-generate` | Generate a router-based skill across the host AI tool(s) | `01-scope`, `02-plan`, `03-write`, `04-validate` | -| `05-rule-generate` | Generate a coding rule that governs editor and agent behavior | `01-capture-rule`, `02-write-rule`, `03-validate` | +| `05-rule-generate` | Generate a coding rule that governs editor and agent behavior | `01-capture-rule`, `02-write-rule` | | `06-agent-generate` | Generate an agent across the host AI tool(s) | `01-capture-agent`, `02-write-agent`, `03-validate` | | `07-command-generate` | Generate a flat slash command across the host AI tool(s) | `01-capture-command`, `02-write-command`, `03-validate` | | `08-hook-generate` | Generate a lifecycle hook across the host AI tool(s) | `01-capture-hook`, `02-write-hook`, `03-validate` | diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md b/plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md index 96673d976..176335539 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/CATALOG.md @@ -118,7 +118,6 @@ Auto-generated index of skills, agents, references and assets shipped by the `ai |-------|------|---| | `actions` | [01-capture-rule.md](skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md) | - | | `actions` | [02-write-rule.md](skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md) | - | -| `actions` | [03-validate.md](skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md) | - | | `assets` | [rule-template.md](skills/05-rule-generate/assets/rule-template.md) | - | | `references` | [rule-assessment.md](skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-assessment.md) | - | | `references` | [rule-authoring.md](skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md) | - | diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md index 4161c1a8a..82d9783b2 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md @@ -14,9 +14,9 @@ flowchart TD decision -->|keep/cancel| stop decision -->|approved| write-rule capture-rule -->|publish/delete confirmed| write-rule - write-rule -->|written| validate + write-rule -->|revised| capture-rule write-rule -->|refused| stop - validate --> result + write-rule -->|verified| result ``` ## Actions @@ -25,14 +25,12 @@ Run the flow above. Read only the next action file and its references. | Action | Does | | --- | --- | -| capture-rule | frame, compare and decide | -| write-rule | publish the approved result | -| validate | check the affected files | +| capture-rule | frame, compare, plan and decide | +| write-rule | publish the approved result and verify it | ## Transversal rules - **Report unsupported hosts** with alternatives; a lone AGENTS file identifies no installed host. - **If an installed reference cannot be read**, stop and report the missing file. -- **Await approval** of the full assessed candidate, new rules included, before any rule, request or publication write; renew it when the candidate, resolution or evidence changes. - **Change existing sources or publications** only with explicit permission naming them. - **Keep or cancel** leaves project bytes unchanged. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md index ec67d9f05..16bff49bc 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # 01 - Capture rule -Frame the request, compare it with existing policies and decide with the user. +Frame the request, compare it with existing policies, plan the publication and decide with the user. ## Input @@ -8,7 +8,7 @@ Frame the request, compare it with existing policies and decide with the user. ## Output -Approved candidates, or confirmed sources, operation and destinations. +Approved candidates with their planned publication paths, or confirmed sources, operation and destinations. ## Process @@ -17,9 +17,10 @@ Approved candidates, or confirmed sources, operation and destinations. 2. **Frame.** Settle the topic. - **Manual.** Ask for the missing topic. - **Auto.** Scan, propose topics and await selection. - - **Publish/delete.** Confirm sources and whole publications, then go to write-rule. + - **Publish/delete.** Confirm sources and whole publications, then plan. 3. **Draft.** Fill the [template](../assets/rule-template.md) per [authoring](../references/rule-authoring.md), once the topic and [fields](../references/rule-publication.md#operations) are confirmed. 4. **Compare.** [Discover policies](../references/rule-discovery.md) read-only in the project and loaded ancestors, skip home and account scans, then [assess](../references/rule-assessment.md) each candidate. -5. **Present.** Show full candidates, exact publication paths and every finding, new rules included. +5. **Plan.** For a host, serialize the request outside the destinations and run the writer with `--plan` per [publication](../references/rule-publication.md); a refusal returns to Draft. +6. **Present.** Show full candidates, the planned paths and every finding, new rules included. - **Needs review.** Ask for evidence and reassess before offering source changes. - **Resolved.** Await the resolution, then the explicit approval. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md index a195dbdd5..110cc34e2 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md @@ -1,24 +1,25 @@ # 02 - Write rule -Publish the approved result. +Publish the approved result and verify it. ## Input -The approved capture. +The approved capture and its request. ## Output -The written files, or the refusal. +The written files, verified, or the refusal. ## Process -1. **Match.** For create/update, check body, fields, publication paths, resolution and evidence against the last approved capture; on any difference, return to capture-rule. -2. **Serialize.** For host create/update, write the JSON request outside the destinations per [publication](../references/rule-publication.md). -3. **Write.** Apply the approved result. - - **Host.** Resolve the installed writer to an absolute path and reuse it for every call. +1. **Match.** For create/update, check body, fields, publication paths, resolution and evidence against the last approved capture; on any difference, return to capture-rule, present the revision and await approval before writing. +2. **Write.** Apply the approved result. + - **Host.** Run the installed writer by the same absolute path as the plan, with the approved request. - **Plugin.** Write or delete the approved source only. -4. **Report.** List the written files; on refusal, stop and quote it verbatim. +3. **Verify.** For a host, run the same absolute writer with `--check --publish`; require no drift, also after a deletion. +4. **Report.** List the written files; on refusal or drift, stop and quote it verbatim. ## Rules - **Leave generated files to the writer.** Canonical metadata and generated outputs stay writer-owned, and legacy rules stay unchanged. +- **Claim consumption** only with matching and nonmatching file evidence from fresh host sessions. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md deleted file mode 100644 index e5983697f..000000000 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/03-validate.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,22 +0,0 @@ -# 03 - Validate - -Check the affected files against the approved capture. - -## Input - -The approved capture and the write results. - -## Output - -A pass or fail with reasons, one row per rule. - -## Process - -1. **Check.** Check existence or deletion, approved fields and host schemas against [authoring](../references/rule-authoring.md) and [publication](../references/rule-publication.md). -2. **Share.** For affected shared publications, check signed uniqueness and last-rule cleanup, then verify survivors, user guidance and memory bytes. -3. **Repeat.** For hosts, republish through the same absolute writer path (`--publish` after a deletion) and require identical bytes. -4. **Report.** Deliver the rows, even when all pass. - -## Rules - -- **Claim consumption** only with matching and nonmatching file evidence from fresh host sessions. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-publication.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-publication.md index 60e8bee06..5e67c5460 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-publication.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-publication.md @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ Copilot `<name>` drops the slug's numeric prefix: category `01-standards`, slug Writer: absolute `scripts/write-rule.cjs` beside loaded installed `SKILL.md`; no checkout/project-relative/CLI assumption. -JSON fields: category, slug, description, body strings; optional paths array. One-line description; empty/omitted paths: all files; no body frontmatter. Reject comma globs; split alternatives. +JSON: category, slug, description, body; optional paths array, omitted for all files. Split comma globs; the writer refuses what else is invalid. ```sh node "$installed_rule_script" --project "$project_root" --tools "$confirmed_ids" --input "$request_json" @@ -25,6 +25,7 @@ node "$installed_rule_script" --project "$project_root" --tools "$confirmed_ids" - Project: real absolute directory; tools: comma-separated confirmed IDs. - Replace `--input "$request_json"` with `--publish`: all canonical sources, no identity argument; subset requests unsupported. - Or `--delete category/slug`: one source, all recorded publications; reports `files`. +- Add `--plan` to any of the three: validates every refusal, writes nothing, reports `{"dryRun":true,"files":[...]}` with the exact paths a real run touches. +- Use `--check --publish` to verify: writes nothing, reports `{"drift":[...]}` and exits non-zero while any publication differs from its canonical source. - Plugin: `plugins/<plugin>/rules/<category>/<slug>.md`; scoped YAML `paths` or no frontmatter. No writer, project metadata or host fan-out. -- Canonical body edits beneath intact metadata remain publishable. - Physical deduplication does not ensure unique host context; local 32 KiB passes do not ensure total instruction budget. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/scripts/write-rule.cjs b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/scripts/write-rule.cjs index e7f1d0c9c..ba341479d 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/scripts/write-rule.cjs +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/scripts/write-rule.cjs @@ -25,12 +25,13 @@ function options(args) { const result = {}; for (let i = 0; i < args.length; i++) { const key = args[i]; - if (!["--project", "--tools", "--input", "--delete", "--publish"].includes(key) || key in result) fail(`Unknown or repeated option: ${key}`); - result[key] = key === "--publish" ? true : args[++i]; + if (!["--project", "--tools", "--input", "--delete", "--publish", "--plan", "--check"].includes(key) || key in result) fail(`Unknown or repeated option: ${key}`); + result[key] = ["--publish", "--plan", "--check"].includes(key) ? true : args[++i]; if (!result[key] || (typeof result[key] === "string" && result[key].startsWith("--"))) fail(`Missing value: ${key}`); } if (!result["--project"] || !result["--tools"]) fail("Explicit --project and --tools are required."); if (["--input", "--delete", "--publish"].filter((key) => key in result).length !== 1) fail("Choose exactly one of --input, --delete or --publish."); + if (result["--check"] && (!result["--publish"] || result["--plan"])) fail("--check verifies --publish alone and excludes --plan."); return result; } @@ -263,6 +264,12 @@ function main() { } // Preflight every destination and ownership above; no validation can first happen after mutation. for (const relative of writes.keys()) target(relative); + if (opts["--plan"]) return void process.stdout.write(JSON.stringify({ dryRun: true, files: [...writes.keys()] }) + "\n"); + if (opts["--check"]) { + const drift = [...writes].filter(([relative, text]) => text !== read(relative)).map(([relative]) => relative); + process.exitCode = drift.length ? 1 : 0; + return void process.stdout.write(JSON.stringify({ drift }) + "\n"); + } for (const [relative, text] of writes) { const file = target(relative); if (text === read(relative)) continue; diff --git a/scripts/__tests__/rule-generation.test.js b/scripts/__tests__/rule-generation.test.js index a387f554f..dd6d1ac0b 100644 --- a/scripts/__tests__/rule-generation.test.js +++ b/scripts/__tests__/rule-generation.test.js @@ -389,3 +389,72 @@ test("valid Unicode pairs and CRLF body survive installed generation and publica assert.equal(f.run(null, ALL, ["--publish"]).status, 0); assert.deepEqual(f.snapshot(), before); }); + +const json = (result) => JSON.parse(result.stdout); + +test("--plan lists exact publication paths for create, update and delete without touching any byte", (t) => { + const f = fixture(t); + const before = f.snapshot(); + const planned = f.run(rule, ALL, ["--plan", "--input", path.join(f.dir, "input.json")]); + assert.equal(planned.status, 0, planned.stderr); + assert.equal(json(planned).dryRun, true); + assert.deepEqual(json(planned).files.sort(), ["AGENTS.md", ".claude/rules/01-standards/1-naming.md", ".cursor/rules/01-standards/1-naming.mdc", ".github/instructions/01-naming.instructions.md", "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-naming.md"].sort()); + assert.deepEqual(f.snapshot(), before); + assert.equal(f.run().status, 0); + const published = f.snapshot(); + const removal = f.run(null, ALL, ["--plan", "--delete", "01-standards/1-naming"]); + assert.equal(removal.status, 0, removal.stderr); + assert.ok(json(removal).files.includes(".claude/rules/01-standards/1-naming.md")); + assert.deepEqual(f.snapshot(), published); +}); + +test("--plan refuses exactly what the real run refuses and still changes nothing", (t) => { + const f = fixture(t); + const before = f.snapshot(); + const bad = f.run({ ...rule, slug: "naming" }, ALL, ["--plan", "--input", path.join(f.dir, "input.json")]); + assert.equal(bad.status, 1); + assert.match(bad.stderr, /Invalid taxonomy category or matching #-slug/); + const absent = f.run(null, ALL, ["--plan", "--delete", "01-standards/1-naming"]); + assert.equal(absent.status, 1); + assert.match(absent.stderr, /Cannot delete an absent canonical rule/); + assert.deepEqual(f.snapshot(), before); +}); + +test("--check passes on an idempotent publication and names every drifting file otherwise", (t) => { + const f = fixture(t); + assert.equal(f.run().status, 0); + const before = f.snapshot(); + const clean = f.run(null, ALL, ["--check", "--publish"]); + assert.equal(clean.status, 0, clean.stderr); + assert.deepEqual(json(clean).drift, []); + const source = "aidd_docs/rules/01-standards/1-naming.md"; + f.put(source, f.read(source).replace(rule.body, "- Manual source edit.\n")); + const edited = f.snapshot(); + const drifted = f.run(null, ALL, ["--check", "--publish"]); + assert.equal(drifted.status, 1); + assert.ok(json(drifted).drift.includes(".claude/rules/01-standards/1-naming.md")); + assert.ok(json(drifted).drift.includes("AGENTS.md")); + assert.deepEqual(f.snapshot(), edited); + assert.notDeepEqual(edited, before); +}); + +test("--check holds after a deletion that emptied the publications", (t) => { + const f = fixture(t); + assert.equal(f.run().status, 0); + assert.equal(f.run(null, ALL, ["--delete", "01-standards/1-naming"]).status, 0); + const after = f.snapshot(); + const checked = f.run(null, ALL, ["--check", "--publish"]); + assert.equal(checked.status, 0, checked.stderr); + assert.deepEqual(json(checked).drift, []); + assert.deepEqual(f.snapshot(), after); +}); + +test("--plan and --check accept only the operations they can simulate", (t) => { + const f = fixture(t); + assert.equal(f.run().status, 0); + for (const extra of [["--check", "--delete", "01-standards/1-naming"], ["--check", "--plan", "--publish"], ["--plan"], ["--check"], ["--plan", "--plan", "--publish"]]) { + const result = f.run(null, ALL, extra); + assert.equal(result.status, 1, extra.join(" ")); + assert.equal(result.stdout, ""); + } +}); From 8a3fd92d4bf1592e79215bc4a66246587a4f6439 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE <baptiste.lafourcade@gmail.com> Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2026 06:55:15 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 21/24] fix(aidd-context): a resolution is not an approval in rule generation Present ends the turn, replans after any change and waits for a later explicit approval. The writer path is resolved absolute once, in capture. Refs #791 Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> --- .../skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md | 6 +++--- .../skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md | 4 ++-- 2 files changed, 5 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md index 16bff49bc..c7db2d8b5 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md @@ -20,7 +20,7 @@ Approved candidates with their planned publication paths, or confirmed sources, - **Publish/delete.** Confirm sources and whole publications, then plan. 3. **Draft.** Fill the [template](../assets/rule-template.md) per [authoring](../references/rule-authoring.md), once the topic and [fields](../references/rule-publication.md#operations) are confirmed. 4. **Compare.** [Discover policies](../references/rule-discovery.md) read-only in the project and loaded ancestors, skip home and account scans, then [assess](../references/rule-assessment.md) each candidate. -5. **Plan.** For a host, serialize the request outside the destinations and run the writer with `--plan` per [publication](../references/rule-publication.md); a refusal returns to Draft. -6. **Present.** Show full candidates, the planned paths and every finding, new rules included. +5. **Plan.** For a host, resolve the installed writer to an absolute path, serialize the request outside the destinations and run it with `--plan` per [publication](../references/rule-publication.md); a refusal returns to Draft. +6. **Present.** Show full candidates, the planned paths and every finding, new rules included, then end the turn. - **Needs review.** Ask for evidence and reassess before offering source changes. - - **Resolved.** Await the resolution, then the explicit approval. + - **Resolved.** A resolution is not an approval: replan, present the revised candidate and end the turn again; only a later explicit approval releases the write. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md index 110cc34e2..3b4a82afe 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md @@ -14,9 +14,9 @@ The written files, verified, or the refusal. 1. **Match.** For create/update, check body, fields, publication paths, resolution and evidence against the last approved capture; on any difference, return to capture-rule, present the revision and await approval before writing. 2. **Write.** Apply the approved result. - - **Host.** Run the installed writer by the same absolute path as the plan, with the approved request. + - **Host.** Run the writer by the absolute path resolved in capture-rule, never `$PWD`-relative, with the approved request. - **Plugin.** Write or delete the approved source only. -3. **Verify.** For a host, run the same absolute writer with `--check --publish`; require no drift, also after a deletion. +3. **Verify.** For a host, run that same absolute writer with `--check --publish`; require no drift, also after a deletion. 4. **Report.** List the written files; on refusal or drift, stop and quote it verbatim. ## Rules From 01aa9ca42803353e9cc62704f2a731d65aecf4c8 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE <baptiste.lafourcade@gmail.com> Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2026 06:57:54 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 22/24] fix(aidd-context): define approval where rule generation writes Write requires a user message that approves the displayed candidate unchanged; a choice, edit or rename is a resolution. Refs #791 Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> --- .../skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md | 6 ++++-- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md index 3b4a82afe..67bca633b 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md @@ -4,7 +4,9 @@ Publish the approved result and verify it. ## Input -The approved capture and its request. +**Approval.** A user message after the last displayed candidate that approves it unchanged; a message that chooses, edits or renames is a resolution, not an approval. + +**Capture.** The approved capture and its request. ## Output @@ -12,7 +14,7 @@ The written files, verified, or the refusal. ## Process -1. **Match.** For create/update, check body, fields, publication paths, resolution and evidence against the last approved capture; on any difference, return to capture-rule, present the revision and await approval before writing. +1. **Match.** For create/update, require that approval and check body, fields, publication paths, resolution and evidence against the candidate it approved; without it or on any difference, return to capture-rule, present the revision, end the turn and write nothing. 2. **Write.** Apply the approved result. - **Host.** Run the writer by the absolute path resolved in capture-rule, never `$PWD`-relative, with the approved request. - **Plugin.** Write or delete the approved source only. From bfaae917c1198dcea0bcbf80d1f70ce71f48e439 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE <baptiste.lafourcade@gmail.com> Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2026 06:57:59 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 23/24] docs(aidd-context): drop the redundant relative-path warning from write-rule Refs #791 Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> --- .../skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md index 67bca633b..95060e41a 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ The written files, verified, or the refusal. 1. **Match.** For create/update, require that approval and check body, fields, publication paths, resolution and evidence against the candidate it approved; without it or on any difference, return to capture-rule, present the revision, end the turn and write nothing. 2. **Write.** Apply the approved result. - - **Host.** Run the writer by the absolute path resolved in capture-rule, never `$PWD`-relative, with the approved request. + - **Host.** Run the writer by the absolute path resolved in capture-rule, with the approved request. - **Plugin.** Write or delete the approved source only. 3. **Verify.** For a host, run that same absolute writer with `--check --publish`; require no drift, also after a deletion. 4. **Report.** List the written files; on refusal or drift, stop and quote it verbatim. From d8d30da553487bc5a5d7f4b4bf33d14865e20571 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Baptiste LAFOURCADE <baptiste.lafourcade@gmail.com> Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2026 11:07:25 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 24/24] refactor(aidd-context): lean rule-generate wording and single approval rule Drop redundant bold step labels and filler across the skill, state the approval rule once in the transversal rules, show description, scope and hosts in the presented candidate, and reuse the existing rule's hosts. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> --- .../skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md | 15 +++++----- .../actions/01-capture-rule.md | 30 +++++++++---------- .../05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md | 22 +++++++------- .../references/rule-assessment.md | 10 +++---- .../references/rule-authoring.md | 14 ++++----- .../references/rule-discovery.md | 14 ++++----- .../references/rule-publication.md | 18 +++++------ 7 files changed, 62 insertions(+), 61 deletions(-) diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md index 82d9783b2..f8ee0c351 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/SKILL.md @@ -21,16 +21,17 @@ flowchart TD ## Actions -Run the flow above. Read only the next action file and its references. +Follow the flow. Read only the next action and its references. | Action | Does | | --- | --- | -| capture-rule | frame, compare, plan and decide | -| write-rule | publish the approved result and verify it | +| capture-rule | frame, compare, plan, decide | +| write-rule | write the approved result, verify | ## Transversal rules -- **Report unsupported hosts** with alternatives; a lone AGENTS file identifies no installed host. -- **If an installed reference cannot be read**, stop and report the missing file. -- **Change existing sources or publications** only with explicit permission naming them. -- **Keep or cancel** leaves project bytes unchanged. +- Report unsupported hosts with alternatives; a lone AGENTS file identifies no installed host. +- Stop and name any installed reference that cannot be read. +- Change existing sources or publications only with explicit permission naming them. +- Write only after the user approves the candidate shown last. A choice, merge, edit or rename is not an approval: show the revision and wait. +- Keep or cancel leaves project bytes unchanged. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md index c7db2d8b5..ce6f18d17 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/01-capture-rule.md @@ -1,26 +1,26 @@ # 01 - Capture rule -Frame the request, compare it with existing policies, plan the publication and decide with the user. +Frame the request, compare it with existing policies, plan the publication, decide with the user. ## Input -**Request.** A topic, `auto`, or a publish/delete; default manual. +Request: a topic, `auto`, or a publish/delete. Default manual. ## Output -Approved candidates with their planned publication paths, or confirmed sources, operation and destinations. +Approved candidates with planned paths, or confirmed sources, operation and destinations. ## Process -1. **Confirm.** Confirm the operation and [destination](../references/rule-publication.md). - - **Missing hosts.** Detect them, propose installations and await selection before drafting. -2. **Frame.** Settle the topic. - - **Manual.** Ask for the missing topic. - - **Auto.** Scan, propose topics and await selection. - - **Publish/delete.** Confirm sources and whole publications, then plan. -3. **Draft.** Fill the [template](../assets/rule-template.md) per [authoring](../references/rule-authoring.md), once the topic and [fields](../references/rule-publication.md#operations) are confirmed. -4. **Compare.** [Discover policies](../references/rule-discovery.md) read-only in the project and loaded ancestors, skip home and account scans, then [assess](../references/rule-assessment.md) each candidate. -5. **Plan.** For a host, resolve the installed writer to an absolute path, serialize the request outside the destinations and run it with `--plan` per [publication](../references/rule-publication.md); a refusal returns to Draft. -6. **Present.** Show full candidates, the planned paths and every finding, new rules included, then end the turn. - - **Needs review.** Ask for evidence and reassess before offering source changes. - - **Resolved.** A resolution is not an approval: replan, present the revised candidate and end the turn again; only a later explicit approval releases the write. +1. Confirm the operation and [destination](../references/rule-publication.md). + - Hosts: reuse the existing rule's hosts, else ask. Missing hosts: detect, propose installation, await selection before drafting. +2. Frame the topic. + - Manual: ask for it. + - Auto: scan, propose topics, await selection. + - Publish/delete: confirm sources and whole publications, then plan. +3. Draft with the [template](../assets/rule-template.md) and [authoring](../references/rule-authoring.md), once topic and [fields](../references/rule-publication.md#operations) are confirmed. +4. Compare: [discover policies](../references/rule-discovery.md) read-only in the project and loaded ancestors, never home or account scans, then [assess](../references/rule-assessment.md) each candidate. +5. Plan: for a host, resolve the installed writer to an absolute path, write the request outside the destinations, run it with `--plan` per [publication](../references/rule-publication.md). A refusal returns to step 3. +6. Present each candidate in full (body, description, scope, hosts), the planned paths and every finding (new rules too), then end the turn. + - Needs review: ask for evidence, reassess before offering source changes. + - Resolved: replan, present the revised candidate, end the turn again. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md index 95060e41a..a8e705925 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/actions/02-write-rule.md @@ -1,12 +1,12 @@ # 02 - Write rule -Publish the approved result and verify it. +Write the approved result and verify it. ## Input -**Approval.** A user message after the last displayed candidate that approves it unchanged; a message that chooses, edits or renames is a resolution, not an approval. +Approval: a user message approving the last displayed candidate unchanged. -**Capture.** The approved capture and its request. +Capture: the approved capture and its request. ## Output @@ -14,14 +14,14 @@ The written files, verified, or the refusal. ## Process -1. **Match.** For create/update, require that approval and check body, fields, publication paths, resolution and evidence against the candidate it approved; without it or on any difference, return to capture-rule, present the revision, end the turn and write nothing. -2. **Write.** Apply the approved result. - - **Host.** Run the writer by the absolute path resolved in capture-rule, with the approved request. - - **Plugin.** Write or delete the approved source only. -3. **Verify.** For a host, run that same absolute writer with `--check --publish`; require no drift, also after a deletion. -4. **Report.** List the written files; on refusal or drift, stop and quote it verbatim. +1. Match: for create/update, require that approval and compare body, fields, paths, resolution and evidence with the approved candidate. Without approval or on any difference, return to capture-rule, present the revision, end the turn, write nothing. +2. Write the approved result. + - Host: run the writer by the absolute path resolved in capture-rule, with the approved request. + - Plugin: write or delete the approved source only. +3. Verify: for a host, run the same absolute writer with `--check --publish`. Require no drift, deletions included. +4. Report the written files. On refusal or drift, stop and quote it verbatim. ## Rules -- **Leave generated files to the writer.** Canonical metadata and generated outputs stay writer-owned, and legacy rules stay unchanged. -- **Claim consumption** only with matching and nonmatching file evidence from fresh host sessions. +- Leave generated files to the writer: canonical metadata and outputs are writer-owned, legacy rules unchanged. +- Claim consumption only with matching and nonmatching file evidence from fresh host sessions. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-assessment.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-assessment.md index 3173930d9..e53216154 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-assessment.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-assessment.md @@ -12,11 +12,11 @@ ## Comparison -- **Compare** obligations, prohibitions, scopes, conditions, exceptions and priority, including prior sources on update and future files. -- **Exclude** only scopes proven disjoint. -- **Cite** source paths, decisive quotes and scope reasons in every finding. +- Compare obligations, prohibitions, scopes, conditions, exceptions and priority, prior sources on update and future files included. +- Exclude only scopes proven disjoint. +- Cite source paths, decisive quotes and scope reasons in every finding. ## Choices -- **Offer** create, keep, update, merge, scope, priority or cancel as applicable. -- **On needs review**, request evidence and reassess before offering source changes; keep and cancel stay available. +- Offer create, keep, update, merge, scope, priority or cancel as applicable. +- Needs review: request evidence, reassess before offering source changes. Keep and cancel stay available. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md index d84a83b76..7b5bddd27 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-authoring.md @@ -2,11 +2,11 @@ ## Rules -- **R1.** One topic per file; split multiple topics. -- **R2.** Concise bullets only; preserve literals, conditions and exceptions. -- **R3.** Explicit scope or all files. -- **R4.** English unless explicitly requested otherwise. -- **R5.** Keep bullets distinct: repeat, weaken or contradict no active bullet within a rule. +- R1. One topic per file; split multiple topics. +- R2. Concise bullets; keep literals, conditions and exceptions. +- R3. Explicit scope or all files. +- R4. English unless asked otherwise. +- R5. Distinct bullets: none repeats, weakens or contradicts another. ## Naming @@ -25,6 +25,6 @@ | 08 | domain | business logic | | 09 | other | miscellaneous | -Prefer framework `03`, syntax `02`, style `01`, architecture `00`, then `04`–`08` in order, else `09`. +Pick in order: `03`, `02`, `01`, `00`, `04`–`08`, else `09`. -- Themes: `## group`; one tiny clarifying good-code example per group maximum. +- Themes: `## group`, at most one tiny good-code example each. diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-discovery.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-discovery.md index ccd7279e6..1e84e8f9e 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-discovery.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-discovery.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # Rule discovery -- Hosts: native paths and scopes from `rule-publication.md`, canonical `aidd_docs/rules/**/*.md`, recorded targets, recursive native directories at relevant root/nested locations and guidance below. +- Hosts: native paths and scopes from `rule-publication.md`, canonical `aidd_docs/rules/**/*.md`, recorded targets, recursive native directories at relevant root and nested locations, and the guidance below. - Plugin: confirmed rules, project authoring guidance, known companion policies. | Host | Additional project guidance | @@ -11,12 +11,12 @@ | Codex | root/nested: first nonempty `AGENTS.override.md`, `AGENTS.md`, configured fallbacks, in order | | OpenCode | V2: project/upward/nested `AGENTS.md`; V1: nearest upward AGENTS, enabled `CLAUDE.md` fallback if absent, explicit project config `instructions` sources | -- Include loaded ancestors, configured sources, future-file scopes and user text outside generated blocks; make no completeness claim. -- Potentially applicable existing policies: verify host/interface applicability; existence proves no activation. Unresolved cases go to `rule-assessment.md`. -- Deduplicate canonical body/scope renderings only with verified ownership; retain every path. Keep differing native edits and unsigned policies separate; a missing publication leaves canonical intent in scope. -- Follow documented imports within repository, detecting cycles. Relevant unsafe/external/symlink escapes or uncertainty need review. Treat imports as text and execute none. -- Copilot CLI recursively imports `@relative-path` from repository-wide/agent sources except GEMINI; not modular or absolute/home-relative. Disabled sources are inactive; repository/agent sources lack general precedence. -- V1 plain references are not automatically expanded. +- Include loaded ancestors, configured sources, future-file scopes and user text outside generated blocks. Claim no completeness. +- Existing policies: verify host and interface applicability; existence proves no activation. Unresolved cases go to `rule-assessment.md`. +- Deduplicate canonical body/scope renderings only with verified ownership, keeping every path. Keep differing native edits and unsigned policies separate. A missing publication leaves canonical intent in scope. +- Follow documented imports inside the repository, detect cycles, execute nothing. Relevant unsafe, external or symlink escapes, or uncertainty, need review. +- Copilot CLI imports `@relative-path` recursively from repository-wide and agent sources except GEMINI; never from modular, absolute or home-relative ones. Disabled sources are inactive; repository and agent sources have no general precedence. +- V1 plain references are not expanded. ## Contracts diff --git a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-publication.md b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-publication.md index 5e67c5460..af89c4aaf 100644 --- a/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-publication.md +++ b/plugins/aidd-context/skills/05-rule-generate/references/rule-publication.md @@ -14,18 +14,18 @@ Copilot `<name>` drops the slug's numeric prefix: category `01-standards`, slug ## Operations -Writer: absolute `scripts/write-rule.cjs` beside loaded installed `SKILL.md`; no checkout/project-relative/CLI assumption. +Writer: absolute `scripts/write-rule.cjs` beside the loaded installed `SKILL.md`. Assume no checkout, project-relative or CLI path. -JSON: category, slug, description, body; optional paths array, omitted for all files. Split comma globs; the writer refuses what else is invalid. +Request JSON: category, slug, description, body; optional paths array, omitted for all files. Split comma globs; the writer refuses anything else invalid. ```sh node "$installed_rule_script" --project "$project_root" --tools "$confirmed_ids" --input "$request_json" ``` -- Project: real absolute directory; tools: comma-separated confirmed IDs. -- Replace `--input "$request_json"` with `--publish`: all canonical sources, no identity argument; subset requests unsupported. -- Or `--delete category/slug`: one source, all recorded publications; reports `files`. -- Add `--plan` to any of the three: validates every refusal, writes nothing, reports `{"dryRun":true,"files":[...]}` with the exact paths a real run touches. -- Use `--check --publish` to verify: writes nothing, reports `{"drift":[...]}` and exits non-zero while any publication differs from its canonical source. -- Plugin: `plugins/<plugin>/rules/<category>/<slug>.md`; scoped YAML `paths` or no frontmatter. No writer, project metadata or host fan-out. -- Physical deduplication does not ensure unique host context; local 32 KiB passes do not ensure total instruction budget. +- Project: real absolute directory. Tools: comma-separated confirmed IDs. +- `--publish` replaces `--input`: all canonical sources, no identity argument, no subsets. +- `--delete category/slug` replaces `--input`: one source, all recorded publications; reports `files`. +- `--plan` on any of the three: runs every refusal, writes nothing, reports `{"dryRun":true,"files":[...]}` with the exact paths a real run touches. +- `--check --publish`: writes nothing, reports `{"drift":[...]}`, exits non-zero while a publication differs from its canonical source. +- Plugin: `plugins/<plugin>/rules/<category>/<slug>.md`; YAML `paths` for scope, or no frontmatter. No writer, project metadata or host fan-out. +- Physical deduplication does not ensure unique host context; local 32 KiB passes do not ensure the total instruction budget.